Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs

Mesa, United States

4.1

Open now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 480-380-3185
Website:
www.papakelseysaz.com
Address:
9124 E Apache Trl, Mesa, AZ, 85207
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
No

Today

Today 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Open now
Local time (Mesa) 13:46 Friday, 13 June 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Thursday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Friday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Saturday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Sunday 11:30 am – 8:00 pm

Description

Specialties

Your neighborhood pizzeria since 1992, Papa Kelsey’s is family owned & operated. We take pride in preparing our fresh sub rolls & pizza crust, using only the finest ingredients. We strive to make each item we serve you the best you’ve ever tasted, and we guarantee it!

Related places

Explore similar places:
410
ft
Papakelseyes
9124 E Main St
1
mi
Pizza Hut
9333 East Apache Trail, Suite 101
1.2
mi
J&B’s Pizza, BBQ And Deli
9950 E Broadway Rd
1.3
mi
Rosati’s Pizza
1035 N Ellsworth Rd Ste C 104
1.8
mi
Hungry Howie’s Pizza
1116 S Crismon Rd Ste 101
2.1
mi
Sourdough Pizza Restaurant
7440 E Main St

Nearby

Near this location:
240
ft
Skeeter Tanning
9124 E Main St
240
ft
Los Favoritos
9124 E Main St
240
ft
The Batteries Depot
9124 E Main St
240
ft
Cannibal’s Pipes and More
9124 E Main St
240
ft
Lift and Stor Beds
9124 E Main St Ste 7
240
ft
Checker Auto Parts
9124 E Main Street Suite 17

