Pietro’s Pizza Kauai

Last day open January 15 2016. Will reopen
In the old Feral Pig in February. I will be back. Great crust, sauce and cheese. Well made and cooked. Minus one star for the toppings, not heavily topped and not top notch.

Not a NY pizza critic but I ordered two pcs of pie from the window. He offered to warm up a bit. Now I am happy that Kauai has pizza to crave and it delivers satisfaction. The service was great but then he’s a local so what do you expect. Mahalo.

Say good bye to Brick Oven because this is now EASILY the best place to get pizza on Kauai. Tastier, and a much better value!
For starters, the owners are AMAZING (literally the nicest, friendliest, most hospitable people you will ever meet in your entire life), and the pizza is amazing as well. The crust is what makes it – thin, and crispy but somehow still soft. There is also just the right amount of sauce and cheese. It’s basically just a perfect balance.
We got a large Don Ho and a large Big Gumbah for 8 people and it was enough for a light dinner. If you want something with a little bit of Hawaiian flare, I would recommend the Don Ho. It has kalua pork and Portuguese sausage — something a little different instead of your normal pizza toppings. Like the menu here says, pineapples and ham aren’t really Hawaiian!
There are a couple of tables inside the restaurant and a few outside as well. They also do takeaway. If you’re in the Lihue area, be sure to give this place a try!
Bonus: They serve pizza by the slice until 4PM!

. Fabulous new pizza on Kauai! Owners are eager to please and the pizza is delicious!

Pizza done right! If you ascribe to getting back to the basics and doing the small things just right, this is the place. The pizza was more reminiscent of one’s I’ve had in Florence and Rome than any I’ve had in the states. I was quite surprised and will be coming back for sure.

We had the «White» pizza and devoured every bite. It was delicious! The friendly owner trained in Naples and he just bought a brick pizza oven from Italy. The pizza is baked over kiawe wood which gives it that extra special edge.

The pizza is so delicious! We stopped here when we first landed in Kauai, and it was so tasty! There was 4 of us, we ordered a large (white) pizza and ate it all. We switched out the toppings the white pizza for artichoke heart, onions, and olives. They will be moving soon with a bigger, hotter oven, meaning there is less of a wait time! I will come back here when I visit Kauai again!

New York style pizzas. The crust was thin and Jalapeños were hot. My husband and I usually have a slice and save the rest for later but not this time. It was so good we finished ever last slice!

We have been to Kauia 7 times but never have we been to Pietro’s Pizza.
This is a fantastic pizza restaurant and only will get better when they move to there new location and start using the new brick oven.
The owner is so passionate about the process of making great pizza.

Absolutely AMAZING pizza. Delicious crust and the owners were kind and welcoming. Felt like home! Great spot to grab and go or sit and relax in their adorable set-​up. Absolutely delicious, will have to visit again before I leave! Thank you for the killer food and hospitality! Mahalo!

Holy Moly!!! This pizza puts all other places to shame! Bomb!!! Excellent crust, sauce is a little sweet… literally perfect! If you don’t try this place then you’re crazy! Can’t wait to come back!

Yes. This.
So so good perfect pizza after a long day. Very glad our plans got changed and we got hungry. Highly recommend the pizza, get the pie you will want leftovers. Thin crust perfect. Nice place to sit and enjoy. It’s too bad this place missed the latest edition of Kauai Revealed. Great service and great food, very nice new ownership. They are getting a brick oven and beer/​wine soon.

Wasn’t planning on it, but we just had to stop in and check this place out.
Yummy New York style pizza! It had an awesome crust and we just couldn’t pass on the Portuguese Sausage Don Ho pizza.
Simply delicious ~ a great, friendly staff with quick service.
Although we got our pie to go, it was still fantastic when we got back to our room to grind.
Great pie… we’ll be back, for sure, brah! \^^^/

Hands down, the best NY pizza on Kauai. We’ve been to Pietro’s three times since we’ve been here on vacation. (Much better value than the old Kauai standby, Brick Oven Pizza.)
Looking forward to when they move to the new larger location in the Harbor Mall and they fire up their authenticity Italian pizza oven.
The owner is from New York and also trained in Napoli, Italy to be a certified pizza-​maker.
Our favorites so far have been the white pizza with clams and the «Haole», which is known elsewhere as a Hawaiian pizza.
Trying the Bronx Bomber tonight. Can’t wait!

Great evening! Eight of us — four kids for adults had our last dinner on Kauai. The owner stayed open for us despite the closing time, let us bring our own booze (we had a bottle of vodka!), helped us arranged the tables and chairs for our group. Salads were excellent — fresh and plentiful, definitely better than we had in more expensive restaurants in the area. Very accommodating with pizzas — our kids were all over the place deciding what pizza they want. We ended up with lots of half and halves. Pizza tasted delish. We had garlic, pepperoni, cheese and sausage. Crust was excellent, sauce yummy. The owner, Tom, came outside and talked to us. He is a New Yorker and so were three adults in our group. We had a lot to talk about! He was hospitable, gregarious, very positive. In other words our experience was great. I see how some reviewers might not like the venue, but the owner showed us a new venue that was being remodeled, where he is planning to move shortly!

We went for lunch and had the pizza by the slice for lunch. Good NY style pizza, cheese and crust. It was so good that we went back for a full pie. Pepperoni slice $ 3, and the full pie was $ 21. Location is very close to Marriott Vacation Resort club and about a 5 – 10 minute walk. Excellent value for the money.

I really liked Pietro’s. On our first night in Kauai, my girlfriend and I were exhausted from all the travel and didn’t feel like getting dressed up for a meal. We ended up walking across from the Kauai Marriott to Pietro’s intending to pick up a few slices. It turns out that they don’t sell slices after 3 or 4pm (I forget which), so we somewhat reluctantly bought a full pizza (Half Pepperoni and Half Pineapple). We met the owner and he was a very nice guy who makes a pretty mean pizza for Kauai. My girlfriend and I loved the light crust and tasty sauce and were happy to have the leftovers on our hike in Waimea Canyon the next day.

Pietro’s was walking distance from the Kauai Marriott so we decided to give them a try.
Despite showing as «Open» on Unilocal!,they were closed. OK then! Off to get some ramen instead.
Went back a second time and ordered a large Don Corleone. We thought it was okay, but not great. I think Pizza Hut would be about as good, to be honest. The crust was decent and the sauce good, but the whole thing lacked a bit of punch in the flavor department.
Probably won’t be repeating this one…

Tried this place for the first time today, and we all loved this pizza! Just my opinion, but think this is the best pizza on Kauai! The crust was the perfect combination of crispy & chewy, the toppings were fairly generous, and it was just so good! Kind of reminiscent of Pizza Hanalei… in fact if there were garlic butter brushed crust, it would be 5-​star for sure!
We were just saying how they need a better venue, so more folks can experience their pizza… then heard they are indeed planning to move to a bigger location in the same shopping center; great news! We will definitely be back…

New York style pizza was good but not the best. We ordered a large Uncle Vito, we liked the sauce and crust, but thought they skimped a bit on the toppings. For 28.00 I would expect a bit more. We did however consume the entire pie so it was good. This place is in a small shopping mall near Nawiliwili bay with a few tables inside and out.