Andrea’s 25 North

Very good service. The servers and managers are very friendly. The restaurant has several levels which makes each level more intimate. Instead of having sports on the large TV’s by the bars they had a fireplace video playing. My wife, kids and I all thought the fireplace video was quite enjoyable… or mesmerizing according to my kids. Excellent, warm, crusty, doughy bread served before the meal… we had two baskets. My wife had a shrimp dish which she thought was excellent. My kids had the standard pasta off of the kids menu. My Chicken Milanese was terrific. I won’t even need a menu next time because I’ll be getting the Chicken Milanese every time. My only suggestion is to do something with the entry. You walk into a large room with a bar on one side. This room needs some definition. Maybe a half wall in the middle of the room that separates the bar area and kind of directs you towards the restaurant entrance to the right and up the stairs.

Excellent food and service. Went for a birthday dinner and had the Veal Venti Cinque with Luciano sauce cherry peppers over a bed of sauteed spinach-​Delicious!
It was a Monday and all their wine bottles are half off on Monday. This place gets packed so call for reservations.

I can always count on this place to make it good! There is a big and diverse menu and are great for kids. On Sundays, (I think) for kids they do create your own ice cream! There’s beautiful art here and multiple floors of seating. There is wine on the walls… Very tempting for kids… Just kidding.

This is the best restaurant I have ever been to. The food is always out of this world and the service is extraordinary.

Their food is amazing! The owner is superb! Food was fresh and delivery came fast. Owner delivered himself!

My first time there tonight and I was so impressed. Amazing food, wine and service. Going back this Saturday… Loved it

Andrea’s 25 North is where you go when you want to have a fantastic evening! The gentlemen that run it are top of the line! The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is amazing, the décor is gorgeous and the food is incredible. I’ve been there many times and it is consistently a memorable experience! I’m so glad they came to Mamaroneck!

A little pricey, but one of the best meals I can remember. Shrimp appetizer on toast was scrumptious and satisfying. The veal chop was out of this world. Polite and super attentive service, and a good vibe between all diners and staff.

1^st time there tonite Not bad food & service were decent Surf & turf cooked very nicely There was a lil wait to be expected on a Saturday nite with no reservations had a few drinks at the bar within a hour I was seated. To me its a lil pricey but the dishes are a good size. Would I go back ?? Maybe but not rushing it

We went here based on all the great reviews. We were there pretty early on a Saturday evening and they were already packed. The service wasn’t great and the food was just fine — but nothing memorable.

Hands down Andrea’s 25 North is my favorite restaurant in Westchester. Not just my favorite Italian– my favorite restaurant period! The experience from start to finish is perfect every time. You always get a warm greeting from either owner Will or manager Carmine. If you get there early there’s a bar on the 1^st and top floor (dining tables are only on the 2^nd and 3^rd floors). While all the waitstaff are friendly and efficient I always ask for one of my 2 favorites– John or Cisco. John’s passion and enthusiasm is intoxicating. Weekend nights a reservation is highly recommended. Self parking is nearly impossible but they have valet parking every night.
After being seated a basket of very warm, fresh crusty bread is brought out with a saucer of bread crumbs and spices to be mixed and blended with olive oil. To start my favorite antipasti are the baked clams with their «Luciano» sauce, broccoli rabe & sausage egg rolls and fried calamari with arrabiata sauce. Their salads are delicious and large enough to be shared– my favorite is their baby arugula salad.
For the main course I’ve only had 2 pasta dishes. Their meatballs and sausage dish is very, very good– meatballs so big that even Fred Flintstone would blush! While that dish is very good Sal’s Mac & Cheese steals the show. My girlfriend Tricia is addicted to it and gets it almost every time. This is no ordinary Mac & Cheese! I won’t even try to describe it other than saying it blows away anything else you’ve ever had that calls itself Mac & Cheese– not sure if I should call it heavenly or sinful.
My favorite meat dish is Veal Venti Cinque. The veal is super tender– no knife necessary. It comes with their scrumptious Luciano sauce and cherry peppers over a very generous bed of sautéed spinach. While not super hot this dish is spicier than most but I’m sure they would hold the cherry peppers if you’re not into spicy foods.
Their fish specials are excellent– my favorite is their red snapper. If they have it don’t miss it. I almost forgot their sides. Try their burnt broccoli or burnt string beans. It may sound unusual but it truly tastes amazing!
If you’re not already stuffed their desserts are off the charts good and all are made in house. My 2 favorites are their Oreo Stuffed Zeppolis (why didn’t someone think of that years ago!!!) and their Napolean. If you want something lighter they have excellent biscotti served warm on a plate with a generous scoop of cannoli cream in the center for dipping.
Trust me– go once and you’ll never want to go anywhere else!

Excellent food and service! We ate here for dinner on New Year’s Eve and we were very impressed. We will definitely be back to try them again on a regular night. Lobster ravioli and biscotti fresh from the oven were amazing.

Found an amazing restaurant last night! Beautifully decorated and nice ambiance! A tad slow on service but the food was off the flavor charts! I had lobster raviolis in a vodka sauce with tons of lobster meat in the raviolis and in the sauce! The salmon Dijon was so tender and delicious, the special appetizer was just that, delicious soft Burrata mozzarella, prosciutto and cherry tomatoes! The meatballs were gigantic and savory! I would definitely recommend this restaurant, but you def need reservations on the weekends because this place is bopping!

Have to say I live near this place and was excited to try it. Wass unfortunately sorely disappointed (have to wonder if friends of owners are writing the reviews). Ordered salmon and center was cold and clammy;obviously they did not defrost/​cook it enough. Was enough to turn me off for life. Yuck.

The review of A.S. Is racist to Italians. Would you say the n word to an African American. I don’t think so. Why is it ok to call someone a Guido.

The food is delicious! Something’s they need to work on are as follows. 1. Most of there dishes are drowning in sauce and lacking in actual food. I ordered the Stuffed Rigatoni in Vodka sauce (which I highly recommend) and it was drowning in sauce and barely had any pasta. Someone else in my family ordered pasta with olive oil, there was about an inch of oil at the bottom the bowl and it was unbearable 2. There chopped salad was basically chopped iceberg lettuce and tomatoes that’s it, nothing special. Overall the restraunt was excellent and I highly recommend that you visit.

In response to other negative reviews I respond: the food is almost always perfect. However, if something is too saucy, etc, tell them. They apologize and get you something else with a smile.
My husband, friends and I eat here regularly. The owners are always on site and very eager to ensure a wonderful dining experience. Each time I go I try something different. The fish dishes have been delicious, recently I had stuffed sole with spinach over risotto. They honor special requests, the place is immaculate and the ambience is fancy without being uptight.
Food is very good and service excellent.

Delicious, reliable, inventive Italian dining.
Andrea’s 25 North provides an all-​around great dining experience. The menu features traditional Italian dishes, while also offering a lighter fare menu for the calorie conscious.
I tried the zucchini marinara, which features julienned zucchini strands topped with a delicious marinara sauce. It was great.
The menu is diverse, the drinks are delicious and the atmosphere is elegant yet comfortable and warm. Give Andrea’s a try!

I am so glad I got the recommendation to come here. The service is incredible, you will feel like a regular the first time. The food is a 10 and I will make this my goto spot. Go now you will be pleased. I am afraid it will be the new raos in Westchester and I won’t be able to get in pretty soon …
Awesome job

Fabulous food. Best vodka sauce I have ever had. My husband loved the chicken scarpiello. Chicken picante was very good as well. Will have to come back and try other dishes. Highly recommend.