Absolutely love this family owned business. Pizza, wings, subs, Stromboli are always deliciously amazing.
Judas P.
Place rating: 5 Wallkill, NY
Banging pizza hidden away in the corner of the Kingston Plaza. Definitely a happy find. The place was big for a pizza joint and the prices were very reasonable. The cashier was a little rude but it was pretty busy, so I’m gonna cut the girl a break.
Andrew H.
Place rating: 3 Kingston, NY
A nice pizza place tucked in a corner of a plaza. Best thing I’ve had so far is the chicken parmesan Stromboli which was cooked perfectly! Pizza is good too. Recommended.
Denise M.
Place rating: 1 Norwood, MA
The first and last time we will be here. The pizza was gross. The crust was not cooked enough. The whole thing tasted like dough. Very disappointed.
Earl M.
Place rating: 3 Kutztown, PA
Good inexpensive lunch of 2 slices with drink for $ 7.50. Big enough for 2 people. Alot of pizza choices.
Tammy S.
Place rating: 5 Kingston, NY
The best pizza outside of NYC.
Alexis L.
Place rating: 1 Lake Katrine, NY
On my first impression the woman behind the counter was so rude it was unbelievable. We were rushed while looking at the menu and came close to walking out. Even after that experience I decided to order a pizza and wings for delivery one night & it was the biggest mistake of my life. I had friends over and we were all so disgusted we couldn’t even eat. The wings were soggy and looked microwaved and the pizza was ice cold. Upon calling them to complain the guy admitted that THEWINGSWEREMICROWAVEDBECAUSETHEOVENWASNOTWORKINGPROPERLY. Have not ordered from this place since nor will I or any of my friends ever again.
Andrea L.
Place rating: 5 Santa Ana, CA
After a 20+ year absence from Kingston, I returned this spring and Plaza Pizza was my first stop after I checked into my hotel. As good as I remembered. Make sure to order a calzone – bell pepper and pepperoni is my fave – it’s big enough for two and has tons of ricotta. Owners are warm and friendly and the food is really authentic.
Pietro P.
Place rating: 3 Saugerties, NY
Had two large, plain, cheese pizza delivered. $ 29.50. Prompt, hot, nicely boxed and cut, friendly young delivery man. Generous toppings, just a bit heavy on the salt and sauce a bit thin for my taste. Good but not great pizza.
Mickey S.
Place rating: 5 Albany, NY
I have been going to Plaza Pizza for YEARS and it is simply delicious! Food made fresh each day. The crust is soft but also crispy and has a nice taste. It is not thick like a mattress and all doughy. The sauce is NOT sweet at all. The cheese is a little oily but the whole pizza is just wonderful! I hate sweet sauce and thick doughy crust, so this pizza place is great in my opinion. The calzones are good, the SANDWICHES are mouthwatering! Subs or regular sandwiches are stacked with meats, cheeses, lettuce, tomato and whatever you want on it. They pile on the pizza toppings and the extra cheese pizza looks and tastes like one! The wings are delicious and juicy. The meatball sub is fantastic. Some pizza places just can’t make a good meatball sandwich, but Plaza Pizza has it nailed. My only complaint is that they don’t offer fresh garlic as toppings and THAT should be a staple in Italian food! When I think of Italian food, I think of olive oil, fresh garlic, tomatoes and cheese. I had suggested to them to TRY making HOTOIL pizza, but so far, it has been nearly 4 years later and they still have displayed no interest in attempting this delicious, spicy, popular pizza! I tried it in Connecticut and suggested that Plaza Pizza make it. No doubt it would become one of their best selling pies, but I can’t make them try! Downside? The service is hit or miss but the food is always good quality.
Ray S.
Place rating: 5 Kingston, NY
Great food!!! Great wings!!! My new pizza place.
Gus C.
Place rating: 2 Hurley, NY
Average pizza. Indifferent staff. If this place was in NYC, it wouldn’t rate at all.
Mike W.
Place rating: 3 Hudson, NY
Ever walk into a pizza place expecting a godawful slice(I mean, it is called Plaza Pizza) and receive something totally acceptable? Made a warm, sunny day even brighter. har har. Cheesy line for an exceptionally cheesy pizza. Your jaw will get a solid workout chewing through the fresh, hot globs of, albeit, quality mozzarella. The crust was also a bit too thick and chewy for my taste. Even with these factors going against it, I was still FEELING this slice. It had umami. The total«i just ate a decent slice of NY style pizza and will feel satiated for the next hour and a half» feeling. All in all, I’d spend another $ 2.16 for a slice if I happened to be near Kingston Plaza, didn’t want a hot dog from Dallas’ and didn’t feel like driving to Five Guys.
Ray S.
Place rating: 5 West Hurley, NY
This place is really good. Great hero sandwiches, and the chicken cesar wrap can be delicious! Lots of varieties of fresh pizza, too. Very reliable.
Rebecca P.
Place rating: 5 Seattle, WA
For someone who loves pizza, I know this place is good. It’s real pizza made by Italians and their friends. Try is out. And, remember: the true judge is a fresh slice of cheese.