Lucy’s Pizzeria

I ordered here twice since my last review and I literally got sick. My friend and I couldn’t even eat the whole slice… I don’t know what’s going on but the cheese tastes funky

I go to the one in Roberts, ID.
It is closer to my work. Friendly people, cooked fresh. I keep going back. Worth it!

This place is the best. Love it. Chicken wings are very good although I wish they had hotter spicier buffalo sauce. The pizza was amazing very good flavor, however if they would use a little more cheese it wouldn’t hurt anyone. Good atmosphere and good food. I’ll definitely be coming back.

Nope, never again. It was awful and way to expensive for the garbage they serve! Everything is way over priced and all four of us eating where discussed. Never get my business again.

Perfect Pizza. We were visiting and staying in a hotel and they delivered to our room. We had the Buffalo chicken pizza… I highly recommend this pizza. Their crust is thin and perfectly chewy and delicious. Great… great pizza.

This pizza is really tasty if you can endure the hour and sometimes thirty minute wait. Not a good choice for hungry kiddos. Our server was excellent and did her best to cover up the mistakes from the pizza chefs. The two individuals preparing the pizza were unprofessional and obnoxiously loud. After they burned our kid’s pizzas luckily our server came through with not having to pay for the kids pizza replacements that finally arrived at 1 hour and 45 min later. I’m gonna recommend takeout only and give yourself plenty of lead time.

Any place that puts ricotta on pizza and/​or has ricotta on site is a place to go to. Have you put ricotta on your pizza before? you havent? well you might as well give up on life now.
The BBQ chicken’s sweet bbq sauce pairs perfectly with the saltiness of the ricotta and that blending of flavor leads to overeating, which also leads to death. But one of the most pleasant deaths in the history of mankind. (im a history minor so… i would know.)
Their pepperonis are huge and taste like friendship… i myself have never actually tasted friendship but i assume this is what it would taste like. The read sauce is smooth and the tomatoes are just ripe enough to provide the right amount of sweet to acid of the tomato.
THE VERDICT: Idaho falls you have the pizza place. you need not going anywhere else. just go here. if you are going somewhere else you should probably get an MRI. I may have just saved your life. The pizza is delicious and reasonably priced, and food in IF has been saved by this place.

Kicking back watching the presidential debate at the LQ Inn and Suites. Unilocaled Lucy’s and liked the reviews. Walked across the parking lot and the order was ready in 23 minutes.
We had the medium Margarita pizza, Fried Mozzarella, and cheesy bread.
First and foremost, the Margarita pizza was the best I have ever had. Freshly sliced tomatoes and basil over the red sauce. The cheesy bread had the perfect blend of bread, garlic butter and cheese. The Fried Mozz, which we thought were going to be pre-​fab mozzarella sticks, was actually a ½ inch slice cut off of a fresh block of cheese and fried.
This could have easily fed a family of four for less than $ 25.
Absolutely the best. Move to Vegas so I can eat your Za weekly.

This may be my favorite pizza! It is sooooo good!

The family salad and 15″ pizza fed a family of three easily. There were several good beers on tap too. The slices were cut the right way, so you could fold them properly. This will be my go to place for pizza.

My husband had the meatball sub, very bland, served lukewarm… borderline cold, 15 minutes before our calzone and pizzas arrived. I had a calzone that was amazing. I ordered white sauce, chicken, green olives and sausage. Their pizza is pretty good. My fave pizza is the Zestbian, and they make yummy cheese sticks too! Stick with the pizza and calzones and you won’t be disappointed.

I’m going to say this is the best pizza in town, but that’s only because everyone else in town really wouldn’t know pizza if they saw it. This is New York pizza. It’s cooked right, it has good ingredients, and great crust. It’s a good slice. I enjoy it much.

Simple ingredients & Whole Foods make the best pizza. Thank You Lucys for keeping it real!
Awesome quality yummy pizza!

Excellent pizza! We also had the antipasto salad which was very good. We were looking for a good pizza and we found it right next door to our hotel. Not only was the food terrific, but the service was just what we have become accustomed to in Idaho — very friendly and attentive. This was a perfect evening with good food and good people. Thanks Lucy’s!

