Three Guys Pies

Great pizza and ah-​mazing garlic knots!
Ordered the cheese pizza to go, 14″ for $ 14: cheap, simple, quick and delicious. I particularly enjoy the thin crust, a little dense around the edge but overall, still very chewy!
The garlic knots ($ 5.50) here is the BOMB! They are loaded down with garlic goodness with just a touch of basil (each orders comes with cheese and tomato dipping sauce). The best part of the knots was the bread, they are exceptionally soft and chewy *love*!
The service was great, all smiles and friendly servers. I was in and out the place within 15 mins, definitely be back to sample more of their pie!

The large pizza on Thursdays are only $ 18. We ordered the combination and it was loaded with toppings. It was pretty good, but what makes this place off the chain is their garlic bread knots. Really garlic-​y with hot toppings such as marina sauce and cheese. Service is also really good.

I work next door and I come here every now and then when I feel like feeding myself and all my co workers. We all love this place!
Today, I ordered a large pie with half and half toppings. They accidentally forgot the other topping, however, they took care of me by making another medium pie with the other topping that I requested. Thanks for doing the right thing!

Three guys pies and 1 sweet lady who works here! When we first walked in, already welcomed by her sweet presents. Not only that, she offered us free garlic rolls and cannoli!!! I wish I have got her name., but I’m sure she Is the only girl that works there. Could be the manager maybe?
She recommended the Philly cheesesteak pizza and we half it with butterfly shrimp pie! It was absolutely hella good!!! So filling, I only had 2 slices!!!
Def would come back here for the awesome pizza and of course the awesome customer service!!!:)

The vegetarian pizza was a bit overwhelming with diced onions. The pizza crust was a bit undercook.
Garlic fries were perfect & served with three different sauces.
The cashier and cooks were very friendly & accommodating.
Look forward to return visit to try their other menu items.

First of all, their large is the largest pizza I have ever had. This was as big as Captain America’s shield. (Forgive my Civil War reference, the movie was awesome and Iron Man was playing on their TV). Between the hunger of my friend and I, we finished all but two slices. Second of all, it was probably one of the most delicious pizzas. We got half of the Three Guys signature Pie and half of he chicken pesto pizza. The sauce, the crust, the cheese, the fresh ingredients– all just perfect for a pizza. We had a cannoli for dessert and that was icing on the cake.
Parking was easy and there is plenty of seating. The pizza was ready in about 15 minutes.

Came for lunch on a weekend with a couple friends. It’s not a big place but I think most people get pizza as takeout. There’s maybe 5 tables or so. We took our time and decided what to get. Then we ordered at the counter, paid and waited for our food to be brought out. So you can get half and half on a pizza, which is nice so you can try different options. We opted for the 14′ size with the namesake, three guys (with sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms) and the butterfly shrimp on the other half. The three guys is normal, typical. I preferred the shrimp. The shrimp was like grated or minced very small and spread all over the slice so you get shrimp in every bite. It’s different too — I’ve never had a shrimp pizza before. It’s thin crust so I was able to eat two huge slices. Oh and we started off with the dogonits appetizer, which is a twist on their famous garlic knots. It’s garlic knots wrapped around little hot dogs. We quite enjoyed them. I think an order comes with 6 because the three of us got two each. I could’ve eaten the whole plate of it though. Haha. We finished off the meal with their mini cannolli. An order also comes with three minis (or one big one) so again perfect for splitting. Oh and for drinks they have fountain drinks and my personal fav, the San Pellegrino Italian sodas. Overall a very nice meal. Service was good and I didn’t feel like we waited too long. I would come back for their garlic knots and to try their other pizza options. In an area full of Asian food, this is a welcome change.

If you are complaining about the taste and crust of this pizza you can go back to Domino’s, byyeee!
We moved to Fremont from the east coast, and have been searching for comparable pizza for 8 very long years. This pizza is by far the most comparable to NY pizza that we have experienced in the area. Delicious and very fresh! Everything we have tried so far has been amazing.

