Atlantic Pizza

Atlantic Pizza, Kennebunkport, Maine: Probably deserving of it’s mixed reviews. My wife liked it better than I, but I thought it was very good, but not great. Still, very, very fairly priced with fast friendly service. My frat brother who has a home in the area said it was terrible, but a couple we spoke with in the pizzeria eat there often and thought it was spectacular. So, somewhere in between, leaning toward the better.

Only OK. It’s not that it was bad; it’s that it isn’t as good as Alex’s in Biddeford. The crust definitely was not as good, and the pepperioni was not as good. If you can, save your pizza eating for better places.

Great pizza! We were craving pizza and this hit the spot! The staff was very friendly. Would definitely recommend Atlantic pizza.

Believe it or not, our favorite pizza take out place anywhere. Their cheese blend is delicious and they are generous with it. More of a Greek style dough. Simple, home town pizza done the right way. Nothing more to say. We come from Massachusetts and among the seafood places in KPT we choose to eat here when the kids are here with friends.

Great pizza! While looking for an allergy friendly restaurant we came upon Atlantic pizza. Staff were accomodating, friendly and knowledgeable about ingredients. Great pizza and Greek salad :)!

Good Greek-​style pizza. Ordered take out which worked well since there didn’t appear to be great seating options. If you need a break from lobster rolls and fried clams give it a shot.

Small pizza place just off the main rd. We originally saw it on Unilocal with strong reviews and decided to check it out. Looked like a little dive and weren’t sure how good it was going to be. However don’t let looks fool you, it was delicious. Two pizzas ordered and prepared in minutes. Sat outside on the patio and pizzas were brought out about 10 minutes later. Absolutely delicious and very reasonably priced for the location. If you are looking for a high end pizza shop this isn’t it.

Ordered the pizza at 3:30p and the guy said his delivery driver comes in at 5. At 4:30p I called back and ordered the pizza and at 5:45p I called back to inquire what was taking so long. The guy said the guy couldn’t find the address and I said why didn’t he just call me to tell him how to get here?! Anyhow after 3 hours I still starving and they refuse to bring the pizza. I would be careful working with this group as they didn’t follow through very well at all.

Greek salad was really good, but they don’t do grilled chicken :/​. Buffalo wings are teeny tiny! Nice people, good food, good price, small portions!

Stumbled upon this place looking for a quick bite to eat. Looks like we stumbled upon one of the best pizza places EVER! The staff were friendly, the wait was short (we ordered two full pizzas but you can also get slices fresh out of the oven!), and the food was delectable! They have lots of great toppings to pick from, though I just got cheese and it was still full of flavor– herbs and spices, etc. Definitely check this place out!

My favorite place to get pepperoni pizza! Wish it was open year-​round!

In the world of pizza, New England usually seems like it’s located between New York and Chicago. The pizza usually isn’t as thin and crispy as it is in New York, but it isn’t thick and stuffed like a good, Chicago deep dish pizza. New England pizza is typically sort of in the middle, especially as you head Northeast into Maine, but not the pizza at Atlantic Pizza. Although I didn’t find it as fresh and crisp as I was hoping, it was thin and tasty in a way that’s hard to find in Maine. I only got a few slices that had been sitting for a while, so I wasn’t able to sample a truly fresh pie.
The décor of Atlantic Pizza is nothing special. I could see a tourist thinking of this place as a really great hole in the wall that no one knows about because the dinig room is nothing impressive. That’s okay, it’s not priced like fine dining despite being located right next to pricey K’port.
I’m going with four stars because Atlantic Pizza shows potential to be amazing, especially for the area. But when a slice has been kept warm for a while, it really needs to go back in the oven for a few minutes. This pizza is too good for one of those weird warming cases and they take away from the experience.

Delicious pizza. We shared margarita between two adults and 2 kids. Super fresh, tasty, juicy (not oily) which leaves you with a full stomach but feeling light. Fresh tomatoes and basil. Want to go back. Hmmmmm

This pizza and sandwiches are always good. One place we’ll always come back to when we can’t find anywhere else to eat or don’t feel like going to far.

Not as great as the pizza you’d find in a bigger city, but for a vacation town Atlantic is great. This place is a vacation tradition for my family.

While the workers there were really cool guys, it was the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life and it wasn’t cheap either!