Enzo Pizza

Don’t let these reviews fool you, this is mall pizza. Comparable to Sbarro’s, actually it’s exactly the same. I thought it was «like real NY pizza». Regrets…

Really liked the spinach, tomato, ricotta pizza. Large portions, friendly people. Didn’t care for the pepperoni breadsticks, but overall really good. 3.5 stars.

Enzo pizza is one of those places we don’t eat at often even though we basically live in their parking lot. It’s not that the food isn’t good, it’s just not something I crave very often.
The restaurant itself is clean, and the staff is friendly. We usually use the drive thru. The menu is a little hard on the eyes, but that’s no big deal. The line moves a little slower than some places, but you have to consider what you are ordering.
The food is pretty good. I usually get Stromboli. There are a few combinations and they’re all good. I really like ham and cheese. It’s a pizza place so it’s honestly hard to go wrong. But whatever you do, make absolutely certain you get at least one cannoli. They are delicious.

I love it, large and greasy just like home! The closest to NY pizza I have come across in Indy! If you can fold it and grease runs down your arm to your elbow, the pizza is perfect! I would like a little more crunch in the crust.
If you don’t like the grease, use some provolone cheese to soak it up! Yummy!

It was hard to find east coast style pizza when I moved to indy but this place is exactly what im looking for. A bit pricey if you dont order a special and add extras but I think its worth it.

So Enzo is a place where when I first got to Indy I craved pizza and it was near by so I took a chance. I do Iike it but I do not like all the grease that comes with it. Its definitely New York style pizza just with a little bit of extra grease. My husband Ike’s everything but the pizza. The Cesar salad and the chicken pasta are his favorites.

It’s ok. The pepperoni breadsticks are better than the pizza. Be careful going thru the drive thru as it’s easy to drive up on the little curb you cannot see.

The staff is friendly and the food is amazing. I work nearby so this is a frequent lunch stop.

I love the pizza here! I’m not a huge fan of thin crust pizza, but when I’m in the mood for it, this does the trick! I usually just stick to plain old pepperoni, but next time I go, I’m going to try one of their calzones or pasta. They look awesome.
The staff is definitely friendly… maybe a little too friendly? This isn’t a club and I’m not looking to get stared at or hit on. Just give me some pizza!
The restaurant itself is clean and casual, nothing fancy. This is a really good spot for a quick lunch.

All I got was a slice of pepperoni and a small drink. Almost six bucks. For one slice and a drink? The pepperonis weren’t spread out either, which is annoying. It was hot though, seemed somewhat fresh.

Enzo is a favorite among my coworkers. We have been here so many times, you would think I would get sick of the place, but the food is always really good and the service and staff are excellent. We bring visitors from out of town here and they love it. I have personally tried the pizza, and the stromboli but my favorite has to be the fettucini carbonara. The pricing is reasonable as well.

What a great place. I was able to grab a nice order of spaghetti with an attempt at a Mozzarella Caprese. I think that if you can’t do it right you might just want to try something else. I’m kind of a Caprese snob and have had some really amazing tomato and mozzarella cheese salads. The gravy was thick and robust, and they put it on top of the spaghetti. Some places like to throw some sauce in with the noodles, mix it up, then serve it. I prefer to do my own mixing and typically find the noodles more al dente in this configuration. I was even able to purchase three Peronis and Tiramasu for desert. Best thing I liked was that I did it at a drive through. I know, I was feeling non-​motivated. All was warm and tasty when I arrived back at my hotel room.
I noticed there were four different police cars in the sparsely populated parking lot. Four officers were sitting at a table eating together. That’s a recommendation to me anywhere.
I had worse, I’ve had better… mostly worse though so try it out.

So this adds to my week of pizza. I ate pizza almost 5 days in a row, god knows why, but… I suppose it’s comfort food for those of us raised in New York/​New Jersey families… and nothing beats good comfort food during cruddy cold weather.
ANYWAY. I’ve been eating Enzo’s for quite sometime — they used to have a shop at the Fashion Mall and they have two locations downtown — on Ilinois and in the City Market. I had never been to this location, so I decided to venture just south of downtown and see how it was. It’s a free standing location, in a crappy shopping center next to a Taco Bell.
Despite the not-​so-​sexy location, the building is really well maintained and super clean. I was greeted by friendly staff with plenty of menu options. I ordered two slices of pepperoni and used a coupon from their website which got me a free drink with the purchase of two slices.
The staff was very friendly, and it didn’t take long for my slices to be heated and brought to me at my booth. I like heat with my pizza, so I added on some red pepper and prepared to pig out.
I was left with a really disappointing taste in my mouth (no pun intended). There was too much cheese on the slices, giving an almost nauseating feeling when eating it (gagging, perhaps. I’m not one of those types that loves extra cheesy pizza). It also was a bit undercooked, they could have left it in the oven a bit longer. By the time this all processed through my gorging pizza hunger, it was too late to ask them to heat it. I wasn’t in the mood (my fault…) to deal with it, I suppose.
I had 1 ½ slices (And before you think I’m some out of shape junk food addict, I swear I’ve got a high metab and I keep in shape, heh) and couldn’t stomach the last half. The cheese was getting to me and I started to get grossed out by the goo. The heat was also super weak, the red pepper was «stale» so to say, leaving very little pack to the punch.
I trashed my pizza, went back into the rain and headed home feeling disappointed by Enzo South. I usually have a great experience with slices at the Market. I’d consider going back to this location, if they go a bit lighter on the cheese and I have them keep it in the oven a bit longer.
They also need to freshen up their spices!
Overall a clean restaurant with a friendly staff, just a bit too cheesy for my NYC style tastes.

Enzo’s is a great place to eat. I think their meat-​stuffed pizza is to die for. I am also a huge fan of their chef’s salad. Since this location is right by my office, I eat there all the time. The staff is really friendly, too.

Enzo is a great place for a tasty, affordable lunch or dinner. The staff is friendly and I’ve never had anything that I didn’t like there. Both the regular and stuffed pizzas are good, as well as the lasagna and spaghetti with meatballs. My favorite recommendations: the spinach & cheese calzone and pepperoni stuffed breadsticks. Enzo’s marinara sauce is awesome — just the right amount of spiciness with nice chunks of tomato throughout. Enzo is definitely nothing fancy, but I highly recommend if you have a craving for Italian food.
An added tip: I just went to their website for the first time and noticed that they offer a few good coupons on it.