Signatures Mill Stone Tavern

I order the Chef salad with oil and vinger. The lettuce was wilted and I was given malt vinger. The salad was of poor quality. But believe or not the malted vinger helped.

Terrible service. Fish and chips had no flavor except for the breading and tartar sauce.

We’ve been coming here for most of a year. Tonight the service is beyond horrendous. It’s as though I’m invisible. Not sure if it’s under new ownership or what but wow. Big disappointment.

Great bar food! Usually pretty fast service and patio is nice in summer. Prices are super reasonable given portion size. Beers do seem expensive for a slightly dive bar vibe.

What a great place to have across the street from your business. Pigskin and Signatures are great friends and we promote each other. We even brewed a beer for them!

Really great lunch! Classic tuna melt and really good coleslaw. The hamburger cabbage soup was hot and comforting. Reminded me of soup my grandma would make!

The pasta bites were amazing, but filled me up such that I couldn’t enjoy my burger! Good beer selection, easy-​going atmosphere. They do, however need to hire/​schedule more wait staff. Our waitress was very friendly and attentive, but just had too many tables. If you come here, have good food and good beer, but don’t expect to get in and out quickly.

Had a great experience here! Very good service & great burger/​buffalo chicken. Was really happy with the quality if the local beer selection as well! Will be back soon!

It’s 1:16, this restaurant claims that it is open until 2:30 pm but they are closed. Gahanna has no restaurants open passed normal city hours. To say you are open till 2:30am is absolute bull shit.

This place has some solid bar food. I’d probably give it a 3.5 due to some service issues, but it wasn’t a huge deal since they gave us a bit of a discount, so I’ll round it up to 4. Signatures is located right in the heart of downtown Gahanna across from the new Pigskin Brewery, and it has some great patio seating in the front facing Mill St. as well as the back where there looks to be a stage for live music. The inside is fairly large and has TVs on all the walls for some great sports viewing, and the bar looked to be stocked with local brews on tap! If this was a little closer to my ‘hood, I’d probably be here all the time.
As far as the food goes, it’s pretty straight forward pub grub with sandwiches, burgers, wings, etc. My buddy and I went with the buffalo chicken sandwich; mine was fried (of course) and his was grilled. I opted for the Hot sauce on mine, and it comes with tomatoes and onions and ranch or blue cheese dressing on the side. Well, the server thought we had ordered salads apparently, so those came out and we had to send them back. Luckily, the place was pretty much empty, so it didn’t take too long to get new food. It happens.
The sandwiches were both tasty, and they gave me three, fairly large chicken strips on mine. The hot sauce had a nice kick to it, and I really like their ranch dressing. Had I not had to go back to work, this would have been awesome with some drinks. The fries that came with it were super tasty as well, and we both really loved our meal overall.
We’ll definitely be back here to try some other options, especially the wings which looked delicious. It’s actually a nice and quick place to grab lunch during work, especially compared to Gahanna Grill which was packed last week when we went in. If you live in the Gahanna area or anywhere close and are looking for a great bar to chill or watch some games, this would be my suggestion by far. The beer options and food along with the walls decked in TVs make it a top notch sports bar.
P. S. You can help yourself to free popcorn while you wait!

Everything you are looking for in a hometown bar. Good food, great pizza, great beer!

food was good. service was horrific. I understand that it was Creepside tonight but there is no excuse for us to wait 30 minutes just for our bill. Out waitress clearly forgot about us and we asked a couple of times for our check.
This was my first time here and I really like the atmosphere. unfortunately because of the service I will not be coming back.

Pretty good food and has a nice casual atmosphere but wish the live music was not so loud. It makes it hard to have a conversation with friends. Great drinks and great service.

I have been to Signatures a few times due to some work I’m doing running a local political campaign. I’ve taken a liking to the joint as it has a decent selection of beers on tap, a great set of spaces for hosting events, and the food isn’t too bad either.
Hosting an event at Signatures was really easy and they were all ready for us when we showed up. I had a fundraiser here with around 12 – 15 people or so and they handled us very well with courteous and quick service. On top of that we had access to a stage space which was a nice bonus.
My experience with the food is so far pretty decent. On my last trip I had the philly quesadilla which was essentially philly steak ingredients wrapped up in a tortilla. It worked out pretty well, and while a little greasy the flavors were definitely pleasant.

Changed ownership, who decided to cut costs by making the, formerly, great food a lesser quality than you could get at most fast food places.