Very cold night and I walked over to Lucy’s from my hotel. Very friendly and seated fast. The place smelled good. I started with the antipasti salad. For 6 bucks you get four slices of ham, four pepperoni and four salami, shredded romaine lettuce, two grape tomatoes, a few pieces of artichoke, sliced black olives, and shredded cheese. I got my choice of two salad dressings, I just stuck with Italian. I wanted salad, would not order it again. I got the veggie pizza. Tasty but I think they forgot the sauce. They handle special orders very nicely. I got the cannoli for dessert. Good crisp shell and tasty filling. When they offered me huckleberry cannoli I stopped her. I am a NY Italian… don’t go there with me. Over all nice service. Would get the pizza again but ask for triple sauce.

Ordered delivery… burned bottom. And you call those things bread stixs… worst ever, hard as a rock.

People in IF are the weirdest Unilocal raters. For one thing I can’t believe this place only has 6 reviews. For another, I can’t believe my favorite pizza place in the WORLD got 3.5 stars. What a joke. This place is DELICIOUS. We usually get half pepperoni and half Hawaiian. I’m talking real slices of pineapple. The sauce? Mmmm so good. The crust? Delicious. Nom nom nom. The service is great. When they are busy they recognize it and apologize. Seriously I’m pregnant right now and ALL I WANT TO EAT is LUCYS! It is on the pricier end of the spectrum, so be prepared for that. They have 1.50 slice tuesdays. Their slices are big. It’s the only thin crust pizza I’ve had in idaho that I enjoy. I think it’s weird that all of the reviews say it’s good but then give it 3 stars. 3 is «I may go back» 2 is «I probably won’t» and 1 is «never ever». Get with it peeps! Amazing pizza, just go. Mmmm

Average so hence the 3 stars. They were doing great until they forgot half out order. I’d try it again

I’ve been to this particular location a handful of times, each time I go the service is great and the pizza is even better. As far as pizza goes in Idaho falls, you really don’t have very many options. This place is really good, I’ve tried a variety of their pizzas and I’ve never been disappointed.
The pizza are very large and flavorful, I would definitely recommend giving this place a try the next time you are craving some New York style pizza.

I have ordered delivery from Lucy’s a few times before but never dined in until a few days ago. We stopped in around noon and were seated at a table somewhere near the back of the restaurant. It bothered me that there were no booths to sit at because I prefer the privacy.
After a few minutes of looking over a menu that wasn’t terribly easy to navigate, we ordered our Meaty pizza. I also had a half Caprese salad to go with it because I was hungry and wanted something to eat as quickly as possible. The Caprese took longer to arrive than expected, around 10 minutes or so after ordering.
The Caprese tasted okay once I removed half of the basil leaves. I understand Caprese gets some of its flavor from the basil leaves, but leaving all of them on top overwhelmed the dish. Otherwise, the mozzarella and tomatoes tasted fresh. I would order it again if I was hungry enough, but wouldn’t come back just for it.
The pizza took around 25 – 30 minutes to arrive which seemed unusually long, especially because I could see the cook from my table and he didn’t look incredibly busy. I’ve ordered pizzas from this same place that have arrived in half the time it took.
Still, the pizza did eventually arrive and it tasted above average. Messy and delicious make the best pizzas if you ask me, and this was no different. After finishing my half, I was content and overall satisfied with the food quality. We also ordered a few canoles as we had never had them before. They were very small, but tasted okay. Did not expect them to be as crunchy as they were.
The décor in the place feels dated, especially after I know this location has only been open for a few years. I didn’t like that I could see the cooks from my table (along with the waiters that seemed to like chatting more than working), and it seemed like the place has a bit of an identity crisis. Do they want to be a sports bar or a pizzeria? I don’t know.
Still, I’d bet I’ll come back to this place, I just won’t be rushing to. The food was fine, and the best part about this place (which is most important) but the wait time was unacceptable and the atmosphere didn’t seem all that welcoming. Maybe I’ll just order delivery next time.