Times Square Pizza

Great pizza Hit the spot very reasonably priced. Got the pepperoni pizza this time. Will stop back if we get in the area again

I’m not saying it’s my favorite pizza, but it’s far from the worst. There are so many delivery options in my neighborhood I figured they deserved a chance. An interesting thing about this pizza, which BTW was delivered in a very timely manner and still pretty warm — a good sign, but there was something in the sauce and flavor of the toppings that reminded me of a regular Italian meal like pasta (more to the point lasagna or rigatoni). You might ask, in what regard? Simply put, it tastes better a few hours later in the fridge or even better the next day — this is really one of those pizza flavors that grow on you and taste better after a little time has passed — and that’s always a good thing… if there is any left over to begin with!

If you like thin crust pizza ask for extra thin. Wow, just right. Hot Sandwiches are all terrific… Sausage, chicken parmesan, meat Ball, all great and larger than other local joints. My take out favorite for a quick Italian meal.

false advertising i’m less than 2 miles away and they won’t even deliver to me this place sucks.

Great New York Style pizza! Definitely recommend!

I ordered a small ham calzone for delivery. It came luke warm at best. When I cut into the calzone, there was no sign of steam, so obviously it was not hot enough. The portions of both the ham & cheese inside the calzone were extremely skimpy. The dough was tough — not flaky & fresh. The gentlemen that took my order over the phone was cordial. He quoted 30 — 45 minute delivery and it arrived right at the 45 minute mark — so they met their promise. The size of the calzone was appropriate, but my main disappointment was in the quality of the food — very much a letdown.

Always great pizza. You could not find nicer people, or better food. Times Square is an excellent, consistent place to eat.

Amazing veggie subs and pretty good pizza. Good prices.

if you’re gonna call yourself Time Square Pizza, it better make me relive my first NY pizza experience. NY pizza it’s not, but it tasted ok.

I’ve heard a lot about this place… the Pizza is good but the place is unsanitary. I decided to check it out for myself. I walk in craving pizza and cheese fries, so I ask the guy at the counter, «do you have fries»? He had the nerve to answer me, «we are not McDonalds»!! I’m an educated woman, I know I’m not in McDonald’s. Is McDonald’s the only place that sell fries. The guy was a total wise guy who took me for a chump! I will never walk foot in this place again, nor recommend anyone ever to eat there.

Best pizza in Fort Lauderdale. Just like back in NYC! The crust is thin and crunchy and this sauce is just a little sweet from the basil. Pizza is Always cooked perfectly. They are a busy shop but always seem to arrive in under 45 minutes.
You can also eat in, the have 3 – 4 tables. They also make some pasta and sandwiches though I“ve never tried.

Good pizza and sandwiches. The staff and owner are very friendly as well. One of my favorite lunch spots.

Great pizza, with fast delivery. Meatballs are definitely homemade, and delicious ! Haven’t had a bad meal yet from here. Absolutely worth trying.

I just tried this place for the first time. I have to agree with some of the other reviews. I did not like the tomato sauce this place uses. I did enjoy my 4 cheese pizza with ham and garlic. But I know I can find better pizza somewhere else. I might come back one more time to try something else but not pizza.

These Unilocal reviews are deceiving. There is no way this pizza deserves four stars. The crust is doughy and nothing like New York style.

I can’t believe how many positive reviews for this place!
The sauce was inedible and the cheese was really low quality. It tasted like a bad/​low quality freezer pizza.

Excellent service, but I have to say the caprese salad and the pepperoni pizza we ordered were not up to part. The pizza was a bit saggy and the caprese salad didn’t have balsamic vinegar that it comes with in every other Italian place we’ve visited before (maybe that is the way they do it, yet it tasted bland and simple). The pizza flavor was awesome, but the combination of a saggy pizza and paper plates make for a big mess and sometimes the wet paper would stick to the pizza.

Ducked with with Johnny D. to get a slice and it was great because:
* A pepperoni slice was HUGE.
* Packed and stacked with pepperonis
* Came out fast!
* Johnny bought!
* Conveniently located at Oakland Park and Useless 1
I love big, hand tossed, authentic pizza pie, baby, none of this corporate stuff. Score!
They could put a couple bucks into keeping the place looking new, but that’s just my opinion.
Cabeza out, regretting I hadn’t visited sooner!

My husband and I love this place. We have been going there for 4 years and have never been disappointed with the pizza. Our preference is the large cheese with half meatball. I never was a fan of meatball until trying how this place does it. I am now addicted! I also love the cheesy garlic bread. The garlic has a great flavor however sometimes I feel as if they don’t out enough cheese on it.
I love chicken parmigiana subs but this place doesn’t do it for me. They slice the chicken into thin slices. I personally would rather have the whole chicken cutlet though. the staff there are really nice too.

This little Pizza/​Sub joint takes the prize for first place in the area in two categories.
First the pizza is NY style and I recommend bringing help and ordering the biggest pie possible. Their sausage is great and I usually get double. The place is a hole in the wall and for takeout or very casual dine in it’s great. They only have a few tables but the place is exactly the little type pizza joint you’d find in NY. Their crust is about an 8 on my very critical NY pizza scale of 10 because it is just slightly pastry like (but very good). I do like the very fresh toppings and when you put the pie together I have not found better pizza without going all the way up to Jupiter FL. to Vinny’s on Indiantown Road 70 miles away, kings Pizza in Aventura, or Rice And Dough in Ft. Laud off Broward. (I will go anywhere if I’m convinced it will be great)
Now second and even better are the Italian subs. This may be the best kept secret in Ft. Lauderdale. I decided to try subs from the top three places on Unilocal (for subs). On a whim I went to Times Square Pizza as well making it the fourth place. I brought them all home for the family to blind try and it was unanimous! Times Square has the best Italian sub. I lately have found myself wanting one of their Italian subs and it was truly a joke when I compared it to the «Monster subs» on Sunrise. Monster was NO monster compared to Times Square.
I don’t like my subs toasted and you must say «don’t toast». Their bread is always fresh so in my opinion it’s not necessary but have it your way!
I’m a very picky «foodie» and Italian is one of my favorite categories. Try a «BIG TIME» pizza at Times Square (at Oakland Park BL and Federal Hwy.) and try the #1 best «Italian Sub» I have found so far in Ft. Lauderdale.
I’ll include two pictures so you can see if this meets/​passes your «LOOK TEST»?