Evaroni’s Pizza

What a really nice place for a family meal. The pizza is tasty and the service is awesome. Sodas are a bit small but free refills when dining in. The sauce is sweet and the crust flavorful. I will definitely be returning.

The best pizza I have ever eaten! The only complaint I have is that they put a little too much sauce on the pizza, so when you order, you might ask for less sauce.

THE BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD!!! If you are ever near the Huntington area you MUST eat here!

Got a pizza with bacon and pepperoni, the potato wedges and the small baked spaghetti. As for the pizza wowza sauce! Uniquely sweet marinara sauce. The potato wedges were delicious. The small baked spaghetti. A little too small for me. Next time I’ll get the regular sized. Overall good food and good service.

Wow! My husband ate here during college and wanted to take me back. Again, wow! I think it was the best pizza I have ever eaten. I really like desserts and I think that is the reason. The sauce is very sweet. If you like desserts, then this will be close to perfection for you.
I called in our order because we were just passing through. The girl that took my order could not have been more friendly or helpful.

The food is perfectly mediocre. The people that love it grew up with it. Cabell County transplants tend to not like it.
They always understaff their schedule. This is problematic for everyone. The servers are doing a hundred things at once and are always stressed out. This means that customers wait longer and feel rushed. If customers are less likely to come then it has to cut in Evaroni’s bottom line.

I personally think the pizza sauce is entirely too sweet but I might be alone on this because everybody loves the place.

There is no other pizza, they just pretend to be pizza. Have ate here 1 to 2 times a week for over 20 years and would more often if it were closer. The wonderful waitresses know our order by heart. I could literally drink the sauce and the sweet tea is the bomb! Don’t know how anyone wouldn’t like it.

My extended family just descended on Evaroni’s after a memorial 5K race in Catlettsburg for my deceased cousin. There were probably 24 of us. One server handled all of us and nobody was ever without a refill, food orders were correct, she was never flustered. Hat’s off. I own a restaurant and that kind of personality and proficiency is gold for a restaurant– or any company. Everoni’s, I missed her name but she has worked for you for four years and she’s in school– take care of her!

Delicious pizza, good service, and good prices make coming here worth it every time. The atmosphere reflects the area (Marshall, C-​K and the like) and the food tastes amazing. Dont like pizza? Get the chicken strips or pasta, but personally I love their potato wedges.

Fantastic pizza, but dreadful service. The tips are all split between the servers — so no one goes above or beyond. Actually, they don’t even give mediocre service. It’s pretty bad. You’ll get your order, but don’t expect any friendliness. I find the signs posted around the store about the tipping and about «absolutely no outside food» (not even cakes or cupcakes — which are things they don’t even offer) to be in as almost as bad taste as their tacky and outdated booths and wood paneling. Do yourself a favor and get carryout.

Evaroni’s has some of the best pizza you’ll ever eat, and certainly the best in the Tristate area (with Rocky Tops sweet sauce right there with them). Their pies have a unique flavor of their own mainly because whatever they’re putting in their sauce is just unbelievably good. This place is absolutely fantastic for groups. The kind of place you take the team after your kids sporting events, or the family for someone’s birthday, etc. The ambiance is classic and classy and the wait staff is always friendly. Evaroni’s makes Kenova shine.

This restaurant has great food don’t get me wrong. It’s really good. But I have some complaints though. Mainly the atmosphere is 30 years old and very ugly and outdated and needs replaced. Also the tips and combined and split them equally. I hate that. It gives no incentive to the server to actually provide good service!
They nickel and dime you for everything. You only get one free refill and if you want a box it’s 50 cents. It’s just stuff like that which is totally not needed or cool. Also they don’t get that it makes sense to put groups or children in the back. I’ve been here twice with extremely loud and annoying people without any waitress or hostess asking them to quite down. Again the food is great, pizza is probably the best in town. The restaurant overall just needs some improvements.

My significant otter and I stopped here on our way out of town. Service was fast and friendly and the pizza was good.

Great pizza. I’ve been a fan for over 30 years. Love the sweet pizza sauce! We try to eat there at least one time per month.

I really try to avoid writing a review after only eating someplace once, but this is an exception. We were passing through and chose Evaroni’s based on online reviews. We arrived to find the place packed with a short wait for a table. However, it was all worth it. They know how to make a pizza. The crust and cheese blend are both spot on, the sauce has just a hint of sweet, and the cheese sticks have some sort of herbs and spices on them that set them off. I want one in my town!

At first when you walk in, you wonder why it has such a great reputation amongst locals. The décor is very dated, and seems almost off putting. However, when the waitress smiles and asks how many, it made you feel very welcome. The menu IS limited. Don’t expect to order the new trendy appetizers. They have Garlic Bread and Bread sticks. The do have a small assortment of salads, and you can order spaghetti as well. Their pizza was what we ordered, and it was great! Lots of Cheese, plenty of pepperoni and sausage. The sauce is on the sweeter side, and the pie is cut in squares opposed to traditional slices. One thing to note, they do not bring you your check, when you are done, you just go up to the counter. They also split tips, so don’t leave money on the table.
Enjoy!

The Tri State is blessed with several great pizza places and this one might be the best of the bunch. Located on US 60 right off the highway, this place gives you great service with extra attention to the food. The sausage pizza is the best that I have ever had… but just about any combination there will make you go home with a smile.
Kudos.

Don’t live there any more but always order two large every time. One to eat there and one half bake to take back to PA with me. Sausage & pepperoni. Half bakes are just as good. Sauce is out of this world but it does always make thirsty for hours. If you think you’ve has good pizza and it wasn’t Evaroni’s you are clueless or have lost your mind. Been Aton there for 40 years. Last slice was as good as my first.

1^st time ever eating here and had always heard good things about it. Don’t know why i waited as long as i had to eat here… food was amazing.