My review reflects not only the delicious piña colada cupcake we had but also the amazing customer service. Julie, the owner, made our daughter’s first birthday cake and hand delivered it after the major snowstorm this weekend, despite her car being snowed in. She almost got on the bus before a neighbor offered their vehicle. We are so happy to support her local business and encourage you to try them out!
Michael N.
Place rating: 5 Bloomfield, NJ
These cupcakes are really, really good. They taste completely homemade and they contain butter — that’s the main ingredient by which I judge pretty much all baked goods. In my opinion, if you don’t use butter, you don’t know what you’re doing. We had salted caramel, red velvet and carrot cake. We also got a pecan chocolate chip cookie. All top notch. Go.
Tamara S.
Place rating: 5 East Orange, NJ
I absolutely adore their cupcakes! They’re always so fresh. As soon as you bite into one of their cupcakes, you’re in heaven. The Obsession is amazing! I love the Caramel de Leche and the Strawberry Lemonade. Definitely the best bakery in Montclair. Cupcakes by Carousel does not compare. I am truly obsessed with this bakery
Alyana C.
Place rating: 1 City of Orange, NJ
This place is horrible… the cupcakes R so dry and hard. Just do us a favor and close down ASAP!!!
Jenine C.
Place rating: 5 Brooklyn, NY
I was in the neighborhood and stopped by for the grand opening because I was so happy to see a bakery in the neighborhood! I was pleasantly surprised to see this was a family owned business and the owner had her kids helping her behind the counter. I tried their champagne and strawberry cupcake and the red velvet with cheesecake frosting. The cheesecake frosting is AMAZING and there was actually fresh strawberries on the cupcake. Everything was delicious and I cannot wait to go back and try more flavors. Would definitely recommend for a snack or event.(Also loved their graffiti wall so I attached a pic)
Charis J.
Place rating: 5 Montclair, NJ
I walked by and couldn’t resist peaking my head in the store. I love cupcakes, but can never find the perfect cupcake. I ordered 6 different cupcakes. My family and I love them. They are moist, light and the frosting is not too sweet. They are absolutely delicious. I would highly recommend!
Ashley W.
Place rating: 5 Stone Mountain, GA
I had the pleasure of Cakeaholic’s Obsession preparing my wedding cake. I had a 3 tiered cake with a buttercream frosting. The top tier was red velvet, middle tier was chocolate and the bottom tier was vanilla. The owner was very welcoming, she provided a taste testing for my husband and myself to help us create our perfect day. She arrived to the venue early and prepared my dessert table. My cake was very moist and delicious. My guess really enjoyed the desserts. I would recommend her for any event.
Jasmine N.
Place rating: 2 Montclair, NJ
I stopped I’m about a week ago for a cupcake. It ordered the chocolate with sweet cream. It wasn’t bad, reminded me of something my mother would bake for my birthdays when j was younger. The only issue is for $ 3, I could have gotten a box mix cake that would have been the same. If you like Betty crocker and your too lazy to make it yourself this tastes eerily similar. I’m not saying they use box mix, buy you try it and tell me.