New York Pizza Express

Matthews, United States

3.7

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 704-821-2020
Website:
nypepizza.com
Address:
4520 Potter Rd, Matthews, NC, 28104
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Accepts Apple Pay
No
Accepts Bitcoin
No
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
No
Dogs Allowed
No
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Matthews) 00:52 Thursday, 29 May 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am – 10:00 pm
Sunday 1:00 pm – 9:00 pm

Description

Specialties

New York Pizza Express specializes in Pizza, Calzones, Stromboli, Pasta, Subs and so much more. We are a express delivery service or you can come in and pick up your order.

Related places

Explore similar places:
400
ft
Dunwright Grill
4432 Potter Rd
1
mi
Athens Pizza
2920 Old Monroe Rd
1.1
mi
Bisonte Pizza Co.
1381 Chestnut Ln
1.5
mi
New York Pizza & Pasta
624 Indian Trail Road S
1.6
mi
Hungry Howie’s Pizza
553 S Indian Trail
1.8
mi
Domino’s Pizza
3335 Siskey Pkwy

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
60
ft
Lucy’s Bakery & Deli
4522 Potters Rd
240
ft
Stallings Express
4540 Potters Rd
300
ft
Stallings Barber Shop
4516 Potters Rd
310
ft
Gold & Silver Mint
4512 Potter Rd
310
ft
All Moto Depot
4514 Potter Rd
310
ft
Family Hair Care
4514 Potters Rd

20 reviews of New York Pizza Express

No registration required
Place rating: 1
Hattiesburg, MS
I got 2 pizzas from here. They ripped me off. I paid over $ 20 for 2 large cheese pizzas. I seriously could’ve got better quality and quantity at little Caesars. The guy also lied to me when I asked for crushed red pepper and told me he had no more. I KNOW he lied to me. I hate establishment that don’t care about the customer experience and just want to rip you off. They don’t even have a restroom for customers! That tells me «give me your money and get the hell out we don’t care about accommodating» Crappy pizza place.
Place rating: 1
Matthews, NC
The last couple of times I’ve ordered from NY Pizza Express my food has been horrible. The pizza is very soggy and the salad is brown and mostly inedible. The workers are always nice but that doesn’t make up for the fact that the food quality is awful. I don’t know what’s changed in the last year or so but something definitely has. Prices have gone up and quality has gone down.
Place rating: 5
Saint Louis, MO
Love this place it’s always delicious. Delivery is always on time and PIZZA IS HOT!!! I’ve ate here for about a year and I love the price for the quality. It us the closest to new York style pizza in these parts.
Place rating: 4
Matthews, NC
My husbands go to for pizza delivery in the Matthews stallings area. We always get pepperoni and mushroom and it’s always quick, hot, and tasty.
Place rating: 4
Matthews, NC
Solid pizza for a great price. I wouldn’t exactly call it ny style but more so than others that make that claim. Fast delivery as well
Place rating: 2
Charlotte, NC
No thank you. I got a medium 3 topping and this pizza was very bland to me. from my first bite it was missing something… flavor. Service was ok. I could have made a better one on my own… or just went to papa johns. Won’t be going back.
Place rating: 4
Charlotte, NC
Is it the best pizza I’ve ever had — no. BUT it is, by far, the best pizza I can get delivered to my house in SE Charlotte. It’s nothing fancy, but the crust is very good, the sauce is decent, and the cheese and toppings are fresh. That is more than I can say for some of the more highly regarded pizza places in Charlotte. They deliver fast too. We had my daughter’s birthday party at Squirrel Lake Park and NY Pizza Express delivered a pile of pizzas piping hot and right on time. What more can you ask for?
Place rating: 4
Indian Trail, NC
Very good classic New York pizza. I would highly recommend it. If you want to get the best pizza possible make sure you order light sauce. They tend to over do the sauce sometimes but overall great pizza place.
Place rating: 4
Matthews, NC
Would have been 5 stars w/​better pricing BUT what KILLER PIZZA!!! I cannot put into words how good it was and I am mad at myself for living here for decades and just now discovering them! We will be ordering again!!!
Place rating: 4
Indian Trail, NC
Very good pizza! This is usually our «go to» for pizza when the kids aren’t around (they prefer Pizza hut). Pretty authentic NY Style pizza although a little bit on the pricey side.
Place rating: 4
Livonia, MI
Great place! Good pizza that tastes great and is very authentic! We had a mushroom and sausage and we were very impressed. You won’t be disappointed!
Place rating: 5
Harrisburg, NC
Best pizza I have ever had.
Place rating: 2
Charlotte, NC
I wasted nearly twenty bucks on the driest and most boring white pizza ever! The whole dinner was nothing but a downer. Plus the sample we got was way undercooked, after eating the first slice we decided to bake it for another five minutes.
Once reheated the crust wasn’t bad, not soggy or cardboard like but way thick for an alleged NY pizza. The topping unfortunately didn’t get any worse or better for it, it was as solid as it was bland.
The only reason I’m giving it two stars rather than just one is that I suspect their plain pizza is better than average for this forsaken area.
You’ve been warned: in Matthews-​Stallings 5 stars amounts to just average out on in the modern world, and 4 stars here translates to «it’s pretty much crap but we have no better».
Place rating: 4
Charlotte, NC
They do take out and delivery! The pizza is tastier than most delivery places. The 10″ is a good size for an individual pizza. The staff was a lot of fun to chat with and answered any questions we had. We will definitely be getting food from them again.
Place rating: 4
Matthews, NC
My family actually prefers this place to other pizza places in the area — or did before they stopped serving the onion rings! This place had some of the best onion rings, but mysteriously, they stopped serving them!
The pizza here is a lot like NJ/​NY pizza. Cheesy with a crisp/​bendy crust. The pizza really is very good. The mozzarella sticks are great also.
Please bring back the onion rings guys! The meatball and chicken parm. sandwiches are VERY good. Great bread too.(the meatball sub could use a few more meatballs but is still delicious)
We still love ya and will order from you often!
Place rating: 4
Nashville, TN
I was disappointed that they don’t have an online menu. Of course, after i had placed my order, I did some digging and found one on