Overrated, overpriced, and lacking quality service. My brother and I fed into the hype and ordered their signature garlic knots and a pesto special pizza. Should’ve tried out the garlic knots before committing to a whole pizza as well. The garlic knots were mostly dough with no hint of garlic flavor despite the pieces of garlic on top. Such a disappointment. The disappointment continued when we started eating the pizza, which to no surprise was more dough than flavor. Who would’ve thought a pizza with pesto would taste more like a dough? I strongly advise you to look into alternative pizza places to satisfy your craving.

Best Italian food in town. With only a handful of Italian options, I think Three Guys Pies puts out the best. It’s not pretty. It’s not big. But these guys make the pastas and the pizzas and what nots well. I’ve dined in (did I mentioned it’s not a big space) at one of their few tables, I’ve gotten take out, and I’ve eaten it catered. NEVER disappointed!
Sometimes hole in the walls are THE BEST. These guys, they’re doing it right.
If you’re looking for kale salad or quinoa, this is not for you.

The Philly’s are massive! I’ve been here twice and I’d have to say: the first time I was not so enthused with the customer service. I wanted an exchange /​refund for the garlic knots because I did not find them too flavorful, the owner came out and spoke with me to ask what the problem was. It seemed more like a confrontation but I got the exchange and I enjoyed my Cannoli instead. I’m giving four stars because I really like the food, demographic and aesthetic of the place. One tip to the management is to be a little less argumentative. I can’t change the way your garlic knots taste to ME, I understand that many others love them, but please just give me something else in exchange so I’ll feel more inclined to return to your business.
Back to the Philly’s, they’re massive! Tasteful! I love them! So much so that my buddy and I ordered a second round. The person who cooked them asked how they were and thanked us for the compliments, that’s a bit better on the customer service aspect. Thanks!

Pizza place at an Asian mall? I was suspicious of the rating at first. It’s definitely just my prejudice! Their Brooklyn based recipe came through and is most excellent. It is a family owned business and it shows in their approach to customer service. I enjoyed my Shrimp pie while my man enjoyed his spicy veggie pie… Yummmm!

Great service, great food. We were a group on 6. We ordered 3 slices of cheese pizza, a calzone, chicken Parmesan, garlic knots, and mozzarella sticks! Everything was great.
Will come back again! I definitely recommend.

Seriously?! I’ve been looking for a solid Italian place for the better part of four months since my company relocated be here for a temporary project. I spied this spot on Unilocal.Spend me the 20 minute drive from Hayward. It’s fabulous
Hand breaded chicken parm with gravy that’s equally impressive. Garlic knots were chewy and delightful.
Try this place out folks!
Update: came back again only to find that a private party had ordered 300 pizzas which they were very diligently putting together when I walked in
I was politely informed that they were closed to the public as a result, to which I expressed my regret. Committed to coming back tomorrow to satisfy my craving, I turn to leave and was asked to wait. The owner came out from behind the counter and apologized personally for my inconvenience. Super kind guy, that Chris.
When was the last time you had excellent food and great customer service?!!
See you soon

Overall, pretty good pizza. Not the best you’ll ever have, but it does do the NY pizza flavor justice. The slices are huge, quality pretty good, and service just about average.
I came here for a pick up with my cousin today, and it was pretty smooth. No fuss or muss. In and out and pizza in my mouth in no time at all. The 18 inch pizza is huge! Much bigger than I imagined for some reason. A good family size.
If you like NY style pizza and are in the area, then I suggest giving it a shot.

I had no idea this little gem was in our neighborhood! I always thought we didn’t have any good pizza in the Warm Springs District of Fremont. The other pizza joints in our area are not good, but this place just rocks!
I came in for national Pizza Day, 2÷9÷16. Ordered a couple of slices and the garlic Knots that everyone raves about. I was not disappointment. Im glad i cam across this place as we can now order delivery on game days!!!

