Three Fellas Pizza & Market

Absolute best pizza I’ve ever had. Beats out any pizza in the area. Tons of creative slice options with an extensive menu for other goods. #1 choice for pizza.

Slices are good, large and relatively cheap. Meatball/​sausage/​chicken parm grinder is pretty good too. Salads are alright– not really anything fantastic (I prefer house made dressing and they have packets of newmans). Oddly, their whole pies are underdone and kind of cardboard-​y and can be expensive. Also– many menu items on the website are out of date and they don’t have them… Tried to order different Panini and such and they didn’t know what I was talking about. Rossinis in east Hampton is much better for whole pies– but slices here will do when I’m looking for something fast.

Food is amazing and I love it here. Usually buy the buffalo pizzas from here. Only downsides (why it’s 4 stars instead of 5) are that they’re overpriced and that their pizzas are quite thin. However, that doesn’t mean they’re any less delicious!!! I’ll continue to be their customer as long as they keep up this great quality.

Good pizza and fast delivery! Crust was thin and pie was well done… just as I ordered

Authentic New York style brick oven pizza in small town Marlborough. Love the pizza and convenience. I think they deliver too!

I eat this pizza all the time and love it. However recently they upped their prices on everything and most of it, isn’t worth it! If you are going for a slice it’s not too bad– but anything else seems expensive.

Great great great addition to the area. You just don’t get good pizza like this unless you really want to drive somewhere, ever since they’ve opened I have loved coming here. The team is extremely friendly, very quick, and make both awesome pizzas and other dishes. The one thing is though when you walk in there is somewhat of a walk to the back of the restaurant where you order and you get stared down by the staff until you make it to the counter and I never know if I should be the first to yell from when I first walk in and say «hey! I’m here for pizza, how the heck are ya!» or do I let them make the first move and say hi… My favorites are cheese and the buffalo chicken, if you are in the mood for some za, stop in here, it’s thin crust, chewy and delicious… and it gets messy sometimes so be prepared… I’m often too excited to take my time and grease and cheese droppings always end up scalding my chin or making a mess of my shirt, I just laugh and say… «oh meeee hehe». Anyway, I digress.
Great job… Fellas!
How come I only see the one same fella when I go in? Where are the other two fellas?

By far the best pizza restaurant in Marlborough, (believe it or not there are 2 others). It’s a nice, lively place in town with a good selection of pizza and some other menu options which some may find overpriced, but I find the quality is worth it. The atmosphere is young and hip, and is always bustling around dinnertime. Staff is dedicated and pleasant.

Great pizza, great prices and among the best in the area

Enjoyed our pizza. Ricotta and meatball and chicken broccoli the meatballs are delicious. Sliced thin on pizza. Broccoli was disappointing. It was the frozen stuff. Really needed fresh. We will be back

Pizza is good, but the prices are just way too high. Other items on the menu are not worth the try for the $$$$ pricing.

damn good ny style pizza, only missing the hand sliced/​thrown mozz and basil leaves/​oil

Always grab a slice for lunch here. Love the thin crust.
Their meatball eggplant and ricotta pizza is THE BOMB!!!
Very nice people great service and the pizza is DELICIOUS!
They deliver also I just found out to east hampton can it get any better. Enjoy a slice you will sure to be back !!

Went in to grab a quick slice of pizza, great service and great prices. BBQ chicken pizza was delicious, chicken bacon ranch to top it off… And gotta love me some Stewart’s soda

The food is good and it is nice to have a place in town that delivers… but $ 23.00 for a small gluten free pizza is just ridiculous!

This place has damn good pizza. I put these guys in third place all time behind a joint in Boston’s north end and El Presidente in Naples. That’s how good I think they are.

This place is DEFINITELY a diamond in the rough. Very unassuming, and quite honestly I’d have no idea it existed if it weren’t for Unilocal.
Rolled in for lunch one day, and was delighted to find some of the best pizza in the area! True New York style packed with flavor and quality ingredients. After one visit I’m already hooked, and this will probably become my new ‘go to’ take out option. Highly recommend checking it out if you’re in the area!
* It should be noted that this is very much a take out-​only kind of establishment. There are a few bar stools lined up along the wall, but you certainly can’t come here expecting a traditional sit down meal. Nothing wrong with this at all … just know what you’re getting into.

My parents moved to Hebron four years ago and this is by far the best pizza joint I have encountered in the area. Every time I am over and we want take out, I recommend this place. Their grinders are delicious too. The restaurant is clean with great chip and soda options as well.
They deliver, make a great pie, and are reasonably priced making this place the best option in the area!

Great job guys!!! Food is great. Pizza is great! Delivery is great! You all are doing a great job making three fellas number one!!!

I have no idea where I was, but I came across the Three Fellas and took a chance on their pizza. It was a bit past lunch time and the slice selection was on the low side, so i got one cheese and one with fresh tomatoes and some other typical things. I got the slices to go, they reheated it in about 20 seconds and it was warm but not hot which was OK because I was hungry. The oil started seeping through the bag before i got to my car (which is a good sign maybe if you are a fan of oil). The slightly crispy thing slices weren’t really all that oily, as i ate them the oil wasn’t running down my arm or dripping on me. Overall they were decent reheated slices — makes me want to go back and order a whole fresh pie one day maybe. The one thing that I thought was weird was the «& Market» part of Three Fellas. so it’s a few shelves with Italian groceries like peppers and olives. The fridge had some decent looking cake (i wonder if they bake it themselves?)
I have no idea what other pizza around here is like, but this one was worthwhile.