Vintage Pizzeria

single slice of vintage is huge and comes densely packed with a variety of meat and veggie toppings all cooked well. Interior is awesome though I’ve only ordered my slice by phone, picked up and left.

Called to order takeout and dude was pretty rude. We have eaten here before and liked the pizza but will never go back. They need a lesson in customer service.

If you work in the Alpharetta area and are wanting good American style pizza, this place is a great place.
It’s a little out of the way perhaps, but the pizza’s are huge! One slice is enough for most people.
The slices come out pipping hot, and their toppings are high quality. You can tell they do things a little differently and it’s not stuff straight out of a can or bag.

«Vintage Pizzeria, where 12 inches is small!»
If you were to ask me where the best place to get a slice for lunch in Alpharetta, Vintage is my number one pick. They are huge, thin, and perfect for the classic folding of a New York (or in this case NJ) slice. The interior is classy and casual. Service is a team effort and always great. Good selection of draft beer, and if you like cheap beer with your pizza, PBR served up cold as well. While the regular pizza is good in the evening, nothing beats the lunch pie slices. Miles to Jersey, minutes to Vintage!

This food is amazing! I ordered delivery so I could stay home and get some things done. I ordered mozzarella sticks, and Fettuccine Alfredo which came with a huge Cesar salad on the side! It’s a good thing that I planned on eating some for lunch tomorrow because I’ll still have leftovers after that! This was my first time and it won’t be my last! Everything is delicious and came quicker than they predicted. The delivery guy was very pleasant and personable. Great job, great first impression!

Really good place to either eat in or pick up your food. We do the lunch special occasionally which is salad and a huge slice. We love the salads, simple with right ingredients (cheese, red onion, tomatoes, and cucumber). Lettuce always fresh and served cold. I always get Vintage slice which is always good. My wife has had a variety over the years and all good. The chicken and eggplant parm are good, and so is lasagna and spaghetti with meat sauce. Good wait staff and good location.

We just moved to the area, so we have been trying out some of the restaurants as we’re in search of a place to make our ‘go-​to’ place. The atmosphere was nice. The staff was friendly, but not attentive. The food was so-​so, if even that. We had the wings, which were decent… nothing horrible, nothing wonderful. We also had the BBQ chicken pizza, which we didn’t like. There was something about the chicken that wasn’t good… I ended up picking off all my chicken. And the crust was pretty blah, in fact it tasted a bit undercooked. I would rather spend a few dollars more and go down the street to Crust. I don’t think we’ll be making this our go-​to place.

Great atmosphere! Loved the brick walls and lantern style lighting.
Had a simple lunch of a single sliced pizza and greek salad. My husband and I were able to eat for less than $ 15!

Running out of Guinness on Saint Paddy’s
is a sin!
Good thing the food is decent.
Good pizza, salads, subs.

We have been eating at Vintage since it opened, every Friday night and sometimes a Thursday for Trivia night. The food and staff are good. One Friday we decided to pick up our food. I called and ordered a large pizza, two salads and a childs chicken tender meal. I was told I could not order the childs chicken tender meal, I would have to order the full meal. I did not want the full meal, my 9 yo would not eat all of that, they did not care. That was the end of Vintage for me, I ordered nothing and called Crust Pizza and they were happy to carry out kids meals. I have not been back until this last Friday, basically out of convenience. Food and staff were good but the annoying family that eats there every Friday was there. You know the family that lets thier children run all over the restaurant with no shoes on and scream, play in the bathroom while a line forms outside. Well on this night we were about ready to have snow and the temps were holding at 30. These children were running in and out of the restaurant to play as if they were at home, parents just drinking wine with not a care in the world. Unfortunately our party was right by the door. I asked the owner if there was something she could do to stop this because we were cold and our food was getting cold. She turned and gave me a look of disgust. So there ends Vintage Pizza for us we will never return.

Good pizza place. Nice ambiance good staff and very casual. Pescetarians have s few good choices.

Not good service call for a delivery three pizza later no pepperoni call manager talk to waiter stills no pepperoni so we will never order from then again February 6

Awesome Eggplant Parmesan!!! Best I’ve had! My boyfriend got the meat lovers pizza and is was very delish! Garlic bread is wonderful. This is now our go to place.

My favorite restaurant in the crabapple area! I’ve tried almost everything on the menu and have yet to be disappointed. Service is always great, even when the place is packed! My favorite has to be the cheesesteak pizza and the shrimp appetizer.

