Buckleys Inn Between

Hampton Bays, United States

3.7

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 631-728-7197
Website:
www.buckleysinnbetween.com
Address:
139 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, NY, 11946
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
0.4 miHampton Bays
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
Yes
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Dinner
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
Yes
Drive-Thru
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 11:30 am – 4:00 am
Closed now
Local time (Hampton Bays) 08:07 Saturday, 31 May 2025

Business hours

Monday 11:30 am – 4:00 am
Tuesday 11:30 am – 4:00 am
Wednesday 11:30 am – 4:00 am
Thursday 11:30 am – 4:00 am
Friday 11:30 am – 4:00 am
Saturday 11:30 am – 4:00 am
Sunday 11:30 am – 4:00 am

Description

Specialties

Buckley’s Inn Between is a family friendly restaurant with an extensive menu including our famous Conor burger, steaks, salads, and authentic Irish fare. And for the after dinner crowd, step into our pub to watch a game on our big screen TV or play a game of darts. We offer a great selection of beers on tap, including Guinness, Harp and Bass. Buckley’s Inn Between is great place to bring the family or to hang out with friends.

Come on in and watch soccer and other major sports here.

History

Established in 2003.

Opened in 2003, with a growing year round community two Irish men who lived in the town decided to open Buckleys Inn Between, a Family restaurant and bar. to this day it still serves as a community orientated business.

Meet the Business Owner

Mark S.

Business Owner

Born in Dublin, Ireland, emigrated to NY in 1989,

worked in marketing and sales initially and tended bar in midtown manhattan, moved to eastern Long Island in 1995, maintained working in craft beer and distribution business opened Buckleys Inn Between in 2003

Related places

You might also consider:
430
ft
Villa Paul Restaurant
162 W Montauk Hwy
1
mi
Gators Restaurant
6 W Montauk Hwy
1.6
mi
1 North Steakhouse
322 W Montauk Hwy
3.4
mi
New Moon Cafe
524 Montauk Hwy
4.2
mi
Dockers Waterside Marina & Restaurant
94 Dune Rd
5.7
mi
Cliff’s Elbow Room
1549 Main Rd

Nearby

Near this location:
220
ft
East End Eye Associates
4 Springville Rd
220
ft
Seifert Eye Associates
4 Springville Rd
380
ft
NYC Surgical Assocaites
145 W Montauk Hwy
440
ft
Matsulin
131 W Montauk Hwy
460
ft
The Bike Guy
480
ft
Hampton Bays Chiropractic
147 W Montauk Hwy

