Rosati’s Pizza

Big pizza fan here. Tried Rosati’s the other night and I have to say it wasn’t too bad! We ordered a medium meat mania with double dough and some garlic bread sticks. The pizza was extremely filling! It was ordered for 2 people and we had plenty of leftovers. I wasn’t a huge fan of the double dough crust. It was a bit too thick for my preference and the outer crust was a bit difficult to chew. But the pizza itself was very good. Maybe next time we will order a different style crust-​they offer thin and a chicago deep dish style as well.

Got an order to go — meat mania with double dough. Being a first timer I figured this would be more of a traditional crust as they have thin, double dough, and Chicago deep dish. Not a huge fan of the crust but the toppings and sauce were pretty good! Next time I’ll try the thin crust. We also got the garlic bread sticks which were pretty good as well. It’s a little more expensive but it’s quite filling and pretty good. Would definitely try again.

Great pizza but the rest of the menu leaves much to be desired… The wings in particular are atrocious, soggy abominations. Sandwiches are decent if uninspired and the pasta is very inconsistent.

The staff was friendly, the service time was spot on. The beer battered cod was very good. Will definitely eat there again.

At long last this St Louis transplant and new Wisconsin resident has found a pizza worth ordering — great flavor, terrific sauce and the right balance of toppings with a buttery crust. Yum-​o.

Best pizza! We have tried the thin crust, the pan, the Chicago style and the are all delicious. This is by far my favorite pizza and I’ve lived all over the country. The thin crust is crispy, but not too much. I’m trying to find a copycat recipe for the sauce and the ingredients they use are high quality. Delivery to our house normally takes an hour and we are about 4.5 miles away, it is worth the wait and we always plan ahead. Utilize their coupons to save a few dollars. Whenever I call to order the person answering the call has always been very pleasant and efficient. Your phone number is saved in their system so they have your address right away. 40 minutes until ours is delivered tonight! Highly recommended.

WOW!!!
Have had an opportunity to have Rosati’s pizza once, several days ago, and as I write this review I can honestly say I am salivating wanting their pizza again.
Had one of their stuffed pizzas, and it reminded me very much of a pizza place near my hometown.
Definitely costs a little more than your run-​of-​the-​mill chain pizza place, but SOOOO worth it.
Absolutely will be getting their pizza again. I would recommend to a friend.
Note: Rosati’s in Hales Corners only offers take-​out.

They are a little more money than other chain pizza restaurants, but they are so worth it! The Panzarottis (calzones) and salads are perfect. The Rosati’s salad is my favorite and can be a meal all by itself-it’s so huge and full of veggies and protein. Looking for a meal for the family? Ask for the family meal deal. You get an extra-​large, 2-​topping pizza, garlic bread, and a 2-​liter of soda for $ 19.99. It’s so much food! If you want delivery, it can take up to an hour depending on how busy they are, so just plan accordingly. Also, go online for the free delivery coupon or others they have available. Everyone should check this place out! :-)

Good pizza, and good deals but I’ve been frustrated when whoever takes my order on the phone rarely tells the delivery driver about my request that they call my phone rather than ring the doorbell when they arrive. It may sound trivial, but I’ve explained that ringing the doorbell agitates my dog to the point where I have to wrestle him into another room before answering the door. A nuisance that could be resolved by the person taking the order relaying a request that has been met by other delivery places, and reflects their level of service.

The meat is pretty delicious. But a little too greasy for my taste. All in all an OK pizza joint.

I usually get a double dough chicken Alfredo pizza with noodles on it. Best pizza ever! It’s not on the menu but you can just ask for white sauce instead of red. If I’m in the mood for a sandwich it’s either the chicken parm or Italian beef with cheese. So good!

Not sure if these are the same owners as the one that uses to be on 98^th & Oklahoma (which is now Pizzaria Scotty’s). I used to order from the old joint and it was always good… so good every time one of my friends was in town we had to order and he’d order another to take home. So I had no qualms about ordering the Rosatti’s name when the pizza mood hit. Hooooolleeeeeyyy cow… such a difference and not in a good way. I ordered what we usually did, double dough, sausage and mushrooms. The crust was horrid. No flavor at all and reminded me of a saltine cracker. I LOVE pizza crust and ended up throwing theirs away it was that bad. The bottom was nonexistent to the point my husband thought he grabbed a piece where the toppings slid off and went back to the box looking for the crust he left behind. It was so poorly sliced, you couldn’t even figure out how to grab a piece. Greasy beyond belief too. Honestly it was the worst pizza I’ve ever had… would have been better off with a Tombstone frozen.

Love this place — one pound shrimp dinner is excellent, cheese tortilini rocks, and the pizza is great… this place gets busy…

I went to Rosati’s the other day to pick up lunch. I thought I would try something that I normally don’t get. After looking at their manu, which has a great deal more than any «pizza place» I been to before, I went with the chicken parmigiana. This was great! The chicken was not over cooked and the pasta that it came with was perfect. If you are looking for a nice meal try the chicken parmigiana. I will next be trying their new Chicago style dogs.

After a children’s birthday party at the near-​by Jump Zone, we picked up a pizza and breadsticks for dinner. It was delicious! First, the smell when you walk in to pick up your order is amazing. I felt like I was in a NYC pizzeria. I want to try the calzone next time!

Seriously one of the best pizza places in the area. Perhaps being a take-​out/​delivery only allows them to focus on doing it right. Locally owned, Rosati’s is several steps above the chains. The thin crust pizza is really good; the veggie pizza is awesome. Although Rosati’s has a huge menu, my friends and I always go with good intentions — to try something new — but usually end up with pizza. On occasion we order the Friday fish fry special that’s really one of the better fish fry choices. Not all places can fry fish well, but Rosati’s, a pizza place, does it right. The lunch menu — a slice of pizza and a drink is the perfect size — and when the weather is nice, the outdoor table makes it near ideal.

they deliver, and fast. pizza is okay. ive had much better. stay away from the sandwiches. italian beef was very unflavorful.

This is quite simply the best delivery pizza in the area.
I’m pretty sure this store moved from 98^th and Oklahoma, which was a good location until it closed, pretty sure this one opened right around the same time.
Great pizza, great toppings. Thin crust is excellent, the sauce is superb. Usually they’ll include a coupon for free garlic pizza dough strips on your next purchase, also highly recommended.
Main downside is that they’re bloody expensive, but sometimes that’s something you can ignore. In this case, you can ignore it, the pizza’s great.