I got delivery– they dont do individual slices, so I got the pepperoni mini pizza (8in.) and small side salad. That wasn’t even enough to fulfill the $ 10 minimum! $ 6 Say whaaaa? So I added breadsticks to make the order $ 12 including tax. Perfect portion for one person, slightly greasy, but it’s pizza, people! The breadsticks had this addictive garlic/​Parmesan butter mixture that I kept licking off the wax paper (hey! judgement-​free zone here!) and the marinara was thick and not too sweet. Luckily they delivered to my hotel relatively quickly– I felt like I was withering away in my (100 count sheets, I swear!) hotel bed with visions of mocking, dancing pepperoni swirling in my head…
I would recommend NY Pizza Express for a quick cheap bite. Next time I will try the calzone.
Place rating: 5
Waxhaw, NC
some of the best pizza we have had since moving to the area. very very good! highly recommend.
Place rating: 4
Stallings, NC
First time trying NY Pizza Express tonight, and I am very glad I did!
Found a menu online to have a look at prices, very reasonable, actually I was surprised at how cheap they were. We order 2 large pies, one just mozz, the other sausage & bacon, for delivery on a Saturday evening. They gave us a 30 – 40 min time estimate, and were in my driveway no more than 20 minutes later! Good friendly service both on the phone, and from the delivery driver.
Pizza was great, nice slightly chewy crust, thin, but not too thin. Good amount of sauce, and cheese tasted very fresh! It was really good. Super happy to have tried this place, now I just need to try their subs, calzones, and everything else!
Thanks NY Pizza Express!
Place rating: 4
Seattle, WA
These guys definitely know how to make a good pizza. The crust is the perfect blend of chewy with a hint of crunch, totally foldable and delicious! Not only do the make a good pie, they do it quickly, even when it’s busy, and get it to your door still hot and tasty. They’ve officially made it into my phone contact list!
Place rating: 4
Raleigh, NC
Take out — No dine in — Friendly staff — Very good Pizza, better than most! Fast, fast, fast service, great quality, great taste! Ate here (in there parking lot) Sunday night!
I’m almost sure the Cheese they use is 100% Mozzarella (instead of a blend) I am a Fan of this Pizza with EASE! If they were located closer to me I would be getting more Pizza from them vs Fuel!