Cayley Cakes

Great place to meet with friends for coffee and a treat. Quiche, scones, sticky buns, even soup! The owner works hard at variety and has even made Profiteroles (which she promises to do again one day!)

Had their cupcakes many times before and was impressed. My husband ordered a custom cake for me with coconut filling and I was expecting coconut frosting. The frosting was buttercream and it tasted like an actual stick of butter with sugar mixed in here and there. Not impressed especially for what he paid. Very upset it was not what I expected.

This is my favorite time of year at Cayley Cakes! The cupcakes are specially decorated for the holiday and Christmas season. They offer an extensive selection of pies, and specialty cookies are sold by the pound. It’s a family-​owned local business, and the owners are incredibly generous and friendly. The staff works hard to make sure the customers are happy and the atmosphere upbeat. Definitely a weekly visit for my family for homemade desserts! (Sugar-​free options available!!)

I needed a birthday cake in 24 hours because of short notice from my family. Cayley Cakes not only came through, but did a custom cake that was just gorgeous. We wanted a Nightmare Before Christmas theme and we got a round cake with black icing on the sides and yellow on the top along with a beautiful raised Jack Skeleton. The cake was waaaay better than other cakes I’ve gotten from bakeries and stores. Very light and fluffy and was shocked that the teenage guests ALL make unsolicited comments about how good it was! The plus part was the black icing made all our tongues black until we brushed our teeth which made for great pictures. We even got a lot of laughter out of it when we fantasized some scenarios such as being stopped by police, visiting the doc or dentist… etc. with a black tongue. Much laughter. Really made the party!

Love Cayley Cakes– everything is made fresh and from scratch! Coffee and espresso are the best!

First time here, the frosting is like no other and the cake is so soft and fluffy just like a cupcake should be :) My prego sister had the strawberry cupcake and the frosting is like cream cheese. Didn’t get to take a picture before she gobbled it up!

This is a local business, which I always try to support when possible.
There is always a wide variety of cupcakes and pastries, candy and ice cream.
If you have a sugar craving, this is the place to satisfy it.
They also make soup, sandwiches, salads and quiche. Quiche is delicious!
Always very clean and employees friendly.

Paid 65.00 for a ¼ sheet, asked for a pretty cake for 80^th BD. got a plain cake with simple scroll work, definitely not what I expected. Next time call Safeway! Very disappointed.

I have been here twice so far. I got a couple cupcakes the first time and was slightly disappointed. The cupcakes were dryer than I expected, but they were still a nice little treat. I decided to stop in to give the cupcakes another shot but ended up getting ice cream and a scone instead. Both were delicious. The ice cream was perfect for a hot Tucson day. I saved my blueberry scone for the next morning’s breakfast and it was perfect.
The atmosphere is perfect. It’s a cute place for a coffee or ice cream date.

Amazing cupcakes. That’s all we’ve ever been there for, to take out, but wow. We’ll go back and try the lunch sometime. What a great place with nice people.

While visiting family in Green Valley we decided we would try this little cake shop called Cayley Cakes and aren’t we glad we did. The baked goods are amazingly delicious, the customer service is great, & the quiche is flavorful!
Suggestion: Try the muffins!

Best cupcakes I’ve ever had. I live in Phoenix and have family in the area, so any time I’m down here, I buy a bunch for the family, and then I bring a bunch back home with me. All of the flavors are amazing.

My first visit did not go well with an encounter I had with a former employee. Once the owner read my view, she contacted me with an apology. Since then, that employee is gone and the cakes are delicious.
I picked up a lemon pie for home and the aroma in the car was mouthwatering. Everyone really like the lemon pie with a crispy flaky crust.
This place is a gem in the neighborhood and worth going there

They should sell the bread pudding with a needle and thread because it was so damn good I wanted to sew my butthole shut. It tasted like an angel flew down from heaven and jizzed right in my mouth. OMG, so good!

WOW! Lunch at Caley Cakes was an accidental find for me.
I’ve had their divine cupcakes before, but I stopped in because they were recommended for some candy bags I wanted to put together and that’s when I found out they’re so much more than «just a bakery»
They’re open 7 days a week and have wonderful lunches. They also have a very large variety of candies, just like when we were kids and ran down to the penny candy store. (well, you may have done that if you’re over 50 — if not, just trust me on ths part).
I ordered a sandwich. I’m a big lover of spice and found what I crave in the Big Pappa. It’s a MUST TRY!!!
It will be one of my regular lunch spots from now on.

Atmosphere gets more stars than the baked goods. Fun place, more a candy store than a cake bakery, cute and colorful with lots of classic treats like Bonomo Turkish Taffy and Burnt Peanuts.
I came with a friend and got one of their HUGE bear claws. The thing was like a small coffee cake, but we got it (to split) and two small brewed coffees for about $ 6. Honestly, Safeway’s bear claws are better – flakier pastry, more almonds – but this thing was loaded right out to the edges with a thick layer of almond paste which kind of made up for the insipid pastry. Sustainability points off for serving it on a big styrofoam tray (and offering a second, which we declined) when it could have been on a tissue or a paper plate.
I probably wouldn’t visit this place again if it were in a big city, but Green Valley isn’t exactly a culinary paradise so there are fewer alternatives. Might be back, since it is close to the library and White Elephant.

Been quite a few times recently, everytime more pleased than the last.
I keep trying new things, cinnamon buns, cupcakes, and the best was the last minute heavenly Red Velvet cake they made for me. She already had many orders to fill, but was able to make it happen. (I dont recommend hoping for a last minute miracle, def order ahead).
The staff are genuine people, and work hard to serve their customers the best they can.
Thanks CC!!!

I usually come here for a little treat & to catch up with my friends after Zumba
(I know, I know– counterproductive, BUT nothing wrong with a small treat here & there, lol!) but I wanting something a little sweet, I had my husband take me to this local gem. We just got a chocolate pie, some cupcakes, & cookies right now– the service was awesome & goods were delicious!!! My husband & I were very happy with everything.
Cayley’s Cake offers more then just custom order cakes– they have ice cream, cookies, cupcakes, fudge, pies, soups, coffees, chocolates, & gummy candies. Yum! There’s a drive thru & they also have seating inside/​outside so you can sit & enjoy your food.

Hearing «cakes» in the name, like many others, I thought this would be a bakery. That said, there are some baked goods, namely some cupcakes, some fudge, and a few by-​the-​slice cake. It appears that you need to order ahead for any cakes — unfortunate as I was going to just drop-​in and purchase a display cake.
I was next door at the church and spoke with some ladies re. this location, etc, and they had not patronized Cayley Cakes and could not comment. Upon entry of the shop, it appears like a candy shop with coffee and other sundries as an addition.
The bear claw is rather doughy; it’s a large size. The options for coffee are the norm. It was hard to find napkins/​creamer/​etc, as it’s off in the candy area. The area is a bit disjointed.
They have free WiFi. There are no outlets to plug-​in your electronic devices.
They DO NOT accept American Express. They have a drive-​thru window, outdoor and plenty of indoor seating. Large enough space if you wanted to have a bookclub meeting, etc.

Love the new spacious place. More room for great delicious treats. I have never had anything I haven’t loved. Absolutely in love with caley cakes. The owner is a great person who cares about her community. She is a very talented baker. The Kentucky bourbon pecan pie is amazing. It will be as new addition to my thanksgiving table this year. Her custom cakes a perfect. She can do anything. This a great local place we are lucky to have. Her candy selection is great. I could write so much more but all I really need to say is stop by and try anything and you will be in love with caley cakes too!