The Jolly Roger On The Beach

Fort Myers Beach, United States

4.7

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 239-314-5608
Address:
19051 San Carlos Blvd 19&20, Fort Myers Beach, FL, 33931
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
Yes
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Accepts Bitcoin
No
Good For
Dinner
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Quiet
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
Yes
Caters
Yes

Today

Today –
Local time (Fort Myers Beach) –

Business hours

Monday –
Tuesday –
Wednesday –
Thursday –
Friday –
Saturday –
Sunday –

Description

Specialties

Known for the ‘Finest’ thin crust pizza. The dough is rolled fresh daily, the sausage is hand mixed, the sauces are all homemade as well as all the dressings. If you want the best thin crust this is the place to go. The Italian beef and Italian subs are also delicious.

History

Established in 1947.

The Jolly Roger was opened in Champaign/​Illinois in 1947 by Maxine and Raymond Timpone. Michael Timpone, their son took over the family business and successfully ran it until 2006. He moved to Fort Myers Beach and decided to open a Jolly Roger ‘on the beach’ December of 2013.

Meet the Business Owner

Michael T.

Business Owner

Parents started Jolly Roger restaurant in Champaign-​Urbana Illinois in 1947. I took over restaurant in 1986. Moved to Fort Myers Beach and opened Jolly Roger ‘on the beach’ in December 2013. Known for the ‘finest thin crust pizza’ and Italian beef.

Related places

Explore similar places:
1
mi
Beach Bums
1190 Estero Blvd
1
mi
Rays Pizza
118 Crescent St
1.4
mi
Perky’s Pizza
2801 Estero Blvd
1.5
mi
Pietro’s Pizzeria
2943 Estero Blvd
1.6
mi
Junkanoo On the Beach
3040 Estero Blvd
2.7
mi
Busters Sports Tavern
16681 Mcgregor Blvd Unit 401

Nearby

Near this location:
1
ft
Gulf Coast Cellphones
19051 San Carlos Blvd
250
ft
Moose Lodge 964 of Ft Myers Beach
19090 San Carlos Blvd
280
ft
Leisure American Realty
19050 San Carlos Blvd
370
ft
Dream Your Ink Tattoo
19170 San Carlos Blvd
430
ft
Afa Auto Rental
19011 San Carlos Blvd
800
ft
Tip Top Welding
1145 Main St Ste 2