20 reviews of Papa Kelsey’s Pizza & Subs

No registration required
Place rating: 4
San Buenaventura (Ventura), CA
This is a great restaurant if you go during the day when the owner is running the kitchen. Everything, from pizza to subs and chicken wings are amazingly good. 5 stars. However, the two times we’ve been there at night, it’s like a different restaurant. Especially the pizza and chicken wings. During the day the wings are crispy and so good. At night the skin is still soft and squishy, and for us that’s not so good. 3 stars at night, hence my 4 star average!
Place rating: 1
Boston, MA
Just called to order a pizza to try something new even after mixed reviews. Always go to sourdough pizza down the street which we love but wanted to try something different. I asked the guy on the phone if he had sliced sausage because my boyfriend prefers it, his response was no and as I was checking to see if that was okay with my boyfriend, I heard him say «yeah we don’t use that sliced crap». We were going to order a pizza anyway but after that response we changed our mind, would have liked to give this place a shot! Bummer!
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
Delicious food, fair prices and courteous customer service.
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
Love the veggie pizza! Great service… very friendly. Super prices and specials. Hubby loves the Hawaiian pizza.
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
This is definitely the best pizza place around. We haven’t tried the subs but the pizza is cooked perfectly and the wings are amazing! The also have great deals like a rewards program and on Tuesday buy one get one for $ 2. Quick delivery.
Place rating: 3
Mesa, AZ
Papa Kelsey’s is a little mom and pop pizza joint in a strip plaza along Main. The first unfortunate thing is that the plaza is fairly dead. A headshop, crappy Mexican place and an O’Reilly are all that keep this area afloat.
The interior is always clean and has vintage video games to keep you busy while you wait. I appreciate that they finally made a small waiting area for those ordering to-​go. I always felt bad sitting in a seat for those dining in.
The pizza is sub-​par in my opinion, but always made fresh to order. My choice here is the Turkey sub. My man always gets the Steak sub. And they buy cookies from a local baker, and they are to.die.for. splurge for the Macadamia nut cookies — soft and melt in your mouth.
The staff is always friendly, but sometimes get carried away with their own personal conversation and forget the folks waiting at the counter.
All in all, we will be back, just as we have many times before.
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
I always have a great experience here! Customer service rocks, emailed coupons are great and I never have a hard time using them. The food is wonderful! This is not your cheap fluffy bread filled pizza. Its Italian pizza! Thinner with great toppings and they actually use seasonings you can taste!!! If your just looking for bread with toppings then stick to frozen, Barros or little Caesars. If you want real pizza with actual flavor, then this is the place!
Place rating: 3
Apache Junction, AZ
Just average. Not much more to say. I had the meatball sub. First three bites were sauce and bread granted they were small bites. I was afraid to take big bites cause it was mushy and kind of exploded in my hands. Resorted to fork and knife, but I found the meatballs. My husband had the Italian and he said his was fine. Nothing to write home about.
Place rating: 5
Gilbert, AZ
It’s been a couple years since I tried this place, I loved it then and I still love it now. I don’t go here for the pizza, can’t say I’ve ever tried it, I go for the subs. The Cowboy is fantastic, but my loyalty is to the Club Sub. The family has branched out and tried other subs off the menu and not one complaint. I will continue to drive out of my way to get a sub.
Place rating: 4
Mesa, AZ
Love this place! My boyfriend and I get takeout from them at least once a week. The pizza and pasta is always fantastic. I love that they don’t have a ton of random items of their menu. Pizza, pasta, and sandwiches is the focus and they do them well!
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
I wanted to add to my review since I’ve now been able to try delivery. When I placed my order I was told there would be a half hour wait, but was surprised with a delivery that took less than 23 minutes from start to finish. Superb pizza and fast service.
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
The service was amazing and friendly. The place looks very clean and maintained. The food was great, the bread for the subs taste homemade, very soft and flaky. I had the pizza sub and spudsters. This place is definitely Canyon State Beard Club approved!
Place rating: 5
Apache Junction, AZ
This a perfect neighborhood restaurant with great sub’s and pizza. My favorite is the Taco Sub, it is a must have. Great for family’s and good weekly specials. Also fast delivery.
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
This place is so awesome! Has the family owned feel to the atmosphere. Their delivery driver Brittane is so nice and really fast. Cute too! I love to get their Honey BBQ Hot boneless wings with ranch. So delicious. The pizzas and subs are all amazing and they have new really delish chicken strips. Recommend this place! Way better than a Pizza Hut or a Papa Murphies. The owner, Andy, is awesome as well. He came out and checked to make sure everything to my satisfaction On point! KEEP IT UP PAPA KELSEYS! :)
Place rating: 4
Glendale, AZ
Good place to go for a pizza. The employees are great.
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
Papa Kelsey’s is fantastic! The oven toasted subs are easily one of the greatest things available on the menu. The pizza is great, and the buy one pizza get another for 99 cents on Tuesday is a fantastic deal that keeps me coming back! That deal doesn’t just apply to pizza either. On Saturday you can get a crazy large 12 inch calzone, and add another for 99 cents, and calzones are delicious too. Also, you can choose what goes inside them, which is very helpful when you have friends who are picky. The people who work there are funny and friendly, especially when you’re on the phone ordering for a delivery. I can’t wait for their online orders to start up, it’ll make ordering much more convenient.
Place rating: 5
Gilbert, AZ
Awesome sandwiches. The bread is the best!
Place rating: 1
Mesa, AZ
We have lived in this area for 4 years now and always wondered about this place. We stopped in and ordered a regular old sausage and onion pizza. We weren’t very impressed. Maybe we’ll go back and try a sub at some point but I wouldn’t recommend the pizza.
Place rating: 5
Superior, WI
Wow! Not a huge fan of the classic sub — I was totally blown away by Papa Kelsey’s Sub sandwich. Fresh bread and crisp vegetables compliment your choice of fixings! The staff is friendly and accommodating. We enjoyed our lunch in the nice clean café styled restaurant, but they offer take out as well as daily specials. YUM!
Place rating: 1
Mesa, AZ
Pizza is bad ! Bad bad bad! Never again! Don’t waste your time there are other great pizza places nearby!