Fratelli Pizza

Flagstaff, United States

4.2

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards
Free Wi-Fi

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 928-774-9200
Website:
www.fratellipizza.net
Address:
119 W Phoenix Ave, Flagstaff, AZ, 86001
Nearby public transportation stops & stations:
340 ftDowntown Transfer Center
1.9 miFort Valley Rd. / Stevanna Way
2.2 miShoshone Point
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
Yes
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Dinner
Parking
Street
Bike Parking
Yes
Wheelchair Accessible
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
Yes
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
Beer & Wine Only
Outdoor Seating
No
Wi-Fi
Free
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Closed now
Local time (Flagstaff) 21:27 Wednesday, 25 June 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Tuesday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Wednesday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Thursday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Friday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Saturday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm
Sunday 10:30 am – 9:00 pm

Description

Specialties

We offer hand tossed pizza made with Wisconsin Whole-​Milk Mozzarella, Housemade Dough, Sauces, and a wide variety of toppings. Our Specialty Pizzas are the talk of Flagstaff, with the Pesto Cashew and Route 66 BBQ pizza local favorites. Our Calzones are stuffed with up to 4 toppings and are usually enough to provide you with two meals. Sundays are great at Fratelli, as we offer NFL Sunday Ticket and have Slice Specials and Beer Specials all Day. Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, Toasted Ravioli, Breadsticks, and Cheesysticks, are some of the appetizers we offer. Don’t forget our salads too. Check out our menu at www​.fratel​lip​izza​.net

History

Established in 2002.

Opened in June of 2002 in a 450 sq. ft location with seating for 4 by Brothers Pete and Brent Schepper, we were quickly recognized by downtown merchants and employees as the place to go for a quick lunch and giant New York Style Slices. In 2004, Fratelli Pizza opened a 2nd location at 2120 N. 4th Street and in 2006 moved our downtown store to it’s current location. Voted Best of Flagstaff by AZ Daily Sun Readers every year since 2002. Also recognized in Arizona Highways as 25 favorite places to eat in AZ 2011. Newly expanded/​remodeled dining room completed December 2012.

Related places

You might also consider:
180
ft
Pizzicletta
203 W Phoenix Ave
380
ft
Ni Marcos Pizza
101 S Beaver St
900
ft
Alpine Pizza
7 N Leroux St
1
mi
Picazzo’s Organic Italian Kitchen
1300 S Milton Rd Ste 101
1
mi
Oregano’s Pizza Bistro
605 Riordan Rd
1.1
mi
NiMarcos Pizza
1800 S Milton Rd

Nearby

Near this location:
80
ft
The Toasted Owl Cafe
12 S. Mike's Pike
90
ft
Bikram Yoga College of India
119 W Phoenix Ave Ste 3
100
ft
Canyon Pet Hospital
12 S Mikes Pike
110
ft
ASIS Massage Education
113 W Phoenix Ave
130
ft
Alpine Pedaler
7 S Mikes Pike
150
ft
Church of Jesus Christ LDS
315 W Phoenix Ave

