Pie High Pizza

I ordered the 10″ pizza with ham and pineapple. The crust was thin and crispy just the way I like it. However, my friends ordered a gluten pizza and the crust was too chewy and left a bad taste. Also their chopped salad and caprese salads were actually just basic house salads.

Nice sports themed pizza restaurant located in a cute building that also has a coffee shop on the other end of it. There’s parking on the road or in the parking lot behind the building with an entrance on either side. The landscaping in very nice. Lots of benches outside to enjoy the scenery and a few rocking chairs on the porch area. When we went, we walked up to the bar and ordered our food and then chose our own table. You can also sit at the bar. Table tops have paper covering them with a bucket of crayons so you can doodle while you wait for your food. They have beers on tap and also a good selection of bottles beers. They have a variety of other beverage choices. You can get Pepsi products yourself at the fountain or in cans. I noticed they have a few coin games for the kids to play. Theres a few TVs and The Milwaukee Bucks game was on.
We ordered the meatball sandwich and the Friday Night Lights pizza. Our sandwich was great! The bread was lightly toasted and SO fresh! The cheese was put into the bread first then the meatballs, topped with just the right amount of sauce and then sprinkled with a little parmigiano cheese. We had split it and I really wanted more! I could have eaten it all myself! Then the pizza came… we ordered the small size and again, I wanted more! The Friday Night Lights has olive oil, garlic, melty mozzerella AND slices of fresh mozzerella topped with chunks of tomatoes and fresh chopped basil. I normally love pizza sauce on my pizza but I didn’t even miss it at all! The crust was perfectly crisp all the way through. You could tell it was freshly hand tossed. Nice crisp thin crust with great flavor.
We often stay at The Abbey Resort across the street so it’s real close to walk to or drive. We’ve been to Pie High several times before and every time it’s really good! In the past we have ordered the cheese and sausage pizza 5+, the hickory cheeseburger, which is char-grilled…5+ and the cheesy garlic bread (same fresh bread they use for the meatball sandwich) which comes with dipping sauce 5+! We’ve also ordered delivery a few times to The Abbey. They bring it right to your room!
I didn’t catch our waiters name last night but he was very attentive and his service was A+. After we finished we told him how amazing our food was and how fresh the bread was and he said he had just made the bread fresh that morning!!!
Today’s our last day at The Abbey and we’re going again for lunch. Yes. It’s THAT good!!!
I didn’t use the restroom there so I can’t comment on that.
On a side note, if you check-​in on Unilocal and show your waiter, you get a FREE fountain soda with your pizza purchase! Score!
As you can see, I highly recommend stopping in for any of their food. We’ve only had a few things off the menu but I can imagine it’s ALL great! Hopefully you enjoy it as much as we do!

The place smells like a sewage dump. We ordered a pizza and waited about 5 minutes and the smell just hit us. We felt sick just being in there so we left. Save your appetite for a cleaner place.

Not bad pizza, I suppose. The crust was very thin and chewy, but was seasoned nicely. Honestly, it tasted better cold the next morning.

We went to the location in lake Geneva. Service was reasonably quick. I ordered the chop salad which was swimming in water when severed and lacked any flavor. My boyfriend had the chicken bbq pizza which was also a disappoint. The sauce was thin and the chicken was flavorless.

Came here for a quick bite on our way out after Forth of July weekend with friends. Pizza was ok. Agree with other reviewers crust was good. Very kid friendly. Walking distance from the Abbey resort. Would go back.

Took the family to The Abbey Resort and we felt like pizza for dinner. Pie High had good Unilocal reviews so ordered a Hawaiian and a Cheese Calzone. We were unfortunately really disappointed. The crust was like cardboard and tasteless. The sauce and cheese were OK but the cheese slid off the crust. Isn’t that Pizza 101? Maybe the regular cook was sick tonight? Staff was nice, but not a memorable meal. Don’t know if we’d try again next time at the Abbey.

Stayed at the Abby and decided to go in for a pizza
Very nice kid working there and very good hot yummy pizza

While visiting a near by B&B we wanted to order take out pizza, we had driven by this place on the way into town and it looked like a very inviting place.
We placed our order online and then went to get our food not too much longer. It was ready right away and the staff was very friendly. The pizza crust was a little different than I had ever had but absolutely wonderful. The only downside was I would have liked to see field greens instead of iceberg lettuce in my salad. But I would definitely order from them again if in the area.

