Giacomo’s Pizza Cafe

Dude, this place does it right! Their buffalo chicken pizza changed my life. I’m a pizza traditionalist. To explain: I like my traditional crust, my traditional toppings (normally pepperoni or lots of stuff/​supreme. I’ll eat Hawaiian pizza, but it’s pretty out there and I’d rather have pepperoni. So I go to Giacomo’s for lunch one day had a square slice of the buffalo chicken pizza since it looked cool with the sauce drizzled on it or whatever. Holy bejeezus, it’s good! Like slap your mamma good! My mouth is watering thinking about it weeks later good. Now that I’ve been exposed to square slices and weird toppings it has me questioning a lot of other things in life… what else am I missing?

Great pizza, pretty good pasta, amazing service. My favorite local pizza spot, where we always go, at any location, to grab a pie for the family or the drive-​in.

Love them! Good food! Good service, and fast delivery times! The prices are reasonable especially since the food is so good! Don’t go to the one in Wappingers though, yuck! LaGrange location is the best!

Get a pepperoni pizza with roasted vegetables on top. Mwwwwaaaaa!!!

This latest Giacomo’s opened up not far from our house and we have become regulars. The food and service are consistently really good. Great pizza, subs and salads. Plenty of seating if you want to eat there.

Overall I had a very pleasurable experience when I visited this particular Giacomos location. The store was clean and well decorated, the staff was friendly and made us feel quite welcomed. Spacious seating & a very convenient location. I would definitely recommend this pizzeria not only for take out but also as a dine in dinner with my family and will be back soon! :)

Delicious pizza, not far from the Taconic Parkway. A great place to stop midway from NYC to the Berkshires. There were nine varieties of slices that looked freshly made. I had a wheat slice with vegetables which was delicious; my son had a sicilian slice which he said was good but nothing special. It was clean, the service was friendly and helpful, and having a whole wheat option was a plus. It deserves a 3.5, but I up it to a four because of its location.

Oftentimes when I am traveling between Albany and Long Island, I take the Taconic State Parkway between the two locations. I tend to stop in Lagrange or East Fishkill as this is usually where there is the best selection of places to stop, get gas if necessary, stretch my legs and grab a bite to eat. The Route 55 exit seems to be where I usually take my break, and it was dinner time when I stopped at Giacomo’s for some pizza.
The food was decent, tasted good and there were a number of different options. I decided to have a couple of slices of square pizza, since it looked tasty, and it was. The price though, was a bit more expensive than what I was expecting. I may give Giacomo’s another try based on the quality and taste of the food, but I may look elsewhere first for the food itself.

The latest Giacomo’s just opened up on 55, and I couldn’t be happier. Pretty much the best pizza around the county, in my view… and last night’s bacon, onion, mushroom and black olive pie was up to the same delicious standards as the other Giacomo’s on the other side of the town. We’ll be funneling all of our local pizza consumption squarely in the new place’s direction!