Tony’s Restaurant & Lounge

What a dump. We had just eaten for a friend’s birthday and were gonna stop in for drink at 9:30 on a Saturday. The bouncer refused to let us in with our leftovers and was incredibly rude. We sent someone to take the leftovers to a nearby friends house and proceeded in despite the poor start. Went in, didn’t even order one over priced drink because the bar smelled so awful. The condescending rudeness did not stop at the door either. I highly recommend spending your time and money at any of the other much nicer and more enjoyable bars in old town, shut this dump down

Such a terrible establishment! Not only were the bartenders hammered but they took my friends atm card and they came back with waters and not the drinks that were ordered. on top of it all, they claimed that they lost her atm card! OH WAIT THAT WAS AFTER THE DRUNK BARTENDER KICKED ME OUT AND CLAIMED THAT WE HAD IT THE WHOLE TIME! Then to make things worse, THEY CALLED HER A HOUR LATER saying a cocktail waitress had it in her apron, which I never even spoke to, and that my friend could pick it up from their drunk bartenders before last call or the next day! This establishment has such an incompetent staff. WTF!!! This is pathetic and something no one should have ever had to deal with!

One of the worst bars in Fort Collins. The staff is really rude and the bouncers are very disrespectful.

Do not ever go to Tony’s bar in Fort Collins. The bartender tonight kicked me out because I told him his pool table wasn’t working and he got mad. I did not ask for money back. I just told him it wasn’t accepting quarters and he got so mad that he called the cops on me. Some bars in Fort Collins are extremely hateful, but this is the worst one that I have ever experienced. If you want to go somewhere where you feel comfortable, do not go to Tony’s. He got mad because his property was not working and I informed him of it. Never going there again. What a crappy place to try and have fun.
The owner happened to be there and I went to talk to him. He didn’t understand what was going on. I explain the situation and he told me to stop screaming. I wasn’t? I had already paid my tab, asked to pay extra for quarters for pool. The table wasn’t working and the out of order sign was in a pocket. I went to let him know and everything happened. Really poor management. The server was rude too. A piece of crap place.

Pizza is amazing… be prepared, they’re humongous! Courtney is an amazing server and really sweet and accommodating.

The most convenient outside pizza isn’t always the best. We stood in line for ten minutes with only one person in front of us. We ordered two single slices which were sub par. I will not go back.

I’ve tried so hard to hate Tony’s but I just can’t. Tony’s is always there for me when I want to make bad decisions after making bad decisions. I tried their pizza sober for the first time a few days ago and it was just as satisfying. I always ask for a clusterfu*k of toppings and they have never missed a single one. It’s always fast and hot too. When it comes to dranks, yea, they’re not going to concoct some magical elixir for you, but you’re likely to get something that’s not bad for two bucks, TWO BUCKS! Local flagship craft beers are dirt cheap. Couldn’t find a filthy bathroom. Don’t be a hater.

Pizza’s are awesome here. And slices are huge.
Drinks are decently cheap.
Service is great on the first floor, bartenders are rude upstairs.
Pool tables, tv’s in every booth, and gets pretty packed late at night.
Douchey dudes and slutty chicks abound.

I think this place just has a bad reputation. I love it and I’ve never had any problems. The staff is my favorite part. The food is great and the drinks are cheap. I have only ever seen one fight almost happen and they were kicked out immediately. The rooftop is super awesome during the summer. Just give it a chance and be safe just like ever other bar.

Home of the Stiffie — one of the first bars I celebrated being able to legally drink in, and still a stop for me at least weekly although they don’t do the flaming birthday shots anymore. They redid everything, so if you haven’t been in in a few years give her another chance — she is a changed beast. Bartenders are the friendliest in town, the cocktail waitresses are all beautiful and friendly as long as you’re tipping (why would you be out drinking if you can’t afford to tip anyway). ;)
Their pizza slices are HUGE, thin and crispy, delightfully greasy. Their other food is bomb as well — fried pickles YES, gyros are legit, and buffalo chicken salad is one of my fave things on the menu, although I’ve had just about everything and haven’t been disappointed often. This is my home base, I will always either start or end (and sometimes both) my nights out in Old Town at Tony’s. *love*

Great place to hang out anytime of the week. Great food and drinks. Good prices and the place is clean. Staff has always treated me very well.
Forget to mention the great parties on Friday and Saturday nights!