20 reviews of Fratelli Pizza

No registration required
Place rating: 4
Cave Creek, AZ
Amazing Caesar salad and really good White Pizza (made excellent with parmesan cheese and dipped in marinara). Will return! Friendly service.
Place rating: 3
Tucson, AZ
Ok so I finally tried this place after hearing how awesome it is! Nice place but many of the booths are just not conducive to comfort! The benches are way to close to the table!
Ok food I ordered the slice of the week special with a side salad and a beer versus soda! Under$ 10.00!
The salad was killer, fresh mixed greens, carrots, sweet peppers, black olives, delicious! The blue cheese dressing however not so much!
My slice was tasty and huge, but was served barely above room temp! It needed about 3 more minutes in the oven! It was good but nothing I’d seek out!
I prefer the pies at Beaver Street Brewery!
Place rating: 5
Gilbert, AZ
This place has some of the best pizza you can find in Arizona. The staff is always extremely friendly and the slices are generous portions for the price. However if you don’t really like too much grease on your pizza you may not like this place, personally I didn’t find it being a big enough problem to affect the quality of the pizza. You really can’t ask much more out of a small business pizza shop. I always leave Fratellis more than satisfied, glad to have it in Flagstaff!
Place rating: 4
Beech Grove, IN
Got a large specialty pizza and some bread sticks, very good, staff was very friendly
Place rating: 2
Flagstaff, AZ
So disappointed! I was excited to try the pizza and wings here after so many great reviews. To say the least, the pizza tasted and looked similar to school cafeteria pizza and the wings were soggy and small. The woman who took my order was a bit rude also.
The only reason they got two stars was because of the cheap price. Unfortunately it is not enough to make me want to come back. Will be going to the pizza place around the corner instead.
Place rating: 5
Phoenix, AZ
Great food that a New York style. The pizza slices are large and have great flavor. I’ve tried all the pizza places in flag and this is the best one.
Place rating: 5
Mesa, AZ
Local Favorite! Best of Flagstaff when it comes to service and food. I love the various slices of the week and enjoy the big portion sizes. If your in town and want pizza this is were you will want to get it from without a doubt.
Place rating: 5
Houston, TX
Stopped in after craving pizza while boarding all day in the snow. Parked across the street and walked in. Pretty busy for a Tuesday night in Flag. Ordered wings and the meaty pizza with jalapeños. Bought a few beers and had a blast. The team was moving with reason and everyone remainder friendly and helpful throughout the meal. Wings were crispy and the pizza was perfect. I’d def say you should check this place out.
Place rating: 5
San Diego, CA
BBQ Chicken pizza was one of the best I’ve ever had. I absolutely loved this place. Awesome local feel and they have great service as well!
Place rating: 5
Cashion, OK
Fratellis for pizza and wings is about as good as it gets in flagstaff imho. I’ve been a huge fan of their haleakala (spelling?) Pizza since I first came to flagstaff years and years and years ago. The Hawaiian pizza with a spicy kick and BBQ sauce instead of red is where it’s at. If by chance you are stopping by for a slice, (yes they sell by the slice!) You should get some of their wings! Always fried just right and not drowned in sauce ending up in a soggy mess.
Place rating: 1
Flagstaff, AZ
How can they constantly be so bad? Poor customer service. Uncaring attitude. Lousy food. If you order take out you’d better inspect it before leaving that place because they leave it cooking on top of their hot oven until you arrive. Then you had to wait on the worlds slowest moving line to get it. So your pizza is the texture of the box they throw it in. Pathetic.
Place rating: 5
Phoenix, AZ
Loved this place! Staff is amazing and the pizza is on point. Oh yeah… BEER! Stop in for a bite. You won’t be disappointed.
Justin
Place rating: 5
Phoenix, AZ
After a short trip to flagstaff we decided to try this pizza place, and all I can say is wow the environment was so awesome and if I have to complain about one thing it would be the wait time for us to get our pizza, however the staff there was super kind and let us know they were sorry about the wait and when the pizza came it was well worth it. I would recommend this place to anyone who is around looking for a great place to eat and not to mention they are super family friendly.
Place rating: 5
Las Vegas, NV
Oh my pizza & wings! We are in town for a mini vacation & chose to try Fratelli’s based on the reviews & pictures. We ordered a pepperoni pizza & order of wings.
When we picked up our food, the employees were very pleasant & helpful. It looks like a fun place to eat in. We chose take out. Ok, let me start by saying, my husband loves wings, not me. Not sure what got into me, but I decided to have one. Wow! It was so juicy, flavorful… it’s made me a wing fan! The pizza was delicious! Cheesy, a little greasy (but not too greasy), amount of pepperoni so was perfect. We all loved Fratelli’s & would absolutely eat here again!
