Bite of New York

The pizza is so greasy here that the cardboard takeout box ripped after awhile, but the owners are nice. Overall, after dabbing out the grease with a napkin, the pizza is delicious.

Always great food, love the wings! Owners are always there and very friendly. Has been a go to for great pizza and salads for years!

this place is awesome!!! there ranch is amazing, great customer service… and they actually remember your order :) i go here alot totally recommend it

Staying in Seattle for a week to see family and I was wondering where I could get a decent bite of New York pizza. This place is it!
Indulged in Caprese, Plain, and Hawaiian pizza and it stole a pizza my heart. The owners are very friendly, too! Definitely check this place out if you’re a local!

4 stars because they have great pizza and are family run. But I was just disappointed when I called to order a pizza and learned they no longer deliver. So, more inconvenient to enjoy their pizza.

Love this place! Delicious and with the absolutely nicest staff! Highly recommend!

Best pizza in Washington hands down. I come here at least once a week. The owners and staff are wonderful and very friendly. The food is amazing!
I’m from NJ and know what good sauce tastes like… This is it! Salads are always fresh and you never have to wait long for your order. I also highly recommend the philly and the hot Italian grinder! To die for…
The restaurant is always very clean with a warm friendly environment.
You won’t be disappointed!

I LOVE Bite of New York Pizza. Best place around Mukilteo for sure!

Definitely one of the better New York pizza shops I’ve had on this side of the country. Having been born and raised in New York, pizza is one of those things I’ve really missed since moving to the West Coast.
Bite of New York really did an excellent job with the cheese pizza, blending the cheese and sauce perfectly. My only recommendation would be to add a tad more salt and oregano to the sauce, but otherwise excellent.
Make the slice bigger so we can really fold it! Definitely coming back.

Do you love chicken wings?! These are the best I’ve ever had. Crispy amazing wings. We love this meat lovers pizza it’s so good. They also have good sandwiches. This locally owned Husband and Wife team is amazing.

We tried to go to Brooklyn Bros Pizza down the road and they told our group of 14 that they could not get us any pizza for over an hour even though the place was nearly empty. We call a Bite of New York that was closing and they re-​opened for us and served us four New York quality pizza’s. They were extremely pleasant and courteous and never attempted to rush us out even though it was way past their closing time. In summary, great food, fast service and courteous owners and staff.

Pretty decent slices and selection. I am from NY and have a pretty high standard for pizza — the crust being too bready is what usually what kills a slice for me. The crust was pretty thin and crunchy — pretty tasty.
They have a pretty good selections of subs, entrees, etc. Great place for lunch. It is pretty small but there are a decent number of tables. We went with about 6 people and had no trouble putting together some tables.

Good food, good service. I would recommend you check it out.

I ordered the mozzarella sticks and a pepperoni pizza. The mozzarella sticks are very good with great flavor and the marinara sauce is good too. The pizza though is on the disappointing side. There is very, very little pepperoni on the pizza. I think each slice has two, maybe three slices of pepperoni on it. Good size slices though and there is good flavor. I would go back to this place because they have more to offer than pizza.

I stopped in here for a quick lunch because there was no fast food really close. I’m glad I did! What a nice surprise! This place has a great menu from hot and cold grinders and sandwiches to salads to pizza by the slice. Oh and they have ice cream too. The people behind the counter are great.
I ordered the lunch special which was a choice of any 9″ cold sandwichwith chips and a drink for $ 7.99. They have another special with a slice, chips and a drink. I got the Italian cold sandwich. It was AWESOME! I’M DEFINITELY coming back.

Recently moved to Mukilteo and have been exploring the local cuisine. This place is almost invisible from the street, and it’s tucked into the corner of a small strip mall. I popped in for lunch and got a couple of slices to-​go. I got the spinach and ricotta, and the tomato basil. The crust was really good and the slices were really good. I asked the guy at the counter about delivery and he said they do, but only for the 98 275 zip code. Luckily, that includes me. Will be ordering from them in the future…

Best pizza I have tried in Washington. Outstanding customer service and cool setting. It is a bit pricey but it’s totally worth it. I personally recommend anyone who enjoys eating pizza and hanging out to stop by!

Making good pizza is hard. This place seems to try but is still not good, though it isn’t horrorable either. The sauce to cheese ratio was poor. Not enough cheese, the sauce was bland and abundent, the crust was bland and a bit tough. It was very greasy, more so then average I think. I likely won’t be coming back, atleast not for pizza (I haven’t tried their philly cheese steaks yet).
I will say service was fast and friendly. I would recommend this place for people with kids who don’t care to much about over all flavor because like I mentioned it wasn’t bad just not good enough to justify the price.

Amazing pizza! Makes my top 3 for sure!
They have amazing service and a true family owned little pizza shop! Actually eating it while I write this :)

If there was one kind of food that I could live off of for the rest of my life and (probably) never get tired of, it would be pizza. :)
My colleague and I recently ventured into Mukilteo and ordered an 18-​inch, meat-​lovers pizza here to share for lunch. We picked it up to go, and the service was friendly and prompt. I eyed some really tasty-​looking pepperoni sticks (breadsticks with melted cheese and pepperoni), and I promised myself that I would try those… next time. It was very cool to see one of the owners out on the floor tossing dough and making pizzas to order. The place smelled heavenly as food baked in the ovens.
The pizza itself is big — I think our 18-​inch was about 10 slices — although the crust is very thin. The meat toppings were generous although not large (think crumble instead of chunks), and I’d have to say that overall, it’s just okay. It’s not absolutely fabulous nor is it bad. It’s pizza that will «do» when you’re hungry. My colleague warmed some leftovers up the next day as his lunch, and he had no complaints.
I’m not sure I’d return to get pizza (as I am sure there are many other places in the area to get good pizza), but based on the photos and smells inside the establishment, I am eager to return to try some lasagna, pasta, or some of those saliva-​inducing pepperoni sticks. Om nom nom.