Di Cillo Tavern

–small restaurant attached to bar-​bright lights, vinyl table tops, TV on wall
but the food is great and cheap
the pasta dish with clams or mussels is outstanding-​as good as Giovanni’s at a fraction of the cost
the French fries are the best I have tasted outside of France-​I believe that he first soaks them in ice water-​that way the outsides are crisp and the inside cooked but still moist
the fried fish and ground round are top notch
the chef Mr Tomorrow is outstanding

I had the Breakfast Burger and I loved it. You get so much food and a really small bill. The fish fry during lent is phenomenal and will explode off your plate it’s so big. New kitchen staff is much more friendly and consistent that past regimes. Hope they stay for a long time! Great local hangout.

The meat here is very good. The bar is amazing. This is the best bar in Mayfield, not saying much, but you know! The food is pretty good. This is one of the few places you can find real smoked meat on the east side. I had the smoked brisket sandwich. The meat was really good. Smoked percefectly, flavor, not bitter and not salty. The size of the sandwich had more to be desired. For 9 $ it was pretty small maybe 5oz max. For 9 $ it should be ginormous it was not! That is the only thing I orded, but it tired to get more but was denied. I went on a Friday afternoon for lunch. I was there before 2:30pm. Asked for another, it 2was slightly after 2:30pm. The kind server advised the chefs were at a catering event and did not know how to heat up the rest of the meat. So we were deinied. I really have to say this place has extreme potential. I just felt that the size of a 9 dollar samich should be larger than a big roast beef at Arbys. Qualtiy put this at 4 stars, value = 2 stars. Hence 3 stars. Next time I will get the rib and or the combo platter.

Great bar and restaurant!
Best fish fry onthe east side.
Great prices. Freiendly people. Make you feel welcome.
Restaurant under new (better) management.
Longest continuously running business in Mayfield (78 years and counting).