Place rating: 5
Scottsdale, AZ
We’ve visited Fratelli again. I think we’re expecting this to get a little worse… as if the 1st two visits were a bit of a fluke.
Every bit as good as the first two times we visited on our last trip to Flagstaff.
We’re sold… this place is as good as we originally thought.
Pros: Hand tossed pizza crust. The crust of a pizza is a hallmark. It’s true that there are differences of opinion on this topic, generally based on the pizza you had in your youth. For me, pizza crust needs to be thin and have be crisp without be a «cracker» and it needs to have a «chew.» This crust meets that criteria.
The toppings: Plenty from which to pick.
Size — a small is plenty for one hungry person… if you’re having a salad first, split the small pizza, the salads are generous.
The staff is very friendly and ready to assist or answer any question.
Cons: If you’re interested in a broad beer selection (I’m not), you’re going to be disappointed. There are 4 or 5 on tap and some «bottle» selection. Pepsi soda fountain (no Coke products).
Additional: Tables and booths are fairly basic, comfortable enough. Lots of TV screens. Service is good, you order at the counter, they bring the food to the table.
We’ll return… too good not too…
Place rating: 4
Chandler, AZ
Was in Flag visiting my daughter (NAU student) and she suggested pizza! She hit the spot with this one. We got the big sky special with pesto cheesy bread added on. So, for 4, the pizza, salad, and bread was perfect for $ 30.
Service is walk up. The guy who took my order was very friendly but it took quite a while due to the only one register open (with about 4 people standing around talking behind him… huh… but really that is my only complaint and the reason I took off a star.) The pizza was delicious, house salad and pesto cheesy bread were excellent too. We did have to blot the grease off our pizza, but that’s ok. Still delicious.
I will definitely be back.
Place rating: 4
Hollywood, CA
Found Fratelli’s thanks to Unilocal while in Flagstaff. Reviews were correct, it was great. PACKED for a Wednesday night.
Anti-​pasta salad… HUGE AND delicious!!!
Great White Pizza… AWESOME!!!
Definitely will come back next time we are in town!!!
Place rating: 3
Tucson, AZ
Atmosphere: Local restaurant feeling without the over top trinkets that commercial chains have. It feels welcoming and comfortable, albeit a typical pizza place feeling.
Product: Ordered two slices of pizza, cheese and pepperoni plus a drink. The pizza slices are quite large, but they need to be to be filling. Because it is New York style the pizza is thin and sparse on the sauce. The pizza was good, it did not blow my socks off, but it was good (hard to mess up pizza).
Service: Simple platform. Walk in and place your order at the counter, grab a number and wait for your food to come. The staff was friendly during my interactions.
Conclusion: Quick, easy and good. I would recommend this for anyone in the market for good New York style pizza.
Place rating: 4
Greensboro, NC
This is one of the best pizza joints in Flagstaff. There is a nice variety of pizza here and their lunch specials are very well priced for what you get. I usually come here and get a slice with a drink which is 5 bucks. In the past, I have also tried their mozzarella sticks and T Ravs (fried ravioli), and both were very delicious (although I don’t eat them anymore due to cutting fried food).
My favorite pizza here is the Bianca, which is a white pizza with ricotta, broccoli, and others. However they do not offer these in slices. Slice wise, my go to’s are plain cheese as well as the pizza of the week, which often align with my own tastes.
The staff here are great, very friendly and personable, and they also have a tendency to remember your name when you are a regular. My only problem with this place is that it can sometimes get too dirty, even when there aren’t a lot of people around. Also, the pizza slices (especially the ones with tomato sauce) tend to be too greasy for my taste and I end up having to dab it several times with a napkin to get it out.
Still, is a great place, and no visit to Flagstaff will be complete without visiting it.
Place rating: 5
Austin, TX
My partner and I were in Flagstaff for an evening and were on a mission to find some good pizza we could eat in our room. The reviews for this place looked pretty good so we ordered some pizza and breadsticks to go.
The pizza was amazing, the breadsticks were perfect, and the marinara sauce was the best I’ve ever had. Portion size was on point, and we had leftovers for the next day!
They only offer delivery if you place an order over $ 50 so we had to go pick ours up. The guys behind the counter seemed very nice, and the atmosphere was that of an old time pizzeria :)
I highly recommend this place if you want some great pizza at reasonable prices!