20 reviews of The Jolly Roger On The Beach

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Avon, IN
We got the taco pizza and added bacon. It was really good. It’s your average pizza place but has good food. Staff was friendly as well.
Place rating: 5
Fort Myers, FL
My absolute FAVORITE pizza in SWFL! Don’t let the location and building fool you… they know how to cook a perfect pizza.
I have ordered from here 10+ times. Some delivery some pickup but all orders resulted in fabulous pizza nights! If you like thin, crispy pizza then this place will become your favorite too. The pizza is cut into thin rectangle slices. The Hawaiian and the Meatlovers are my favorite. The side salads are fresh and plentiful. They also offer a small selection of appetizers, sandwiches and pasta.
Locally owned and family operated. They are a very nice family and go out of their way to ensure you are happy with your meal.
Place rating: 5
Saint Joseph, IL
Great pizza with a very thin crust that was very tasty. Generous toppings made it delicious. We had pepperoni, mushrooms and onions and loved every bite. We also had a salad with homemade dressing. The French dressing almost looks like an Italian dressing and it was amazing. Location is not the best but the food is definitely worth the trip.
Place rating: 5
Fort Myers, FL
I ate here on a recommendation of a close friend and I am so glad I did! I ordered carry out on a Friday night and I was so surprised that there was only a 15 minute wait.
When we arrived to pick up the pizza, there wasn’t any one in the restaurant and it made me a little nervous but there was nothing to worry about!
The pizza was SO GOOD! It was a little cold when we got home (nothing a quick heat up in the oven couldn’t fix — and I think it was because it was we live 15 minutes away). It was so, so delicious.
I will be ordering it again and will let all my friends know about it!
Just FYI– it says it’s on the beach but it’s actually before the bridge.
Place rating: 4
Valrico, FL
Nice place, good thin pizza. New York style, wife approved. Friendly staff. Very tasty toppings. Good find.
Place rating: 5
Bucktown, Chicago, IL
Best pizza I have had in years (and I live in Chicago). Excellent service. We had cheese, sausage and mushroom, vegetarian, and Italian beef pizza and all were delicious. We left fatter and happier. Definitely recommend this place and worth it to travel to. Delicious! We can’t wait to visit again on our next trip.
Place rating: 5
Lancaster, OH
Pizza was awesome and the service was outstanding!!! Great place to eat pizza and a salad.
Place rating: 4
Naples, FL
My wife and I had dinner here. We had side garden salad, which we split. Pretty standard salad, except the French dressing (which was homemade) was really good. Our waitress brought us the French, even though we ordered Italian dressing (which was also good), so kudos to her. For pizza, we ordered the works and it was very good. Homemade sausage was very tasty, little spicy. Definitely recommend this place.
Place rating: 3
Fort Myers, FL
Crispy thin pizza for sure at this place. The only issue is the oven temp is so hot to get the crust crispy it kinda obliterates the sauce and cheese on top. Maybe they should add more cheese to the pizza. Since the sauce is thin it needs more taste. Only pizza I have eaten in a while that I used salt. A few tweaks and they will have an excellent product.
Place rating: 5
Fowler, IN
Excellent pizza, cute clean place. Will absolutely go again! Great thin crust pizza without an over whelming amount of topping! Perfect.
Place rating: 5
Kent, OH
Love Illinois THIN CRUST. Never had yours, but we will be back … probably every other day! I used to think deep dish Malnatis was the ONLY pizza from Illinois. But Jolly Roger is just like Home Run Inn, Maria’s or other thin crust pizzas that believe the toppings and a crisp crust are the bomb. One tip… offer the italian beef «hot» — more seasonings! Overall, New Yorkers, Ohioans, Illinoisans, Indiana folk, you will love it this transported Champaign Urbana place.
Place rating: 5
New York, NY
HANDS DOWN BEST PIZZA IN TOWN. If the Jolly Roger was in a better location, its phenomenal pizza would be drawing mammoth crowds and creating huge lines. It is by far the best pizza I have had in Fort Myers. Since that may not be saying much, I’ll also state that it rivals the trendy pizza joints I’ve visited in New York and Rome. Don’t be put off by its divey look or the empty store fronts nearby. This place is a hidden gem.
They serve pizza with a thin and delicately crispy crust. We had a sausage pizza, which can be hard to find outside the Midwest. It had a just-​right ample amount of sauce, cheese and topping. Their home-​made Italian salad dressing is excellent.
A tip: thin crust pizza should be eaten right out of the oven. Don’t get it delivered. Go there and eat it while it’s hot.
Place rating: 5
Pekin, IL
We just returned from eating at Jolly Roger Pizza. We are definitely glad we gave it a try. The pizza was great! The crust was thin and crispy and you could taste the individual topping ingredients. The staff was very friendly and attentive. We are looking forward to trying some of the other offerings like the Italian beef or the spaghetti and meatballs. The prices are very reasonable and the food quality is very good!
Place rating: 5
Bridgeville, PA
Great pizza near the beach. The crust is paper thin, love it! They deliver, but I would do pick-​up… If you liked Shakey’s Pizza as a kid this darn close…
Place rating: 4
Stockholm, Sweden
Great pizzas with a thin crust and not soaked in cheese. Very friendly staff and for take out you get the pizzas conveniently sliced.
I’ll be back!
Place rating: 5
Fort Myers Beach, FL
Love their thin crust pizza and they cut it in nice bite sized strips. Good Job!
Place rating: 5
Bangor, ME
Excellent pizza — the service was great and the staff was so pleasant and accommodating. Definitely worth a trip for pizza and pasta! b
Place rating: 5
Fort Myers, FL
They deliver– which is awesome when you don’t want to make the trip over the bridge, the staff was friendly, and the pizza was really good. I have a kid who doesn’t like pizza and she got spaghetti and meatballs and loved it. The portion was huge and came with a substantial sized side salad so she will have a couple meals out of it. Great value for what you get and it’s nice to have pizza that isn’t all dough like absolutely everything else here in southwest Florida.
Place rating: 4
New York, NY
This pizza is pretty good. Different but good. Super crispy. Fresh ingredients. Good taste. Friendly staff. Took about 30 minutes for take out. TV and beer. Florida décor of fish which is different for me to see in a pizzeria being from NJ.
Place rating: 5
San Francisco, CA
Best pizza in the states! We always go with the sausage. The Italian beef is great too.
It’s worth the drive over the bridge.