Mamma Mia’s

I love MM. Been going there since it opened. Pizza on my top 10 list too! Consistent, delicious food. Small dining area so go early if you want to eat in

I had the house special pizza and it was fantastic. The crust was outstanding. I’d definitely get that again.

Waited almost 30 mins before the waitress came to clean our table, then waited another 30 minutes for our food (soup & sandwich) go figure not a 3 course meal.
Food is ok and but it is over rate with just a hint of real Italian taste. Good luck

Came here after a basketball tournament with my daughter, based on positive Unilocal reviews and we were pleasantly surprised by this cute little place with good food in a strip mall.
It’s a cute little place with family friendly pictures on the wall. Bright and welcoming interior.
Tasty and PERFECTLY prepared food. We split a meatball sandwich and a «small» pizza. The sandwich came with fries.
The pizza is thin crust and very fresh and tasty in all ways. Really fresh dough made for a light, tasty crust (although it lacked crispness or stability, it was floppy), really bright, light, sweet tasting sauce and good cheese on top. A little more sauce on the pie would have been welcome, but also would have exacerbated the lack of firm crust. Also, it was huge for a small pizza. Easily the same size as a large anywhere else. The waitress said «it just came out that way.»
As a comparison to another well known place, the pizza was a tastier, much fresher Pizzeria Regina pie.
The homemade meatball sandwich was hot and tasty. The roll was terrific and toasted perfectly. Not burnt, not falling apart, chewy, hot and perfect. The meatballs were somewhat lacking in flavor, but the sauce was delicious, but we could have used more.
The fries were an added bonus, as we weren’t that interested in them initially, but they were golden, hot, crispy and exactly what you always want but rarely receive, especially in this type of restaurant. They needed some salt, but otherwise were perfect.
Finally, the prices are VERY reasonable.
The service was average at best. Our waitress seemed disinterested and rushed and the food took a long time to come out, but neither part made for an overall bad experience. Just bad enough to remove one star.
If you’re in the neighborhood, it’s definitely worth trying.

I am stunned that there are so many positive reviews for the food here. Not my experience at all.
I grew up in Plymouth. The Kingston Mamma Mia’s was consistently fantastic when I was a kid. I thought for sure that Mamma Mia’s in Hanover would carry on the goodness.
I ordered a combo plate of veal cutlet and eggplant cutlet. It came with pasta and a meatball. While I waited, I enjoyed a nice glass of cabernet, which turned out to the the most delicious part of the meal. When the meal came, I could already see that something was off. The eggplant was very greasy, with a slick of oil sitting on top of it. Hmm. I cut into the meatball. It didn’t really even look like beef but rather compacted sawdust. Guess what — it didn’t taste like beef either. It had no flavor at all. No garlic. No onion. No herbs. Just blah. Same went for the veal. It didn’t taste like anything. it didn’t even taste like veal. The whole meal tasted like nothing. I was eating a plate full of flavorless mass. I ate just enough to feel satiated (I hadn’t eaten all day). The rest had to be thrown away.
Italian food is supposed to have flavor. Garlic is so important to a good red sauce. I couldn’t detect garlic anywhere in this meal. There was not even a whisper of oregano, nor parsley, nor onion. Why do people accept this as good eating? I don’t get it. It’s offensive to me that this would be called Italian food.
To add insult to injury, I have had significant digestive problems that had me running to the bathroom within a half hour of eating here, which has progressed throughout last night and into my Saturday. I’d be very cautious if you plan on taking in a meal at Mamma Mia’s. I will certainly not be back.
Positive note: nice waitstaff.

Who would tell that this hidden little place between a hair salon and a dance studio would have what I’ve been looking for a long time. A very good Italian food.
My favorite dish, the Seafood FraDiavolo, which is hard to find and even harder to find well made, is on their menu. And its great.
The home made pasta blends perfectly with their creamy sauce and brings up the perfect flavor of that seafood mix.
Along with some fresh rolls and a glass of wine, it has all the ingredients for a perfect dinner.

Service: I loved Tina. She was courteous and checked on us to make sure we had whatever we needed.
Food: The portions are huge! I ordered the Chicken Marsala and I definitely brought home the leftovers. The pasta was cooked to perfection, but I feel like the meal in general could have used a bit more salt.
Price: My plate was around $ 13. I think it’s a great deal.

Had to wait about 15 min to get the waitress, another 35 min for appetizer. Couldnt wait any longer.
Dont get me wrong mamma mia has great food, just dont dine at the restaurant. You will be faster if you pick up the food and eat it there.

After reading so many great reviews of Mama Mia’s, and how it was so family friendly, we had to give it a try, even though it’s 45 minutes from home.
So My wife and I took our children, ages 6 and 2, to Mama Mia’s last evening.
After waiting for over a half hour for a table, we ordered the Chicken Parm with spaghetti and the Eggplant Parm with house noodles for the adults and pizza for the kids.
Maybe it was a REALLY off night for the cooks because the food was not good, even the pizza. I don’t know if the cheese was turned or they were training a new cook but none got even halfway done with our meals.
Needless to say, we didn’t take the leftovers home.
The previous reviews boasted how family friendly the place was but I didn’t see anything that any other restaurant didn’t offer.
Overall, I was very disappointed that Mama Mia’s came nowhere close to the level excellence that it advertises. In fact it was sub-​par.
I cannot recommend Mama Mia’s and will not be returning.