20 reviews of Buckleys Inn Between

No registration required
Place rating: 5
Smithtown, NY
Great Pub out east especially in a high rising cost environment as you keep getting farther out. Plenty of parking, huge lot. Very affordable food
Place rating: 3
Poughkeepsie, NY
The male bartenders are awesome foods great! Lady bartender had the worst attitude ever. Because this is the second time she has been rude to us. We will never come back and we are locals. Take out from now on.
Place rating: 5
Miller Place, NY
Great lunch had on 9÷19÷15 !Asparagus salad was appealing to the eye and stomach. Sandwiches selected were Reuben, Chicken Cordon Bleu and grilled cheese BT, no leftovers. Beer batteries onion rings my fav! Corn fritters are a good app to share and nibble 12 – 15 nugget style with sauce. Going back to sample burgers and an authentic looking Irish menu. ***Don’t sit in booth, my guests and I were uncomfortable.
Place rating: 1
Hampton Bays, NY
Steak house that can’t cook a steak, even on a steak night. Last time I ordered take out, the salad was barely there. No more buckleys for me. Do yourself a favor and try other places.
Place rating: 3
New York, NY
The buffalo wings. Are great the nachos are good. Except do not order the spinach dip. Steak Sandwich is decent very clean space separate. Dining area and bar clean place over all friendly staff
Place rating: 1
Levittown, NY
Terrible service. We were charged for food we returned because it was not what we asked for– the waitress argued with us when we wanted the item taken off the bill.
Place rating: 3
East Quogue, NY
Good place for beers and lunch good service food is good beer is cold and clean no complaints here a thumbs up.
Place rating: 1
Wellington, FL
The «special» chicken Marsala was a mixture of chicken cutlets microwaved to mush. «Not microwaved» according to the bartender, who also asked me if it was a «special» when I ordered it. He’s new so let’s cut some slack I’ve been there. I wish he would have asked me how it was before I paid, it doesn’t feel right having something taken off the bill after its paid for. Especially when it’s not even the manager who was willing to deal with it at this point. I’ve been here a handful of times and it’s always been acceptable, it’s a pub for chrissakes. But this was entirely terrible again this whole entire plate was microwaved, you could tell from the gelatinous gravy they called Marsala, to the quickness it was delivered from kitchen, to the heat emanating from the plate. No gracious welcoming and hardly a concerned goodbye after a terrible meal which was not followed up on. I will never be back.
Place rating: 5
Garden City, NY
Buckleys has been a family favorite for a long time. We are obsessed with their corn fritters which everyone must try! I have never had a bad meal at buckles and I believe that their prices are very fair. If you enjoy pub style food definitely give buckles a try.
Place rating: 4
Southampton, NY
just had a nice lunch philly steak sandwich with wedge salad. all was very good and the service was great. caroline is not only a very friendly and atractive bartender she provides good service. i would reccomend this place to anyone.
Place rating: 2
Hampton Bays, NY
Expensive drinks and mediocre atmosphere. The place doesn’t have a pool table and their draft beers are $ 6 a glass (on St. Patrick’s day). Food can be prepared well but I’ve heard about issues. Seems as if you’re not a regular or know the staff you aren’t treated with much respect. I don’t know if I would consider this place a «Steakhouse» either, it has more of a pub feel to it. Would solemnly revisit.
Place rating: 5
Smithtown, NY
Once again, Buckley ’ serves up the best food in town. The burgers are delicious and the corned beef and cabbage is out of this world. The portions are huge and full of flavor. Our waitress Hazel is just outstanding! Everything was perfect. …AGAIN!
Place rating: 4
Princeton, NJ
Do you have a craving for really great pub food at reasonable prices? In the Hamptons the answer is Buckleys. Super friendly staff (as well as the owner, Mark), delicious burgers with gluten free buns if requested, excellent nachos, great fries, Magners Hard Cider on tap, old school pub-​by atmosphere… what more could we ask for? My friends also reported that the chicken pot pie and turkey burgers were excellent, and worth coming back for.
Dined here with some friends the other night and all were pleased with the food, the service, and the lively trivia contest. There aren’t a whole lot of restaurants in the Hamptions where you’ll find a true bargain, but Buckley’s certainly qualifies.
Trivia night with cash prizes on the first Wed of every month is another fun option here. If you need a respite from the pricey, chi-​chi, and not always great restaurants that litter the South Fork, put on your comfy old jeans & try Buckley’s.
Place rating: 5
Riverhead, NY
Went here last night with a few friends and we had a really great time! Everyone was extremely friendly! The DJ was awesome, drinks were cheap and STRONG. The bartender was also very friendly. He actually ended up giving my brother a free beer :) I definitely want to go back to try their food — specifically one of their 14 burgers. Definitely will be back!
Place rating: 3
Manorville, NY
I am a frequent customer to the Buckleys in Center Moriches and sometimes I will visit here as well.
I like how this Buckleys has beer pong on Thursday nights. Adds something extra and fun to the experience of the bar and I wish the Center Moriches one did this as well. They also have their wing and beer special on Thursday but the wings are always way too spicy for my taste. Calm it down a bit!
Drinks are decently priced, average. Around $ 8 or $ 9 for medium sized cocktail type drink. Bartenders are friendly.
I think because this bar is in Hampton Bays, it never really seems to get too crowded. Maybe in the summer it does, but the rest of the year it seems pretty dead in there. Therefore I like going there to get a casual drink and talk with my friends, it’s perfect place for that.
Place rating: 5
Asheville, NC
Full disclosure: I used to work here. Here, and her sister to the South, the original Buck’s. Best. Job. Ever. Sadly, Buck’s went the way of the dinosaurs, but the Inn Between barrels on like gangbusters, the local home for all things Irish.
On a side note, if you’re passing through the area come March, do whatever it takes to get in on the Hampton Bays St. Pat’s Parade (which, btw, is never on St. Pat’s). It’s an epic adventure that rivals a day at the Boardy Barn (see my review for more on that matter). Come prepared for day drinking the likes of which you’ve never seen. That plus floats, beads and all the Irish folks within a 50-​mile-​radius is so much awesome.
But back to the basics. Upon making your way to the Inn Between, order some corn fritters (or curry chips) and a cider on-​tap, play some tunes on their all-​kinds-​of-​amazing jukebox and get acquainted with the local Irish invasion. It’s the best crowd you’ll find in the whole of the Hamptons. Promise.
Place rating: 5
Coram, NY
Came here a few days ago and had an amazing dinner not only is the staff amazing cause I asked to switch tables twice I am pregnant and couldn’t get comfy but after two moves was perfect and not one gave me a look they were so helpful we got hot wings to start which are delicious then my hubby got the fish and chips which we both agreed very good and because it was steak night I went with the flank steak and lobster roll with mashed potatoes it was cooked perfect and tasted great was so pleased we ended the night with a chocolate lava cake and fried banana cheese cake now none of the food is imaginative or anything it’s pub food but some of the best pub food I ever had everything was spot on and the staff all of them were so friendly and helpful will def go back :)
Place rating: 5
Brooklyn, NY
Stopped in here after a day of riding my motorcycle out east. I was in need of a solid meal and opted for French onion and shepherds pie.
French onion was dark and rich. Shepherds pie was similar. I can easily say it was the best shepherds pie I’ve ever had.
I will be back.
Place rating: 4
Southampton, NY
Since I wrote a review back in 2012, here is my edited version. As a local resident in the Hamptons, I like to support local business. So I retuned multiple times before writing this edited version. Good job on the entire experience here. Liking the food, service and the experience much better than almost three years ago. Alway has a good clientele for the restaurant. Better than most when it comes to a place to hang with your friends in the Hampton’s especially in the winter months (less crowded) than the rest of the year.
Best Happy Hour in the Hampton’s, I’m the designated driver for a bunch of my friends who love this place. Keep up the good work, it’s all in the details.
Place rating: 5
River Vale, NJ
I wasn’t expecting much… this is Hampton Bays… it was a pub/​family restaurant.
BUT
This food was amazing!
My friend ordered the onion soup which she claimed was completely delish!
We both ordered the swordfish. O… M…G. This was unbelievable. Was cooked to perfection and was served with a side of wasabi something or other.
We topped it all off with the fried banana cheesecake. … yes we’ve all had it. It’s usually not good. This was mouth watering.
Prices were very reasonable and service was exceptional :)