Believe the hype!
Garlic Knots — if you love garlic and aren’t planning to kiss anyone after dinner, then you must really try these, they are so good and addicting.
Three Guys Pie: Pepperoni, mushrooms and sausage– This pizza was tasty, and I loved the crust!
Butterfly Shrimp Pie: Shrimp, olive oil, garlic, basil and mozzarella — I was super nervous about ordering a shrimp pizza, but my son convinced me to do it, and I’m glad that we did! This is a delicious combination.
Service was outstanding! and we were given 2 free cannolis which was really nice of them! They are amazing by the way!
Highly recommend ;)

Three guys, a girl or two, some jesting, some obliviousness. Everybody working behind the counter is there to have a good time, though, so I’m attesting brotherhood and camaraderie here. It’s amusing that in a Chinese dominated shopping center in the Indian populated city of Fremont, that there are guys easily mistaken for foolhardy Jersey Boys serving up New York slices and grub here. Ever ask why New York pizza is often so greasy? It’s pizza for the greaseballs of the world, I tell you.
My wife has been here more often. I’ve had it twice. She says it’s the BEST CASUAL CALZONE SHE’S EVER HAD, meaning, it’s the best she’s ever found in a cheap hole-​in-​the-​wall. For hole-​in-​the-​walls, I don’t find it so cheap. I had a bite of it, it’s like this marinara-​laced burrito, the kind that’s yummy for few bites until you start soaking in it too deep. Don’t get me wrong, I can see why she thinks it’s terrific. But the rest of everything else to me is just adequate. Less than adequate is the care that went into the crummy bathroom facility — geez, it’s such a guys’ café, and I mention this, not because it’s all that deplorable, but because it’s funny and simply unattractive if you see it. #crabbywhiteguy

Three Guys Pies happens to be my favorite pizza joint in Fremont and probably the East Bay. The fact that they are owned by the same people who own Colosseum New York Pizza was definitely a big plus and made me more interested in trying them. The interior is a bit similar to Colosseum, this place is set up like a true New York pizzeria. Everything from the pizza ovens to the New York pictures and memorabilia on the walls and of course the televisions for your entertainment. That lovely smell of pizzas baking just draws you in and it helps that the staff is super nice and greet you as soon as you hit the door. Everyone here is extremely nice and personable, they are good at giving their recommendations and suggestions as well.
This initially was just my go to cannoli joint since they do make the best cannolis ever! But then I steered away from that and started trying their food and now I’m hooked I tell ya! Their garlic knots are just amazing, they aren’t doughy or heavy compared to other places. They are fluffy and cooked to perfection, with a very generous amount of garlic and cheese then served with a side of their delicious tomato sauce for dipping. These garlic knots alone will have you addicted and coming back for more, guaranteed. Not only are the knots good but so is their pizza that they sell by the slice. Slices start at $ 3 and each topping is .25 cents, you can get slices in any variation even the specialties. I really like the Pesto Chicken Pie because it’s loaded with tons of chicken and garlic just how I like and it’s super flavorful. If you like your pizza a little more on the plain side then their White Pie is quite good, nice cheeses, a little olive oil and garlic and it’s all good. Not only do they just have pizza, garlic knots and cannolis but they have quite an extensive menu that seems to get bigger with each visit. They make various pastas (the baked penne is my favorite), strombolis, calzones, chicken wings, cheese sticks and various hot sub sandwiches like the meatball Parmesan sub and pizza steak sub which I hear are popular and very yummy.
Everything that I’ve had here has been amazing and this was definitely a great addition to the Warm Springs neighborhood in Fremont. If you are ever in the area you must stop by, trust me your stomach will thank you.

Instead of trusting my friend’s review, I decided to trust Unilocal’s 4.5 stars. Whoops.
I heard many good things over the years about this place. I believe when they opened, they were a branch off of Colloseum pizza in Milpitas, which I love! Well, fast forward a few years later and I am now working in Fremont. I perused my bookmarks and saw this place. Yes!
The place can be a little hard to find as it it the only Italian joint in a see of Asian restaurants and businesses. It’s basically straight and to the right when you enter the parking lot. When you walk in, it’s no-​frills kinda pizza joint. You basically pick your toppings that you want and they take their cheese pizza, put your toppings on, and then bake it up to warm it. On my visit, I went with my standard Margherita and also a slice of combo. The pizzas were fine, but I think I’d prefer it with not as many toppings. The combo had way too many and I couldn’t fold it.
The one thing I did have an issue with was the service. The guy working there was friendly to me, but I think he had some new people, and he was rude to them. I felt bad. Actually, I couldn’t understand what the lady was saying when she called my name, but she wasn’t rude.
Because their Margerita pizza was decent, I might go back. But, my 2^nd slice will be a standard sausage pizza.