Went here again yesterday after Paws in the Plaza event. Food is good. Atmosphere is relaxed. Lots of cute dogs hanging out. Had burger this time-​was not medium as requested but juicy all the same. Service still slow but for some reason only one waitress handling whole patio. Give that girl some help!

Great staff, pizza chips rocked, burger was perfect. Wings were hot as advertised — jalapeño bottle caps are to do for. Love the craft beer selection

I came here for the first time this evening for a Girl’s Night & was disappointed with the experience. The waitress was prompt and friendly, which I appreciate. When we received our food order of jalapeño bottle caps and nachos everything was burnt! We sent the food back quicker than I could take a picture but I would not make this up; the fried jalapeños were as black in color as the bartop where we were sitting and the «nachos» had little to no cheese, burnt chips on half of the plate and tasted exactly like burnt popcorn. Now us ladies are respectful and courteous but felt strongly that our food should be remade (we had not taken more than a bite of each dish) the server was nice enough to have the OWNER come out & speak with us & we were treated more like an inconvenience. No apology or empathy was shown but instead he replied «I mean, we’ve never heard of it being a problem» in summary this will be my last time visiting Signatures for an intended good evening out.

Their pizzas are pretty good. Good bartender. It can get noisy but it is a bar after all. I miss seeing bands play there but it’s understandable due to the noise level. There is a pretty nice back patio. You can sit in front too & people Creekside. I like going for the after work drink.

Restaurant was extremely understaffed tonight. Wasn’t very crowded but with only one bartender and one server, the hostess had to take drink orders and tables. Took upwards ten minutes for me to receive the beer that I ordered, though the appetizer followed quickly thereafter.
Food wasn’t bad, standard pub fare. When we were finished, we had to wait for a server to stop to offer us boxes. She dropped boxes and one check at 7:25, didn’t check with our group of 4 if we needed it split, for that matter, didn’t stop back at all. At 7:40, we picked up our cards and I paid the bill in cash just so we could leave.
Most probably won’t return.
Update: lowering this to a one star because after eating here, my fiancée and I were swapping positions in the bathroom throughout the night getting sick.
Will not return.

Good hometown bar that has been around for ages. Love the thin crust pizza if that’s your thing. Not sure if they have it all the time, but there is a giant projection screen during big games which makes this bar a great gathering place for sports viewing. Docking a star for the service which is frankly not that great.

Great place to hang out. And watch the games! Great for people who live in Gahanna. Good drink deals, friendly staff. No diet food here!

I have heard a lot about this place but was less than satisfied. Myself and some friends who were in town from NY stopped in after work for happy hour. It reminded me of my grandmother’s house. Really not much character and a bit dark. Its a a bar, with food and patio. Average age in the bar before we arrived was 58.
After leaving, we ventured across the street and found a spot called Local Cantina. Lots of young professionals but served only can domestic beers. No domestic on tap either. Much better vibe and great $ 3.00 fish tacos. Kinda pricey on beers.
To close the night we found a gem called Arepazo (same street as Signatures). Best Latin food I have ever had in Columbus. Ice cold beer and friendly staff. Small patio. Very friendly owner. It is my new favorite spot in Gahanna. Beautiful décor.

It’s a bar with good bar food. The sandwiches are varied and very good. The kids love the pizza and free popcorn. They have an appetizer that I love, fried potatoes with cheese and peppers. Very family friendly during dinner hours but generally no crazy kids running around.

My favorite local hangout in Gahanna. If you are looking for elegant, high end food and all top shelf drinks then go across the street… This place is the best food for the buck, great sports entertainment and some of the friendliest staff in town. It’s a very comfortable place to hang out for a beer or take the kids for wings after the game.
My all-​time favorite is the hot buffalo wrap with steamed veggies (fries when I’m feeling decadent). Also, try the hot mixed with barbecue… Can’t miss!

Pasta chips are amazing. Fried pizza dough tossed in garlic salt with a side of dipping sauce. Add that to a great happy hour special and you are in salty heaven!
The pizza is pretty good as well. Try pineapple onion :)
The highlight is the back deck which has 2 tiers and a nicely-​kept outdoor bar.
Staff is always friendly — this is a family-​owned place and it shows. It may be the unwitting star of ‘Creekside Gahanna.‘
Kids are welcome within reasonable hours and you’ll often see adult league softball teams come in for a pint and a pizza.
Prices are right.
*Closed on Sundays, which stinks, b/​c that’s when I’d love to spend a leisurely afternoon.*