Your Pie

Small pizzeria with flair. Made fresh and brick oven crispy the options are almost endless and fresh. There are salads, panini, soup and the kids love the Italian ice cream. Beer and soda on tap, Coke thank you too off the meal. Friendly, not too much, staff are fun and helpful, the store is clean each time we visit and take out is no problem. Bonus for kids meal and smaller adult options. No points for the gluten free dough at $ 4 more on 10 inch pizza. Family and small group per

Great concept and so delicious! We are already making plans to return with the whole family — the combo special makes this super affordable. We love the hipster casual atmosphere too

This Your Pie is our favorite out of the ones in Jacksonville. The crew is always extremely friendly and doesn’t get an attitude if you have picky requests (like I always do). Definitely one of our go-​to dinner places!

Friendly staff, fresh ingredients, amazing Taste! I wish it was a little cheAper since everyone gets their own pizza but it was worth it!

We love everything about this place… except for how much you will spend on all of the great food. This establishment should be in the $$ category on Unilocal.For someone on a budget… Your Pie is a sometimes food.

Service was good. Pizza taste was also good. However it was quite a wait for our GF pizzas and overpriced. The online ad states 2.50 extra for a GF pizza but the store charged us $ 4.00 each extra for GF for all five pizzas we ordered. There is one bathroom for each sex, so always a wait there. Surprised that’s allowed for the seating capacity. When you order your own food and pay there is a tip line? Is there an expectation now that you tip a cashier just for taking your order? What are you supposed to base your tip on? Overall good tasting pizza and friendly staff.

Normally when one goes to a Pizza Restaurant, you sit at a table, the server greets you with a smile, takes your drink order and waits while you look over the menu. Here, think of Your Pie as a «Subway Shop» for Pizzas, Salads, and Pannis where you can choose from various pizzas or create your own from scratch. Can’t go wrong from the various pizza and panni choices.
Your Pie, in Fleming Island, is located at the west end of the Winn– Dixie Plaza.

Awesomeness. We’ve been to a couple of other pizza joints and they just don’t compare.

Crust is rolled out in front of you so dough is very fresh. They’ve perfected their crust and sauces. I been to a similar franchise that wasn’t so as good and no matter what toppings I choose, the pizza couldn’t beat Your Pie. That being said; the pizza is delicious! Their gelato is yummy as well. Staff is friendly. The only reason I’m giving 4 stars vs 5 is meat toppings isn’t included, which can add up if you like meat like myself. The location in ATL has unlimited toppings including meats.

Great place to eat lunch. Staff is cool. Ingredients are quality and if your pizza doesn’t taste good it’s not their fault it’s yours. Great place and Kramer would be happy.

Being a self-​proclaimed food snob, there are only 4 places within a 40 mile radius that I will consider having a meal… I now have the 5^th. Yum…

Absolutely love your pie! From the family friendly atmosphere, to the awesome staff, to the delicious toppings & delectable gelato for desert! My husband enjoys one of their nice cold draft beers as well. We always order the whole wheat dough which is so yummy. The children love playing with the dough balls they give them. The toppings are fresh & delicious and we’ve never been disappointed. They have specials throughout the week that are worth checking out!

So-​so taste. The gluten free pizza is a major yuck. Nice servers but not worth the price if the food is bland. One thing that is pretty cool however, is that the kids meals come with a token for a free gelato, and if you don’t redeem then, you are welcome to bring it back for a later treat.

I love coming here especially with my kids. They love the size and state of the pizzas, I love it also but also love the price and the customer service. The manager is always clearing tables and making sure everyone is happy, definitely visit this place, I hope all franchises are run as well as this one.

Our first visit and we liked it! We had the Aloha (plus pepperoni) pizza, split the huge spinach gorgonzola salad and caramel sea salt gelato. We would recommend and definitely go back again!

Great quality and a wide variety of selections from pizza to salad to panini. A bit costly, but clearly made with ingredients of excellent quality. Worth visiting every now and then. Good portions, specially the gelato; don’t let it fool you, you get a good amount for a ‘small’.

