Jeremiah’s Italian Ice

Started going to this location after the original Maitland location closed down and it was also closer to my house. I do love but they have a drive-​thru window I just hate that the line is slow. My favorite Italian ice is the cookie butter … And I’m glad they kept it on the menu! This is the only one I’ve been to that has a drive-​thru, price same as others which is reasonable. I still miss the original Maitland location which is what started me going to Jeremiah’s in the first place. Not too many complaints.

First time ever going today. I have passed by Jeremiah’s a few times in the past and its always busy. I decided to try it today, even though i am not a huge ice cream fan. I was unsure what Gelato was, but I got a small mango one. After I was on my way, i was wishing I had gotten a large! I will defiantly be back! It was amazing! I even snap chatted it. It was so delicious!

My daughter & I went for the first time today after living in Orlando for a year now. I wish we would have tried it last summer.
It was the best ice cream/​gelato we’ve ever had. I got a small to share with my husband. I didn’t want to share it once I got it, but I did of course.
The salted caramel was SO GOOD! We will definitely be back for more.
I sent my mom a picture & told her if she passed one on her road trip to make sure they stopped, then I realized they were only in Orlando. I know they will do well the more they expand!

If you’re ever craving ice cream and need a quick fix, this is the spot! I usually grab something through drive thru since they dont have much of a seating area and if its really hot FL weather best to just grab and go. I usually get a gelati, tried about most of their flavors (strawberry, pomegranate, watermelon, lemon, chocolate) they all taste great!

Amazing Ice cream and excellent service.
Was visiting Florida and had to drive 45 minutes the next day just to get to one for my kids.

P-​nutty and chocolate.
Caffe latte with chocolate.
Chocolate with chocolate.
I could go on. For a while.
This place is heaven for a chocolate lover like myself. Or just any ice cream lover. I never liked Italian ice before because I’d only tried lemon before I found Jeremiah’s. Their gelati’s are amazing!

What’s better than a nice gelati?
Ehhh…a few things. But for a dessert, the gelati is impeccable!!!
I always get a cup of chocolate ice and vanilla ice cream in layers between the ice. Love it!!! The chocolate ice has chocolate chips in it and the vanilla tastes like whipped cream! To die for!
This location gets a little busy at times but it’s worth the wait!
The staff is all smiles, ready to accommodate you at all times!
Love it, love it, love it!

Heaven in a cup. Great gelati combos possible — let your imagination go.

Pretty amazing. I’ve been two times in the past week and it hasn’t disappointed. This time I got just chocolate (didn’t mix and match flavored). The chocolate is my favorite and it has chocolate chips in it. The portions are pretty generous.
My only complaint is that it sometimes can be a little slow if the line is long… but the line is so long because it’s so good

Best gelato ever!!! Stopped here because I was in the area and craving something sweet and I’m so glad I did. So many flavors to choose. I couldn’t decide between strawberry and blueberry, so I got both. Creamy velvety goodness from the vanilla ice cream and a refreshing burst of strawberry from the Italian ice. The blueberry was good but a bit too sweet for my taste. Overall AMAZING !! Will go back till I try all the flavors.

Jeremiah’s is the hands down THE BEST! I compare it to my absolute favorite ice cream stop! If you’re by a Jeremiah’s, stop in and try any flavor you want! It’s a must have! You will want to come back all the time!

For a summer treat I think they are one of the best. They have ice cream, icies, our a mix of ice with ice cream.
The new store in Longwood is indoor or outdoor seating. quick service, daily specials and friendly staff.
Well worth the drive through waiting

By far my favorite dessert spot! Whenever I’m in Orlando for business, I always hit this place up at least once. My favorite is a gelati with vanilla ice cream… ½ cookies and cream, ½ strawberry lemonade. Yum!!!
The staff (of cute high school girls) are always cheerful and willing to give you multiple samples to try the many flavors of Italian ice.

