Gallaghers Pizza Inc

I was in Green Bay Wisconsin with my 13-​year-​old daughter for a soccer tournament. A portion of the team went to this restaurant for dinner. I had the minestrone, Greek salad, and ordered a pepperoni pizza to go. My daughter had the lasagna with garlic bread. The minestrone was homemade and was excellent. The Greek salad was very good as well, while the lasagna was a little above average, possibly too cheesy, if that’s a problem. The restaurant seem slow, but the service was also slow. I understand that we had a large party maybe 12 people, call the food didn’t take too long it was waiting for the checks that took a long time. The pizza was average we had at the next day for lunch.

Delicious pizza, sides and pasta dishes. We usually order the monster (supreme on steroids!) and it never disappoints. Great service, fresh ingredients, delicious.

This is some yummy pizza. We are in town overnight and ordered from the closest pizza place to our hotel. We are glad we did! Thin crust was perfect — thin but held its shape. And lots of cheese — we must be in Wisconsin. Fast, courteous delivery as well.

My family goes here alot because we live a few blocks away. I never cared much for the pizza but I love the rest of the menu. The pizza is salty with a rubbery cheese and thick tough crust. The sandwich basket menu is typically what I order from and my favourite is the Southwest Chicken basket. The restaurant offers cheap buffet nights with soup, salad, pizza, and a few appetizers or pasta on the line. They have a small arcade in back and on family nights you can get game tokens with your meal.

Waited over 39 minutes for a burger and received our appetizer in 5 mins after ordering. Time was a little off in my opinion. The staff was a little all over the place. It felt like a bunch of teenagers not caring what happens.
I ordered a southwest chicken sandwich and my wife ordered a hamburger they were both done very well and tasted good. My wife loved the pickles more than anything haha. It was a great time with my wife, even though we would have liked our food a little quicker.
I would say stay away from the soda in my opinion it adds 1.99 per person that orders a soda. Remember water is better for you ;)

The best pizza and calzones around! Make sure to try the spicy sausage on thin crust! Great Buffett as well!

Don’t tell my trainer… but I love this pizza. I discovered it when I was relocating and wanted pizza delivery. I tried the Italian Sausage on wheat crust. One word: Awesome!
It would be great if I could recommend more but that’s now my fav and it’s the only thing I order.

I have never been treated so rudely at a restaurant. I accidentally left my glasses on the table and remembered as we were driving home. We returned immediately. The staff had cleared the table and said the glasses were not on the table. We insisted they were. The teenage staff said they probably threw them in the trash, but refused to look in the trash for us. Because the glasses were prescription, we insisted on seeing the trash ourselves. They gave us the bag and insisted we leave. It was mortifying to dig through the remnants of other people’s buffet food, but we did find the pair of glasses. Horrible awful rude staff.

I have been a multiple time patron of Gallagher’s Pizza on S. Webster. They have always been great on cold days or bad days at work. Great comfort food with lots and lots of options. Also, they are a great local place that is a mere mile or so from my house. However, I just experienced a terrible, and I mean terrible delivery and customer service experience from them. My girlfriend and I ordered food at 5:45pm and were told 45min for delivery. I saw a delivery truck go by at 6:50ish and keep going and then again head back on the crossing street towards the restaurant. Then at 7:10 we called asking about our food and were told it was «on it’s way.» It arrived at 7:15pm, an hour and half after ordering. The food was soggy, cold, and to top it the wrong order. I called and complained to the manager who acknowledged there was a mistake and so had the delivery guy who acknowledged the mistake at delivery. I got a replacement sandwich and the possibility of a 50% off coupon which did not come with the replacement order. I normally don’t complain about things but tonight’s service was unacceptable and local patron should be warned. I complained to the manager and sent an email to the basic contact email. Hopefully they will respond and the manager was very cordial with me and I appreciated that. I really do enjoy there food but this was something that was so unacceptable that I had to comment as such for all other patrons.