Nothing fancy, just good food in a nice small town. Best pizza in the area in my opinion.
Peter B.
Place rating: 5 High Bridge, NJ
Just had great take out pizza for lunch. We ordered a whole Hawaiian pie, plain and mushroom slices. Crust was excellent as was the tomato sauce. The mushroom slice had real mushrooms NOT from a tin. Picked up a menu and will definitely be back. Went to take pictures but all was devoured before I could… next time
Jennifer W.
Place rating: 5 South Brunswick Township, NJ
The pizza here is wonderful. I got some pies when we had guests, and my sister still says it was the best pizza she had ever had. I only wish they delivered, as they are only available for dine-in or carry out.
Allison S.
Place rating: 5 High Bridge, NJ
We finally found a really good pizza outside of Garfield NJ! We had the Sicilian pizza with sausage. You can tell it’s made fresh and they use very good ingredients. We’re definitely becoming regulars.
Kristi T.
Place rating: 5 Annandale, NJ
I had Carlo’s Sicilian and it was great! I paid $ 2.50 for a huge slice. I will definitely go back.
Carmel D.
Place rating: 2 High Bridge, NJ
Pizza soso owner rude. Came in my order was ready on top of oven but he was busy talking to a woman. With so many pizza parlor in area his attitude needs an adjustment
Penguin P.
Place rating: 5 Ottawa, Canada
Had a delicious Stromboli, we even had a miscommunication about which one I ordered and they made me a new one. Points for that. Is definitely go back.
Gerry K.
Place rating: 2 Califon, NJ
The regular pizza is tasteless. Sicilian is a bit better and what I’d order if I went back, which I won’t. Also almost $ 13 for 4 slices and a bottle of soda? No thanks.
Dunder M.
Place rating: 5 Bedminster, NJ
Great pizza on a quaint Main Street. Really great meatballs too.