Burnt gyros twice now

Convenient window service when walking College Avenue. Pizza came out pretty quick and was A-​OK. Gyro took longer and was also A-​OK. Gyro had french fries in it, which was a first. Sidewalk seating is very limited.

The real skinny on Tonys. The pizza is good as any other «NY Style» thin crust. The drinks are never under poured. Mixed clientele. College kids. Drunks. Frat guys. Hookers. Young couples. Thugs. Everyone. It’s a melting pot for a place to grab a cheap drink. The downstairs is neat and if you play beer pong they have it on Thursdays. Smoking is no longer allowed upstairs thanks to Fort Collins law. Lack of smoking has kind of killed the vibe on the outdoor patio. Plus they always have $ 2 Jaeger. Come on. It’s better than going to the Rec Room.

Probably the best priced drinks in Old Town. Watch your Friday/​Saturday nights, if you’re not a stand-​all-​night-​crowd person, avoid weekend nights. If you get the chance to meet Tony, it will prove Tony’s legitimacy. Rage on.

I hate the attitude, the people and SMELL of this place. Will NEVER go back in.

So this place USED TO BE considered the «toilet bowl» of bars, and they have done a lot to revamp the place and their image. The floors have been redone and are no longer covered in mystery stains. The booths are new and are cleaned regularly. The rooftop patio is amazing and is great for large groups in the summer. Drink specials are still great (that’s why people came in the first place) and their food has definitely gotten better.

The only downfall… it’s always packed! I few that as a great thing! Tony’s has 2 levels and the upstairs always are on a «one down one up» wait. It usually moves fast and everyone is very friendly while waiting. The bartenders make great drinks with long pours and the waitresses are very nice as well! If you are in town, stop and see Tony! He’ll be there, most likely!

This is a review based solely on the booze because I ate zero food here.
Atmosphere was very chill and college town. Looks brand new inside, but we really came here for the rooftop patio and cheap drinks. Which this place delivered on.
The rooftop patio is pretty large and nicely shaded with green trees and kept cool with a ton of water misters. My bf was hoping for a street view, but no such luck since it’s to the rear of the building it just overlooks parking lots.
However, we still enjoyed the cheap happy hour beers and watched Angels baseball on the big screen TVs above the bar. There were 3 male bartenders on duty and at least 2 waitresses going around, so service was quick. We stayed at the bar and our bartenders were friendly and one even gave me a sample of Summer Shandy when in doubt about what beer to try next.
The bf enjoyed some $ 2 Jäger shots and I stuck with the beer.
Next time we’re in the area I’m pretty sure we’ll stop by.

Oh Tony’s — the more things change, the more they stay the same!
This was my fav bar a decade ago while in college, it still is hella awesome! Haters, keep out. All ya’ll who think your sh*t don’t stink, go wait in line for the club like the jackasses you are. Maybe come back in a few years once you know how to appreciate this gem! Yes the place gets stupid crowded on weekend nights. No, you don’t have to be half naked to get served. And Tony is still hanging around scoping out the scene!
Now I am a girl from the ghetto and I like some personality in my bars, and this one has a lot! There is a shuffle board table, pool tables, a dance floor, and a fancy huge newfangled rooftop. There is no wait to get in, but around 11 on a Saturday night there is a stupid long line (inside) to get upstairs. F that. If u want some rooftop action, go early.
I had some fun w/​the bar tenders, got dirty looks from some skanky smokers who were not supposed to be smoking on the patio, and got a big olé buzz off of some giant amazing freshies! Their t-​shirts are great and the people watching is fun. I have fond memories of chatting up someone only to have last call flash on the brights and make you realize you were talking to a Sasquatch and it is time to bail, good times. Back then it was known as the ‘home of the stiffy’, and the drinks are just as great as ever!
Sass, ass and class Tony’s has it all.