Jeremiahs Italian Ice

It’s sinfully yummy goodness, and when I eat it all i’m upset that it’s gone and then i want more! LOL Friendly staff also… they’re always smiling!

Ok, i get the hype now. Since moving to Florida I’ve been told by multiple people that I need to give this place a try, and I even see that they keep winning best iced cream /​dessert place in local contests (which surprised me against places like Coldstone and Ritas).
So last night after dinner, we finally stopped by and gave it a try. Just, Wow! It completely reminds me of Ritas on steroids. And he soft serve is just amazing. Nothing about this visit disappointed me. From the friendly staff, to the amazing black cherry gelato I indulged in. I am officially a Jeremiah’s fan.

Hands down, one of my favorite Gelati places! The staff is always friendly and the flavors… So many to choose from. Just wish they had the Sugarfree Tangerine flavor all year round. The best flavor ever!

So good! I’m not sure if you can call it Italian ice since it’s so much better and smoother than any I’ve had before. When we discovered this place, we had to go a few times a week because it’s just that good. Nice employees. Great service. Get the cookies and cream ice!

Oh my deliciousness!!! We recently moved here out of state and stumbled across this establishment. Every time we go there, we get something different and every time, it’s great! The swirled Italian ice/​ice cream combo is a must. Staff is friendly.

Jeremiahs definitely delivers a «small town» feel for a chain italian ice joint, and this location does not disappoint. It’s small but has a drive-​through, friendly staff, and the flavors you are looking for in an icy treat during the day. I wish they had a few more options, or switched it up once in a while, but if you’re looking for a quick (this place is fast) sweet snack on the way home from dinner or on a hot florida afternoon then this is a solid choice.

When it’s hot in Florida (almost all the time) this is a great place to go for über refreshing Italian ice and gelato. I love that this location has a drive up window so you can get your frozen treat to go. They even have dome lids if you just want to take it home with you.
I would suggest the mango Italian ice, it’s so balanced in the sweetness with a touch of tart. I love the gelato but find it very creamy and can’t eat too much of it. When I get the Italian ice with gelato I ask to have it as ¾ Italian ice and ¼ gelato. It’s nice with that amount and so cooling. Just a side note, the Italian ice and gelato are pretty high in calories. Even a mixed Italian ice and gelato is upwards of 400 or more calories depending on the flavor, so proceed with caution when indulging. I really love this place for dessert or a snack. Also the staff will let you sample the Italian ice flavors, so just ask and find your own perfect flavor.

Drive thu! Good soft serve. We ordered the chocolate and chocolate vanilla swirl. Taste great and quick drive thru service.

The italian ice and soft serve combo sounds strange but is delicious. We have tried lemon and vanilla and their mint with chocolate. Both delicious.

This place is awesome. A definite standout in the area for a cold treat. I had the passion fruit and mango (I think it was mango) layered with vanilla custard. I was super unsure about this combination but it was surprisingly very good! The flavors interacted really well together. I can’t find any place that does this in Chicago!
The staff are adorable teenage girls who don’t get annoyed when you ask to try 5 things before you commit to a combination. I really appreciated that.
I wish I lived closer! I would come here every night!

Yum yum yum yum yum. Best Italian ice and gelato I’ve ever had. Black raspberry is to die for. They also have a drive thru window; I love that!

I love this place! First of all, their gelato is amazing, and some (like the cake batter flavor, highly recommend it) are smoother than others, which adds a lot of variety. There are outdoor tables in the back and benches in the front if you don’t feel like leaving right away, and there’s a drive through if you don’t feel like leaving your car. If the drive through line is really long, someone’ll come out and take your order for you so you can get your stuff faster. Overall, this is a GREAT place and highly recommend if you haven’t already to check it out!

Had the strawberry Italian ice with vanilla gelati! It was pretty good! Very different from what I’m use to with the norm of ice cream, but this place offers something different with all kinds of flavors to choose from. From coconut to piña colada, chocolate to cotton candy. There’s loads to choose from. It was my first try and I enjoyed it very much!

Awesome little gelato shop for some ice on a hot day or an after dinner treat. The girls behind the counter are always friendly and the service is fast. Tons of flavors to choose from with lots of different combinations. There is ample seating here, uncovered at the front service area and covered benches in the back. There’s even a drive through if you’re on the go. Definitely worth checking out

Great Ice Cream, great Italian Ice. and it is priced great. The employees are great, always smiling and efficient.
I love to get Chocolate Ice Cream with Coconut Ice, its like an Almond Joy bar, yum yum!

Finally tried some Italian ice and it was good! Something refreshing to have on a hit summer day and this warm and humid Florida weather!

I could swear I’d already reviewed this … weird!
This Jeremiah’s is pretty awesome. The girls who work here always are smiling and friendly. Never spent more than a minute or so waiting in line, either — the employees are quick & efficient and provide great customer service.
This one and the one in Maitland are my favorite Jeremiah’s locations. Both always are a treat to go to.
Highly recommended!

The benchmark for gelati.
No one else comes close.

Versini’s is better… here is why…
Made a recent visit to Brewster’s only to find that they were closed and Jeremiah’s was taking over the empty space. After convincing my crying daughter that there would be other places to buy good ice cream I told her that we would try Jeremiah’s when they finally opened… Today was that day.
Jeremiah’s has lots of people there every time I drive by one in and around Orlando. Great recognition, cool colors and branding. Where my experience fell a little short was with the Italian Ice itself. My Italian Ice had big chunks of well… ice in it. I don’t mean packed clusters of finely manipulated flavored Italian Ice. I’m talking of run of the mill get it in your freezer irregularly sized chunks of water-​small enough to safely eat… just not smooth, tasty decadence. This doesn’t happen to me at other places (like Versini’s). In addition, the Black Cherry flavor was much weaker than you know… at Versini’s but the soft serve ice cream at Jeremiah’s was the higher quality version that is also served at you know where.
Jeremiah’s is fine… people seem to like going there, the counter girls are nice and Jeremiah’s does try to put out a fine quality product. For my money, Versini’s does a better job at it and in my opinion the underdog (up the street-​left @ the park) is a little more deserving of your support.

You know it’s bad when you roll up to a drive thru window and the cashier says «Oh, I remember you, I waited on you the other day.» Is it that noticeable that I am obsessed?
This location opened just a few weeks ago, and I have already been there 3 or 4 times. I have dreams of their Gelati! My favorite flavor is the Strawberry Ice with vanilla ice cream. I’ve also had the citrus twist, cake batter, mango, and cherry, and all were excellent. My husband normally orders the PNutty Ice with the Chocolate Ice cream, which is also delicious! They allow you to mix and match your flavors, so you can sample multiple flavors at a time.
This stuff is icy without being crunchy, and creamy without putting too much lbs on the hips. In fact, it’s less calories than the normal ice cream because it’s half ice!
The place is PACKED every night. You gotta go check it out. I can say it’s seriously the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life.
Now I just need to get their frequent buyers card…