the people who work here are miserable most of the time! they must really hate working here as they all have miserable customer service! Ive been in here a couple times over the past few weeks and they treat the new cashier like an idiot and talk down to her! The food is average and thus today is my last time eating from here!
Mia F.
Place rating: 1 Mansfield, MA
I wish I was able to give them no stars. This place was filthy it looks like they never cleaned it. It was super tiny probably couldn’t even sit 15 people. If I were you I just go somewhere that is well known for good food especially pizza. I was hungry and that was the closest place to go. I went in and the people were very rude and the pizza was not good at all. After that first experience I knew that I was never going there again.
Warren H.
Place rating: 3 Norton, MA
We had their pizza last night for the 1st. time and thought it was just OK. The crust was chewy which we really liked, but it didn’t have much flavor. The sauce was kinda bland. Nothing distinctive about the taste. To me it resembled the pizza sauce you buy in the supermarket in a jar. The toppings and cheese were good.
Samantha L.
Place rating: 5 Mansfield, MA
The only place we order from!!! Best food around!!! They never mess up our orders(as complicated as they can be!) The service is incredible, employee’s are so friendly and always happy and kind to every customer that comes in! We love this place! Food is always fresh and delicious!!! Always clean inside and out, ALWAYS!!! When they tell you a time your food will be ready for pick up, they’re always right on, the food is always ready at the time they say it will be!!! Our favorite place around! We’ll never order from anywhere else again!!! I give this place 100 stars! Congratulations on being the one pizza place around that actually knows what they’re doing and knows how please customers so they keep coming back every single time!!! Keep up the perfect service guys!!!
Jen C.
Place rating: 4 Mansfield, MA
Stefanos is the best pizza in mansfield! However, the reason I am giving 4 stars instead of 5 is that there have been times I have asked for certain things, like the pizza extra crispy and they haven’t done that. I order from them all the time, just wish that they would follow what I ask.
Michelle D.
Place rating: 5 Malden, MA
Yay!!! My husband and I have FINALLY found a great pizza place in the Foxboro/Mansfield area. Delish!!!
Rebecca A.
Place rating: 5 Taunton, MA
It’s really easy to be like the run of the mill pizza parlors that serve up the basic frozen crust, canned sauce, and greasy rubbery flavorless cheese. I found this place while searching on Unilocal.I’m from a few towns over and there isn’t much to be desired for pizza in my surrounding areas. I was willing to travel a few towns over to try out this place. I placed a pick up order for 1 extra cheese and 1 pepperoni large pizza. When I brought it home I was surprised it was still warm which was a plus. The crust is like the hand tossed crust that my family used to make. The sauce had just enough spice and the cheese was flavorful and tasty. I was very pleased with overall taste and flavor. I will definately gonna be making the trip out again soon.
Ash K.
Place rating: 5 Boston, MA
Been eating pizza here for years. Best sauce by far – it’s what makes it. No place else in Mansfield can compete. Family owned and operated(also friends). They donate regularly to Mansfield High, local charity events, and the community. Go in a few times and they’ll remember your name and order.
Gail M.
Place rating: 5 Mansfield, MA
We order from Stefano’s almost every weekend. Always consistently good food. Delivery always within the time frame they give.
John X.
Place rating: 4 Mansfield, MA
There pizza is always good. Crisp crust nice sauce and cheese. I also get toasted Italian suns and chicken fingers here. Best around
Vanessa M.
Place rating: 5 East Providence, RI
Stopped here before going furniture shopping with teh boyfriend. I ordered a small veggie pizza and he got buffalo chicken tenders. Both were awesome!!! My veggie pizza was awesome. The crust was just right, it wasn’t doused in sauce, and my veggies weren’t burnt or totally soggy. The flavor combos on it were a hit for me! His buffalo chicken tenders were perfect! Crunchy on the outside, tender and juicy in the middle, and had the right amount of sauce. He said the fries were just ok… but that he was so distracted by the awesome-tasticness of the buffalo chicken tenders that the fries were just an after-thought anyway. I would definitely eat here again :)
Joshua K.
Place rating: 4 Plainville, MA
I work walking distance from Stefano’s and normally have a limited amount of time to grab lunch, so I find myself here a lot. Luckily, there’s a lot of variety on the menu so I don’t eat just pizza every day. I mean, I love pizza(my fiancé’ jokes that I’m going to have a pizza carved into my headstone when die), but I still need some variety. The slices are good and you can’t go wrong with a meatball sub, toasted of course. Even the burgers here are good and, from time to time, I even get a nice grilled chicken caesar salad. The service is always friendly, but I may be a bit biased since they all seem to know me now.
Abhinav S.
Place rating: 4 Norwell, MA
Great pizzas! Try the pepperoni pizza, its good; and all of that at a reasonable price. Subs were not that great though.
Laurie R.
Place rating: 3 Mansfield, MA
My whole family loves the pizza here. The other menu items can be ok. Unfortunately, after last night, we will probably not return here. We ordered food to pick up and were told 20 minutes. My husband went to pick it up and upon arriving was told that they had never written a ticket for our order! The attitude of the staff was uncaring at best. For our aggravation, we were given a discount of $ 6. You have to be kidding! This was not during a busy time. This was later at night. I would encourage this pizza place to find a new way to take orders and definately to train their staff to be kind and caring to their customers, Especially the home town customers that have been going there since they opened!
Mike D.
Place rating: 4 ATTLEBORO FLS, MA
About as good as it gets around here unless you want to drive to Casertas in Providence or The Town Spa in Stoughton.
Krissy W.
Place rating: 3 Mansfield, MA
I think out of all the pizza shops in town, they have the best prices. The food is good, especially the meatballs! Great location, friendly people working there. Never had a bad experience when ordering their food.
MICHAEL W.
Place rating: 3 Mansfield, MA
I live nearby and the have been here a few times and the food is just… ok. It’s basic pizza, what you’d expect but nothing more. To be fair, I have not tried the subs, but pizza is my choice 90% of the time when I go to a pizza place. I’ll go again in the future, but I find that I head to Magic Pizza whenever I’m in the mood.
Kaitlyn B.
Place rating: 5 Quincy, MA
Just informed that Stephano’s accepts payment by credit card now!
M L.
Place rating: 4 Norfolk County, MA
I like the pizza here a lot, but the subs and salads are just OK. Cash only business but since you can get a small cheese for only 5 bucks who cares.
Sean R.
Place rating: 4 Thompson's Station, TN
We ordered from Stefano’s because the chain pizza places in the area are terrible. You won’t find chains like Papa John’s or even Pizza Hut in the area, so you’re stuck with Papa Gino’s or Domino’s. Personally, I’ll only eat Papa John’s of the big 4 chains, and I really don’t even like that. Stefano’s, like Sal’s and Mal’s, represent the ma and pa type of pizza places in Mansfield. Their pizza is better than the chains and the value is off the charts in comparison. I will be trying some subs from Stefano’s soon because I have been largely focused on the great pizza.