Ok Yeeps let me start by saying that my mom hates pizza. No, she’s not weird, she’s just… how do i say… a health food freak. She doesn’t do greasy, fried, high carb, etc. If I asked her to dip something in ranch dressing, you’d think I asked her to go parachuteless skydiving. That being said when I stumbled upon Your Pie and saw that they not only offered a thin whole wheat crust, multiple sauce and cheese options, but most importantly a virtual playground of veggie toppings… I was in. Convincing mom to try out a new pizza place was no small feat, as you can imagine, but thankfully (though with much reluctance) she agreed to go.
Atmosphere: It’s smaller in size than the Southside location, so go early because it fills up fast. I’ve been here a few times so far, and it’s always clean and well maintained. I like that they have a good selection of both bottled and draft beer available (more than just bud and bud light), because what goes better with pizza than ice cold beer, right? There’s also patio seating outside which is a plus on those perfectly sunny afternoons.
Food: Mom was literally in awe as she feasted her eyes upon the countless veggies available to pile upon her whole wheat crust. She chose the pesto sauce, low fat mozzarella, grilled chicken, tofu, anddd pretty much enough vegetables to open a farmers market. Me? White crust, ranchy marinara, fresh mozzarella and provolone, bacon… bacon…spinach, artichokes, and i’m sure a couple of other things, but i did say bacon, right? I love the crust… I’m not a fan of thick crust pizza, because I feel it detracts from the flavor of all the other components. It’s a thin crust, but not so thin that you think you’re eating a Triscuit pizza. Overall in my opinion everything from the crust, to the sauce and the feshness of the toppings was spot on!
So the verdict is in… she loved it. I was thanking my lucky freakin’ stars. I can now take mom out… for PIZZA. I never thought the day would come *with tears and a slight sniffle.* From the second you walk in you’re immediately welcomed with a warm smile from the staff and it’s great to see that they put alot of love and care into every pizza they prepare. You’re not rushed and if you’re a first timer like mom was, they’ll happily walk you through the process step-​by-​step. I love this place, I’m definitely a fan, and they’ll be seeing me quite often!

Such a cool idea!
Chipotle and subway meet pizza! Pick wheat or white crust, sauce, then choose your toppings. Veggies are no charge unlimited, meats cost a little per item (adds up quickly). It bakes for maybe 5 minutes and they bring it to your table. They also have REALLY GOOD gelato — on Tuesdays or Thursday’s they have a special with the gelato if I remember correctly (sorry can’t remember which day specifically). You must try this place out — it’s one of two locations and it started in Florida.
Oh, and the pizza does taste good ;). Just don’t spill your water on your lap like my wife did to me…

I’m not sure why anyone rated this place a whole star down based on the placed not having a proactive staff cleaning tables?! Get over yourself! Unilocal is about food! To take away a star based on that means you are a #%^*, #endrant. this place was awesome I thoroughly enjoyed the pizza! The concept of making your own pizZa, is awesome. I bopped myself in thinking man why didn’t I think of this. The ingredients are super fresh and the staff was witty! It’s nice to deal with people who don’t take themselves to serious! The pizza is made in a brick oven:) yummy yummy! Go eat and enjoy!

This is a nice addition to the chain restaurants offered in Fleming Island. I came here for an early dinner with my brother and mom since it was still relatively new & we wanted to check out something other than Mellow Mushroom. We were pleasantly surprised to see this cool concept of pizza making where each of us could order «your pie» just the way you like it!
While not the most amazing pizza I’ve ever experienced (that would be Joe’s in the West Village, NYC), it was good for Fleming Island without all the hassle of going to MM for the 1000^th time.
In addition, they offered a gelato dessert with your meal and carry some really great flavors. In fact, I pretty much tried them all. Ask for samples as they were more than happy to oblige me. Overall, it was a good meal at a reasonable price and a gelato for my sweet tooth just sent me over the top. 4 STARS