Most consistent pizza in Keene. A regular Friday night pick-up for my family. Great staff! And now a facelift inside and out. Love the new floor to ceiling windows in front and the banquettes. I might even consider eating in now. :)
Kelly D.
Place rating: 1 Chicago, IL
Worst pizza I’ve ever had. Based on the reviews I thought it would be good. The pizza was so soggy that I could have used a third hand to hold one piece. The box was soaking wet and the pizza tasted exactly like the box from sitting in whatever liquid it was sitting in. Every piece of topping fell off of every piece I tried to pick up. Eventually I just gave up and threw it out. Pretty nasty.
Paul C.
Place rating: 4 Keene, NH
I’d vote for best pizza in town! And BIG slices are a bargin. Nice folks, too.
Matthew L.
Place rating: 5 Keene, NH
Everyone has their own preferences for Pizza, so it’s impossible that the whole world would agree, but this is what you get: Thin, totally authentic fresh thin crust, just the right amount of [not-too-sweet-but-flavorful] sauce, and the perfect ratio of toppings. Not greasy at all. My one tip(but I do this anywhere) is to order your pie well-done for a slightly crispier crust and a little more brown on the cheese. Damn, I want some pizza now…
Tom F.
Place rating: 5 Waltham, MA
Best pizza in Keene hands down! Fresh, hand tossed dough and the pizza isn’t greasy. The crust is so chewy I love it. Give this place a shot. You’ll love it.
Brandie P.
Place rating: 1 Indianapolis, IN
Although I was really looking forward to this based upon the excellent Unilocal reviews I had read, I was NOT impressed. Poor seating. Poor service. Pizza was nothing special… bland really. Not recommended.
SJ D.
Place rating: 5 Orlando, FL
Seriously the best. Has been my favorite pizza place forever. Whenever I move away, I can wait to come back for a visit so I can have some pizza. Highly recommended for anyone passing through Keene. They have more than just pizza. They have subs, appetizers, and salads. I love this place.
Kevin C.
Place rating: 3 Farmington, CT
Neat little pizza joint, friendly staff, expansive menu. Got grinders and pizza, hinders were pretty good, unfortunate that they don’t have much of a selection for cheese. Got some turkey, veggie and pizza grinders, all were delicious, I’d recommend them all. For pizza we got a small half cheese half pepperoni. The pizza was average, crust was doughy, a little undercooked. The inside was cool, small seating area a swell as a barstool counter, pinball machine by the door. Overall standard pizza joint, I’d go back to give their pizza a second chance and to try their calzones.
James R.
Place rating: 5 Jaffrey, NH
Best pizza on the planet. We live about 25 minutes from Keene and every time we go to eat in Keene we have to go to Amicci’s. It does not matter what kind of food we want we just abort and get pizza. It is a thinner crust and it is crispy. It is really good when you take it home but there is nothing better than when the pizza is right out of the oven.
Gringo M.
Place rating: 4 Fitzwilliam, NH
I can’t quite put my finger on why I love Amicci’s so much… No BS, just good food, comes quick and comes cheap.
Andrew E.
Place rating: 5 Manchester, NH
As a new Yorker I have high expectations for pizza. This pizza is exceptional! People in this area are clueless when it comes to pizza, however Amicci’s gets it right!
Jennifer B.
Place rating: 5 Hinsdale, NH
Amicci’s is the pizza my husband and I compare all other pizza to! He’s military so we live out of state, but whenever we are back in the area we have to stop in and grab an Amicci’s pizza. Great price, fresh ingredients, and the staff is super friendly. Conveniently located in downtown Keene so just a short walk from all your favorite spots!
Zoe M.
Place rating: 5 Burlington, VT
I moved from Keene to Boston three years ago and I’m still talking about Amicis pizza. All time favorite.
Michael M.
Place rating: 4 Walpole, NH
Finally! A REAL thin crust pizza in Cheshire County. I know where I’ll be going from now on! Dined in today and it was great — friendly staff, quick turnaround and good prices.
Liz B.
Place rating: 4 Keene, NH
Great place if you’re looking for good quality, inexpensive pizza. Great place if you’re ordering for a large group. They use quality dough for the pizza and their pita bread is amazing(worth the extra $ 1 or so to add it to your salad). Chicken fingers are also a good choice.
Nat S.
Place rating: 5 Denver, CO
This may be my favorite pizza place in southern NH for simple delicious thin crust pizza. Sauce is zesty, cheese in a perfect amount and a nice tooth to the crust. They do slices too and for 2 – 2.50 $ really hit the spot when you want something fast and don’t want to spend much cash.
Cassy L.
Place rating: 5 Medford, MA
Love love this place Only place I get delivery from The chicken fingers are awesome and great portion size! All the hot subs are great My food always comes hot and in a timely manner
Will S.
Place rating: 5 Marlborough, NH
In a town where there is a lack of good New York style pizza, this is really the place to go
Julia M.
Place rating: 4 Brighton, MA
Amicci’s is one of my favorite pizza places. Their pizza is delicious — thin crust, not overly greasy, & the perfect ratio of sauce & cheese. You can order by the slice or pie, & you also have the option of eating the pizza there or taking it to go. They also serve pasta, salads, & subs; although being that I’ve only had their pizza, I can’t speak to the quality of their non-pizza menu items.
Niki V.
Place rating: 5 Boston, MA
My favorite pizza place. Delicious huge slices that aren’t overly greasy and somehow they have perfected the art of thin crust pizza that is still doughy and never burnt on the bottom or too crispy. Their subs and other meals are really good too. And they always have cream soda which is my favorite. It’s very small so don’t depend on eating there I usually just grab a bench outside on main street. Also there’s one or two video games there that kids have a blast on while waiting.