Mills Catering

We were seeking a caterer for our wedding rehearsal dinner, and Mills Catering was suggested to us by our photographer. Their group caters some artsy/​First Friday type events, and she said that they were great.
We weren’t sure if we were the type of business they usually did, but after a call, they were perfectly happy to work with us. We saw some sample menus, but none of them really went with the backyard BBQ theme we were hoping for. When we mentioned this, Jessie (the main gentleman we worked with) put together a fabulous menu that fit with what we’re looking for. Then (and we were floored by this), he invited us to their office where they had cooked everything on this menu, and they served us dinner so that we could try all of it. They even wrapped up the leftovers for us to take home.
Our event was hosted in a family member’s backyard. They were extremely flexible in planning, timing, delivering tables/​chairs, and getting the food set up. The food itself was fabulous – we had BBQ pulled pork, mango/​something chicken, mac and cheese, baked beans, caprese salad, and some brownies/​cookies for dessert. They also brought sodas and lemonade for us, and they had no problem with us providing the alcohol. All of the food was DELICIOUS, and our guests raved about it all night. There were a few staff members present acting as waitstaff, and they were polite, helpful, and gracious.
When we first had this idea, we weren’t sure who we would find who would want to cater something fairly small in a personal home. By the end, we were so satisfied with Matt Mill’s Catering and especially Jessie, who was infinitely helpful. The price was perfectly in line with other options we researched, and they probably provided better food than what we would’ve found elsewhere. We would wholeheartedly recommend them!

First, I should say that I joined Unilocal primarily to give an excellent review for Mills Catering. I use Unilocal on a regular basis, but this is the first time that I have felt called to give props to a truly amazing company.
We recently hired Mills Catering for our wedding reception. From my first email response from Matt Mills until we settled our final bill, we were thoroughly impressed with the quality of Mills’ cuisine and customer service. I heard about Mills through one of my closest friends, who had only good things to say about bout Mills’ catering at her wedding reception. My friend and I both have highly critical and thrifty fathers, who were (shockingly) both impressed with Mills Catering.
Matt Mills runs a catering business that provides ridiculously delicious food and excellent customer service at surprisingly economical prices. Our guests raved about the «best wedding chicken», «really nice servers», and «farm-​fresh vegetables». They went above and beyond the expected service, saving the day when our do-​it-​yourself planning went awry and generously hooking up late guests with dinner plates. Mills Catering impressed the vegetarians, foodies, and less-​adventurous Hoosier eaters.
Contact Mills Catering — you won’t regret it.