Reeser’s Soft Ice Cream

Best soft serve around! Great unique flavor specials every week. Peanut Butter is the best!

I have never had a bad experience at Reeser’s. My parents took me when I was a child and now my husband and I take our children. The food is always beyond reproach, in fact the ice cream is the best I’ve ever had.
The price is more than what you pay at Dairy Queen or other chain ice cream shops, but this is a family owned and operated business since 1969 and well worth the couple extra bucks. Grab an ice cream and enjoy it at the day use area of Pinchot, right up the road.
Definitely a worthwhile stop if you’re in the area. Go a weekend they have fresh peach sundaes or peanut butter ice cream and you won’t regret it!

Easily one of the best shops around. Prices are great but the service is even better. Always pleasant window conversation and a great small town feel. Staff is professional, yet fun. Peanut Butter ice cream is amazing. Their fresh peach sundaes in August are absolutely amazing and worth the wait in line… If you are in the area I suggest you stop in. We need more places like this around.
Suggested Food: Donnie Dog or Beef BBQ
Suggested Ice Cream: Peach Sunday (August only), Peanut Butter, and the Elvis Presley.

I’ve said it before and will say it again… BEST ice cream in town! Love the raspberry!

Thanks to the Unilocalers we had to go out of our way to try Reeser’s ice cream! It was worth it. It’s a local joint close to Ski Roundtop. They offer a quick menu featuring soft ice cream, milkshakes & malts, Italian ice, arctic swirls & a variety of sandwiches priced from $ 1 – 7.50. They have weekly specials and I was actually looking forward to the peanut butter flavor but it wasn’t featured. Bummer. Anyway, one of the special flavors was orange & the server suggested the orange & vanilla swirl, if I liked Dreamsickles. So I tried it and it was very good. My husband got a strawberry sundae with chocolate ice cream & whipped cream. It was very filling. They offer seating on picnic benches. I guess if we can make it back up here from MD, hopefully I will be able to try peanut butter ice cream.

Reesers is a wonderful ice cream store !! The ice cream is amazing especially the peanut butter. If you come to visit in August be sure to have a fresh peach sundae made with local peaches. I have been coming here since I was a little kid. I have nothing else to compare !!

Love this place! I’m from out of town but enjoy stopping here when I can!

They’re right, the peanut butter soft serve is yummmmmmmmmy!!! There was a super long line, but it went fast. The menu is quite extensive, and very cheap! This is a great place for a Sunday snack after a BBQ! I haven’t tried any of the sandwiches, but would try a BLT for such a cheap price!
Great little out of the way place! A nice find!

Best soft serve in the area. The berry flavors (blueberry, rasberry, and black cherry) are my favorites. Peanut butter is the flavor of the week every holiday weekend. My husband adores the fresh peach sundaes served mid-​July through Labor Day. And who can go wrong with vanilla soft serve cup topped with chopped up Butterfinger?

Run by Donny Reeser for the past 20 years and his Father before that. This soft ice cream shop/​food shop has been a staple of my families eating rituals for many years. Being right down the road from Gifford Pinchot State Park and only a few miles away from the highway this is a great place to finish off a day of hiking/​boating/​whever you enjoy doing out doors. Every Fri-​Sun he makes a different flavor soft ice cream. I highly recommend the Banana which tastes nothing like a banana at all, but more like those orange circus peanuts you get in the candy section. (not kidding, keep that thought in your mind before you lick that ice cream cone).
The food he serves is simple, tasty and cheap. He factors in the tax right with the food so everything comes out to a nice round number, well rounded to a quarter anyway. Vanilla, Chocolate, and Mixed are the staples and he has a «Hey what goes in a?» sunday list that has more than 20 different kinds ranging from smores, to blueberry, to peach cobbler. There have been nights I have driven past this place and the line extended all the way to the middle of the parking lot, and when you see just how large his lot is, you’ll understand what I am talking about. Quite surprising that with all those people, there aren’t any reviews for it here yet. Well I’ll change that.
Go here for the food, stay for the ice cream, and enjoy the rest of your night. His hours change throughout the year and he does close for the winter season so this isn’t a 24÷7÷365 business, but who wants to be swimming in ice cold weather anyway?