Wonderfully crispy crust no skimping on the toppings. Easily best pizza we’ve had on the area, puts places like Pino’s to shame. Friendly service and fun vibe. Can’t wait to try their other menu options

My 2^nd 5 star review in the last two days! We were looking for pizza. I Unilocaled and found a few places but most were Chicago style which I am not a fan of. I found another place and we were driving to when we past this place. I liked the outside and they did nothing but pizza (and calzone) so it has to be better than the place we were going to. Glad we stopped. I told the owner his place didn’t come up inYelp. We had the Letterman with sausage pepperoni green peppers onion and black olives. Checked in at Unilocal and got a free soda. Chopped salad as well. Thin crust and crispy. Excellent! All fresh ingredients and you can tell by how the ingredients were cut up it was probably by hand. The sauce was a sauce I have had at other pizzerias. Simple and not over the top or over done with spices. Because of that it didn’t over power the toppings. Friendly service. We were greeted immediately and the apologized for the smoke but even the smoke smelled good. If you are looking for wonderful pizza that isn’t deep dish you need to check Pie High. Across from Pizza Hut. This is what thin crust pizza is about. Not pie style sliced line NY like but I like it cut square because I know the crust is crispy. Check them out and support a locally owned restaurant.

We were staying across the street and Pie High delivered. It was excellent. Lots of cheese! Excellent pepperoni.

Had two pizzas from their Lake Geneva shop on Williams…
Simple 10 inch for grandson Calvin… he liked it!
Sarah and I had the Letterman…16 inch.,…sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green peppers, onions and black olives. Was quite good… thin crust; lots of ingredients; very good.
Will be back…

It’s not Chicago style pizza … But just as good! Crust was nice and thin, basil and feta cheese was excellent! Shared my calzone w/​the wifey … Forgetaboutit!!!

While on a mini get away to Fontana WI, hubby and I dined in at Pie High Pizza. Pie high pizza met our expectations and then some. Hubby and I shared a sausage calzone and cheese, fresh basil and feta pizza. Both were delicious, crust was crispy, tasty and flaky. Venue is small but friendly atmosphere, theme is high school which makes it inviting. They have a shelf full of board games that you can play while waiting for your food. Kid friendly too! Will definitely return.

We came with a big crowd…4 families… everyone loved it! I know they’re famous for pizza, but my burger was delicious!!!

If you’re hungry and order delivery, don’t expect it to come. I placed a single pizza delivery order last night over the phone at 5:00pm…it’s 2:00pm the following day and no pizza, no call, no nothing.

We stopped in on a whim today because our daughter saw the big, smiley tomato on the building. When we walked up we commented on how cute the outdoor space is (shared with the Coffee Mill next door). Through the window we could see, and hear, a large group of employees (6 or 7 of them) gathered around the bar talking. They dispersed before we got in the door leaving one girl running the front. She was friendly and helpful but pretty aloof — giving us the lowdown on how to order.
We picked 2 «freshman» pizzas (10″ each), a chopped salad to share, and one Coors Banquet. The total bill came to $ 35. I thought this was high but reserved judgement for when the food came out.
As we waited, we took in the atmosphere. Our daughter loved the games shelf and the paper on the tables to draw on. The atmosphere fits the theme of a high school hangout but is clean and comfortable. The high school theme seems to carry through to the staff though. It seemed as if there wasn’t a person working over the age of 18. Though I may be getting old because since when can high school kids grow such epic lumberjack beards? The group of employees seemed bored and spent a lot of time leaning and laughing.
We received the chopped salad promptly and I liked it. It was a decent size for the price. We asked for plates and forks to share it and the girl came back with 2 plates and 1 fork, which was odd, but we made it work.
A few minutes later, the pizza came out. They looked good but small for the $ 23 price tag. Now, I’m a Sconnie girl and rarely complain about too much cheese… But on a thin crust pizza it can be the death of a crispy crust. The center pieces were all soggy and limp. The toppings were great though. We got a bbq chicken and one with pepperoni, sausage, and giardiniera. The crust flavor was ok. The bottom had a thick crust of burnt cornmeal on it, but once we brushed it off it was better.
This was honestly going to be a two star review until the epicly bearded kid walked by and casually asked if we liked the pizza. It was the first time we felt like any of the employees cared that we were there.
Overall decent. Our daughter raved about it, so there’s that.

Yikes, what’s with all the bad reviews? My wife and I are new to the area and really enjoyed our experience. We ordered wings and a small pizza and it was the perfect amount of food. The price worked out to be just about right for a place like this so I was pleased. I’m happy to have a fun little restaurant close to home that is intentional with decoration and menu items.
The website, which I think is a third-​party service is having a couple of ordering issues on iOS 7 but I am sure those will he sorted out soon.
We had the Friday Night Lights and hot wings. Both were yummy!

It’s alright, but they could make some improvements. My spinach mushroom calzone was $ 9 after tax and HUGE! But like some have mentioned about the pizza, it was watery inside, and needed a more flavor. It was served with marinara on the side but needed more on the inside. They do use fresh mushrooms and spinach so I was happy about that!
The chilly attitude from the young woman working there was kind of a damper on the «fun little pizza place in a small cutesy town» experience…
Had my first New Glarus beer, the Spotted Cow cream ale on draft for $ 4.75 after tax. Loved it!