Jeremiah’s hands down is my ULTIMATE favorite place ever! I’m even more excited to know that with this new location I may just set myself up for trouble, or would I? :P
It’s the perfect sweet treat to cool you down and satisfy your cravings. They have lots of Italian ice flavors, my personal being mango, and two ice cream flavors, chocolate and vanilla. You can choose to either have the ice cream or ice alone, but get the gelati! It’s the perfect combo of ice cream and Italian ice in one.
Don’t let the size of these cups, yet alone cones fool you. The small is the perfect amount for me, because medium was just a little too much, and well large. Good luck. haha!
Best part of this Jeremiah’s is that there is a drive thru! Now go enjoy, and let your sweet tooth get the best of you ;)

hooked!!!
I always get «scoop froggy» and it’s so delicious!
They have a drive thru which make things a lot easier for me. Theres a lot of people standing in line so i just go through the drive thru, and while your waiting to order, one of the workers go around to each car and takes your order so by the time you reach the drive thru window, your gelati is ready!

Hooray for Jeremiah’s in Altamonte!
What is up with all the cool stuff moving into my hood?! I love it! I’ve been meaning to try out this location since it opened a couple of weeks ago and finally got around to it last night. I took a friend that hadn’t been before and she thoroughly enjoyed it.
There was no line when we arrived, so we had a chance to try a couple of flavors before making our choices. I picked the mango margarita gelati and she went with the horchata gelati. Both were amazing!
One of the things I like most about this location is that it has a drive-​thru, so I can swing by and pick something up to take home (since I live just up the road). We didn’t take advantage of the drive-​thru last night but I definitely will in the future.

I will most definitely need to drop by Jeremiah’s again when I am in Altamonte because hot damn that’s one yummy gelato! I love that there is not only a sweeping variety of flavors, but that you can also layer it with soft-​serve ice cream. Though my gut was originally pulling for the Scoop Froggy Frog (Mint Chocolate Chip), a monkey wrench was thrown into the works when we sampled a tiny cup of Horchata (those who love Cinnamon Toast Crunch or anything with a cinnamon-​sugar flavor will be on cloud nine).
The prices are very, very reasonable with the smallest serving starting out at around $ 3. What I love about the location is that it’s nestled in a former bank building complete with drive-​thru option for those who want their gelati to go! We opted to employ the voluminous parking, mosey up to the window, and then take a seat at one of the picnic tables complete with umbrellas! Some how, we manage to squeak in before a queue popped up right behind us. Seating is very limited, but I am sure that wouldn’t stop folks from going old school and plopping down the steps, provided they aren’t blocking the nice to the service windows.
A customer mailing list is available with an iPad at the window to sign up on while you wait! With the Florida summer quickly heating up, I am fully confident that this will become a new hot spot for ice treat lovers all over Orlando!

I don’t think it’s fair someone gives it 1 star because it was busy when it just opened with «5 cars wrapped around». A place that’s hopping should tell you what kind of place it is! It’s often busy but the line moves quickly. This person also complained about only being able to see their list of flavors, not their menu. The Flavors is what matters!
Their menu is.
Italian Ice Small
Italian Ice Medium
Italian Ice Large
Italian Ice Pint
Gelati Small
Gelati Medium
Gelati Large
Gelati Pint
Bottle of Water
:)
Jeremiah’s is a staple in Orlando. It’s soo good! If you have pups too ask for a pup cup, a complimentary treat for your dog– vanilla or peanut butter, can’t leave them out :)

I’m not sure if this is a fair review to make since we haven’t yet tried this one yet… truth is, we tried, but it was crazy. The idea of having a drive through is ridiculous for this type of business. Last night 5 cars are wrapped around the front of the building waiting on the drive up line… music was blasting, exhaust fumes, hard for people to walk up to the business. There were a lot of people but it was hard to see the menu board, we could just see a listing of flavors. We waited a while and left because just wasn’t a welcoming environment.
Walking back to our car someone is urinating outside their car… wonderful, especially with all of the kids on skateboards zipping around.
We we so anxious for this location to open… hopefully it will die down a it and the owners will re-​think the drive through line.

I was a little out of it from anesthesia as we were driving by this location. I guess they just opened. This location wasnt even on Unilocal and I’ve never seen it before. My throat was killing me. The first thing I asked when I woke up from the anesthesia was, «what the hell, did you guys have a paramedic student intubate me?» so we decided to swing around and grab an italian ice for my throat.
its hard for me to give to many details about the place since I was so loopy. but this chain is consistently good. I hardly ever stop at one because the locations are out of the way. but now that there’s one right by my house I have a new spot to go… grab a large italian ice, add 2 ounces of spiced or coconut rum and your good to go.
oh ya and this location has a drive through. it used to be a bank. so you can grab a ice to go even faster!!! bonus