Ordered food on grub hub at 8:09pm at 9:15pm I called and asked where food was. Meanwhile me and my husband are watching out the window the entire time waiting for our food. Person at location said it was on way that was okay I figured it was busy possibly on a Sunday night. It’s 9:49pm and I got a call from grub hub that the delivery driver lost the order. Grub hub said that they would either refund me the order or re-send the order and it would take another hour. I requested the refund for the fact it wouldn’t be here till 11pm on a SUNDAYNIGHT. It shouldn’t take 3 hours to drive 1.4 miles from location to my house for a cheesesteak and a salad. We’re really hungry and this was our dinner. If you want missing orders and unpunctual drivers and staff this is the best place to go. They couldn’t even physically call my cell phone to explain the issue. Never again.
Kevin C.
Place rating: 1 Matawan, NJ
This was some time ago but it needs to be made known. My sister used to live in the condo complex across the street from this place and when I would visit we would often get pizza from this place, being that it was so close. Every single time we got pizza from here the crust was black and charred. By the third time this happened I decided to tell them not to burn when I ordered it. When I picked the pizza up the crust was again, charred. When i told them this they seemed to get insulted, but I was so upset I just walked out. Will never be returning to this place, much rather go to Enzo’s which is a little bit further but far superior quality.
Peter L.
Place rating: 5 Morganville, NJ
Very good pizza. Owner uses high quality ingredients. Highly recommend the grandma pie … it is delicious.
Gene L.
Place rating: 1 Homestead, FL
Cavitelli and Meat is foul. Felt like it was poured out of a can asked for side extra sauce was old and cold. My wife had Veal Piccata very sour capers gross. Bread is great Sausage Calzone dough undercooked. This place is good for Pizza and always ask for it to be cooked well or you will have slop.
Robert C.
Place rating: 4 Middletown, NJ
Went here with my father and sister for dinner after hearing good things from my father’s friends. I am very happy to say that my father(a very picky critic when it comes to Italian food) was very pleased with his dinner. He and I both had lasagna. Very large portion and very good, although the layer of mozzarella on the top was a bit too much. My sister was pleased with her meal as well. Definitely plan on going back.
Michael S.
Place rating: 4 Matawan, NJ
This is my go-to local pizza place. I’ve tried a few in the area but always end up back at Scotto’s. I do agree with the other reviewers that it’s a bit pricey. and I don’t like how they got rid of their free pizza with 10 coupons deal. I’ve also had their cold subs, which are fantastic. Highly recommend.
Patricia R.
Place rating: 3 Matawan, NJ
A great vodka pie, a bit pricey though. I think it’s almost $ 20 bucks but it has great fresh mozzarella.