4.25 stars.
We love Vintage Pizza. It’s our local pizza joint, kinda like a Cheers bar for the family.
Thursdays are Trivia Nights, and though we never stay for both rounds (approximately 2 hours, 7−9pm), we enjoy competing for the first half.
Meeka (sp) is a terrific host in the bar area, and her wide smile instantly makes you feel welcome.
Vintage has a full bar, but clearly the focus is on beer and wine with nightly specials on the former.
The pizza is very good. Very American. Not Dominos American, but not at all authentic Neopolitan. They mix up the toppings with some creative flair. My favorite is the cheesesteak pizza. Hey, I’m from Philly and this brings me back home.
They have an interesting twist on calamari. Vintage serves the little, breaded, deep fried squidley rings with deep fried jalapenos. Sounds good, and it is. It would be better with ¾ calamari ¼ jalapeño instead of the ⁵⁰⁄₅₀ mix.
Miss B. loves the Caesar Salad.
So go for the pizza. Stay for the friendly service, the cold drinks and the fun trivia. It’s the local place to hang out in Milton/​Crabapple area.

Tonight I went for our usual pizza treat, and while waiting at the bar to pick up our order, I stood there almost 10 minutes before I was acknowledged. Sunday evening, not very busy, perhaps understaffed, but still no excuse. MULTIPLE staff members walked past me more than once, and the bartender was off in a corner on her cell phone when I arrived. This is not the usual bartender (who is always super sweet, bubbly, and on her game), but someone I had perceived in the past to be a manager. I did notice that some of the time I was waiting, she was bringing drinks to another table and on the phone taking an order, but there were multiple opportunities for her to say, «I will be with you in just a minute,» or SOMETHING.
I recall working in a pizza place myself in high school, and my manager used to tell us that the customer on the phone takes priority over the customer in person, because the customer on the phone can’t SEE how busy you might be. But, he would say, you always make sure you apologize and assure your in-​person customer that they are important as well.
This was a surprising and disappointing experience. I think we will try another pizza option next time, and hopefully, if we do return to Vintage, customer service will have improved.

Really enjoyed our dinner. I had a huge «small» Greek salad with chicken. My husband had chicken Parmesan. My step daughter had lasagne and step son had a calzone. All loved their meals. Waitress was efficient and attentive. Atmosphere very cozy and tasteful. Highly recommended in the moron/​alpharetta area!

Nothing less than excellent!
Vintage serves a variety of cold beers, a full bar, awesome atmosphere, selection of pasta dishes and an as close as I’ve had in ATL to NY pizza. Excellent thin crust, cheese and sauce portions. My family and I order Vintage weekly!
Next time your in Milton, stop by for a slice or three. You will come back again and again.

Vintage… it is what it is. I was born and raised on the South Side of Chicago so the pizza style of Vintage is not really what I prefer. The atmosphere is pretty good, and the service is always decent, however I feel like they struggle when the crowd is larger.
The setting is nice. The inside has red brick walls and a nice looking yet small bar. The tables are a little close together but they are working with a small venue so they are trying to get as many tables in as possible. The only time this is an issue for me is when I go on a Friday night and the same family, that we now refer to as the Butt Family is there… for some reason they allow their off spring to run rough shot all over the restaurant while half of the adults stand at their table… in close quarters that means their butts are in someone’s faces at some point, every Friday night… AKA the Butt Family… however this is not the fault of Vintage.
The service is good most nights. Overall they are attentive and most nights there are no problems with refills, or ordering. I do feel that they tend to struggle a little when the crowd is larger. In Alpharetta, this can be any weekend night. However, their over all kindness wins me over.
The food is ok to pretty good. It is not spectacular. I would not think that anyone would crave this pizza. Their salad are very generous and quite good/​fresh. A side salad is as big as a large salad at some other restaurants. I tend to stick to the Carmine Pizza (like a Margarita Pizza) cooked extra crispy. It’s pretty good… I have had a large Grilled Chicken salad in the past also. It was good. Mostly Iceberg lettuce, and the other typical veggies of tomato, onion, etc… but still good. I think it could be great with the addition of a few different veggies… although not sure which veggies that could be.
Overall, I say 3 stars because, again, I am more of a Chicago style (thin and thick crust) pizza guy. Nice location, good service, ok pizza… but this is certainly a place to be on a Friday night if you live in Alpharetta. You will always see someone you know in there…

About the author: I eat lunch at Vintage Pizza once a week so if you’ve got a problem with something I say, you know where to find me.
This place is the best pizza in Alpharetta/​Milton. Whether you’re looking for a large pie to take home and watch the game, or if you want a slice or two for lunch.
Single slices are huge and they are reasonably priced. I challenge you to eat two slices in one sitting. Sausage and pepperoni is my favorite slice. The crust is thin but not too thin.
The service is great. Very very nice waitresses. They have a couple TVs so you can watch a game if you want and they also have a full bar.
If you’re in the area, definitely give it a shot for lunch or dinner.