Red Pepperoni

They had lots of choices on the menu and we decided to order the chicken wings and cheese bread. The chicken is bone-​in and large pieces and very reasonably priced. It came out steaming hot and they let us have a ranch and blue cheese for dips. All the food was tasty and hot. Also, they have a very extensive list of beers. The service was very friendly and the food came to us in a reasonable amount of time.

Tim and I live right next-​door to the Red Pepperoni, so we like to consider ourselves experts. We love their pizza, appetizers, and their beer selection. We are sad that they don’t offer 6-​packs-​to-​go, but we’ve never had a bad experience here.
I love trying a new beer each time we come in because their selection is so vast! And always served with a nicely chilled glass.

Great drinks, great vibe, great staff, and great food. Would recommend to anyone looking for a great place to eat.

Always a «must have «when friends and family are in town. The calzones are more than i can eat.

This was the first time that I had eaten here. The staff was very friendly and helpful. I ordered the Teriyaki chicken Pizza and it was good. I would’ve liked the crust to have been alittle thicker and the chicken chunks were just a bit big for a topping. But I may probably visit here again.

Friendly staff, really solid pizza, and a fantastic selection of beers. I’ll be back!

The beer selection is very respectable but I didn’t get a chance to evaluate it based on price. The menu is fairly diverse with several different kinds of specialty pizzas, salads, calzones and other items. The dining room was clean the staff was attentive and polite. The foot, itself, was alright though I felt the crust was a little on the thin side but that’s more of a matter of preference. My wife tried the french fry pizza while I opted for the buffalo chicken and the kids had plain cheese. The french fry pizza was a little underwhelming, cheese was on par and I thought that the buffalo was pretty good but a little on the mild side. The breadsticks were large, puffy and delicious.

Great pizza. Lots of choices in toppings and good service. Try the Hawaiian pizza or the artichoke.

I could have given it five stars, and maybe I should have. Inside didn’t look really great, but we had such a nice outside table experience. The White pizza was rich and flavorful. Really nice selection of beers too.
Our waiter, David, was very helpful and friendly.

Great lil find while in Madison for a high school football game. Pizza had excellent flavor. Wings were great. Everything, from the dough to the salad dressings, all had a fresh homemade and unique taste! Service was quick and attentive. We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in the area.

Great beer selection and the pizza was so tasty. The beer list is 3 pages typed front and back and is also beautifully displayed on a chalkboard at the entrance. I ordered the Noble Order Tobias Apricot IPA. Unfortunately I received the Original Sin Apricot Cider. Not at all the same thing, but I liked it fine once I adjusted to having a cider, and I didn’t mention the mix up to our very busy waitress. My boyfriend ordered a New Albanian Hoptimus IPA, which came out in a 22 oz. bomber bottle, which was a surprise (but a good one.)
The toasted ravioli were tasty, six to an order and a perfect start. The small RPD pizza (minus green peppers) was the perfect amount. Without the ravioli we’d have eaten the whole thing!
I ordered a diet Pepsi when we ordered the pizza and literally I received the straw when we got the bill! I didn’t get the Pepsi until we asked for the check and I asked for it to go! The poor waitresses here are stretched to the MAX. but they’re so friendly. Definitely a great choice in Madison.

The students at the middle school were raving about this place so I decided to check it out. Definitely worth the trip. I had the white pizza — so good and breadsticks /​so good and a hard cider. They have an impressive beer menu featuring a large selection of Indiana beer. The breadsticks are definitely worth mentioning twice because they weren’t at all greasy. Nice and crunchy on the outside and light and fluffy inside. Not high cuisine but excellent for a pizza joint. The best part — the prices are super reasonable! I would definitely eat here again!

Great fresh made pizza and sides along side the best craft beer selection in Madison. The atmosphere sets the whole dining experience off perfectly. Servers are always prompt and friendly.

I’m surprised no one has mentioned the lasagna! 2 words… Life changing. It is the only place we order lasagna at. The RPD pizza is also delicious. The waitresses are always friendly, and the place is clean. This is one of our «go to» establishments in Madison.

This place is small. Went on a Thursday and it was pretty packed so I’m assuming Fri, Sat will be more so. So be prepared to wait on table… but it’s worth the wait!
The interior is kitschy with beer signs, neon lights, etc. Speaking of beer, WHOA! They have an enormously extensive beer list. They have a lot written on a chalk board but it’s hard to read. They also have a beer bible that tells what they have. I was satisfied with this Peach beer. It didn’t taste like peaches but it was a good beer nonetheless.
On to the pizza… got the artichoke pizza and added chicken. It was delicious! The crust wasn’t too thin or too thick. The sauce was really creamy and satisfying. If you are to order this pizza, stick with a personal pan or a small. To me, the cream is so rich I couldn’t eat more than two or three slices of it.
The waitstaff was really on it too. Our waitress was very pleasant and it seemed most of the staff were local school kids. But they all seemed great and did their jobs well.
Give this place a try!
The End.

Nothing better than a small business with a great product! Awesome sauce and crust! I look forward to enjoying again!

Holy beer selection! They had a ton of great Micro-​Brews that I have never heard of. There was local stuff and other big name stuff as well!
I went here on a lacrosse trip to Hanover College that I was coaching. We stopped here to get some pasta for the team. The manager that was working was awesome. He was very accommodating on our take out menu and cut us a deal since we were spending close to $ 400 for 32 people.
The pasta and the sauce was very good and all of the players were huge fans! The meat balls were larger than normal size which was nice.
If you are in the area, check it out. Very quaint and family focused place.

Try the Sicilian. It will change your life. These people love what they do and are passionate about great food and excellent service. I’ve been twice to sit down and about ten times for delivery and am always impressed. Salads and breadsticks are awesome too.

I drive here about once a month during the summer. I love they have personal size pies and always hey great service.

This place is AMAZING! Service is always awesome and food is great! My fave is the spinach artichoke dip. Does anyone have this recipe? I have googled the hell out of it with no luck. I am dying to make it for my friends and family!