Toppers Pizza

They started out actually, pretty good, even though they got our order wrong twice in a row. Now, I see the pizzas are very sloppily made, and the quality of ingredients seem subpar, or at least not properly stored or prepared. Got one pizza once and the pepperoni weren’t covered by a little cheese, like they literally put the pepperoni on top, and of course, after being in a 800 degree pizza oven, they were badly burned. Threw it away. Problem is, the pepperoni was sooo obviously badly burned, someone should’ve caught that before it went in the box, and into my hand.
*update (02÷07÷16)
Kind of wrote this place off after last time, but I had a $ 15 credit from the last time they got my order wrong. Kept it simple. Cheese & sausage pizza. That’s it. It was the worst pizza I have ever had! Cheese burned, to the point where it wasn’t «cheesy,» it was flaky. Ordered extra cheese, and I think «extra,» means «less» in this Topper world. I ate 2 pieces and threw it in the fire. Now I’ve had pizza from other Toppers, good pizza, especially for the money. This Topper’s used to be just as good as well, when they first opened. Really good, actually. This particular Topper’s, at this time, well with so many other pizza choices nearby, including frozen pizza choices, I wouldn’t bother. I’m done, I’ll revisit them in one year.

The employees are very helpful and the location is perfect. The pizza was excellent and the bacon sticks were to die for.

WHEN YOU CAN ACTUALLY ORDER ONLINE we will order it again. They say Google cannot find your address but when I Google my address it comes it comes up. There is a problem between Google maps and the main street location. The location «Louie» told me to call Google or coorperate. Why should I have to call??? This has been months. THEY need to fix their problem. We’ll try again in a few more months. In till then they aren’t getting another order from us. AND he was rude about it. All I did was try to bring in business. Screw you toppers.

Best Toppers location ever. Great staff and Amazing pizza… just like I remember from college, (UW-​Milwaukee offsite dorms location). I am not sure when they opened, but as soon as they did we started getting coupons in our household, so of course we have been going there often. Love this place! Yummmmmy!!!