Simply Chic

The store on 96^th St is the best one! The staff there is a lot more friendlier and the selection is very nice. The location in Noblesville is not that great. The staff is ok. The selection I find not to be that great. I give simply chic a 3 stars. I really like it for the most part.

So you got me! This is my secret gem. I love this resale shop specializing in upscale casual clothing and accessories. I shop at basically four places on the regular Dottie, Target, TJ Maxx, and here… I like shoes and accessories… they have them here, lots of them, cheap. Scarves, shoes, jewelry, clutches, shoes, jackets, coats, belts, SHOES… my favorite pair of boots I purchased here for $ 10.00. Ever in need of a new handbag they have plenty to choose from and many are name brands like Coach, Dooney and Bourke, Louis Vuitton, Michael Kors, etc.
In addition to finding some good deals on gently worn clothing and accessories I like to come to Simply Chic for those once in a blue moon occasions. I don’t enjoy spending money on «once-​a-​year-​wear» clothing and when I can’t find «the look» I have envisioned at Goodwill I come here. I have purchased items here for interviews, a trip to Vegas, a dress to wear to a wedding, St. Paddys Day, a Jimmy Buffet concert, etc. The fun part is finding the right item for your event, spending little on it, and getting a ton of compliments.
Speaking of selling & making some $$…this is a great place to get cash on the spot for gently worn clothing. Yes, it’s a little uncomfortable as you hand over your wares, hoping your clothes pass the cool factor but keep your eyes on the prize. In the end, even if they only take a few items, giving you $ 10.00, that’s $ 10.00 you didn’t have before on crap you didn’t want to keep in the first place. I like to use this $ as my «buy new clothes fund». Sell clothes, make money, buy new clothes. It’s the circle of my wardrobe life. **A little tip: whatever they don’t buy take those items to Clothing Mentor where you can also get cash on the spot. They seem to be a little less picky.
Notes: Sign up for their rewards benefits. Every dollar you spend gives you a point, once you reach so many points you can save a percentage off of your total bill.

I used to love this store! Sadly, my opinion has changed. I was appalled after walking into the store today. The first thing I noticed was that the prices have significantly raised! $ 20 for an old Gap sweater, $ 18 for a Loft shirt. Are you serious?! I used to be able to get shirts for $ 8 – 12. The prices have doubled on many items. However, the quality is lower. I saw a $ 22 Gap sweater that was obviously counterfeit (had a fake tag) and had a hole in it! Saw many other shirts that were no-​name brands that they were selling for $ 15+ dollars. I’m going to the store itself if I want to spend $ 20 for a shirt! The icing on the cake was when I was only offered $ 4 for a few shirts I sold after waiting an hour in the store. Sorry, Simply Chic, but you have now lost a loyal customer. Time to rethink your business model.

I typically donate all of my clothes to Goodwill, but my recent «New Kitchen Fund» inspired me to give the whole consignment scene a shot for the first time. Simply Chic was recommended by my fellow Unilocalers (thank you all). I have to admit the process of watching your clothes be sorted and having them only keep three items is slightly tormenting. Red flag: am I super unfashionable? Orrrr… shall I slip on my rose tinted glasses and call myself a trendsetter? I choose the latter of the two.
Personal wardrobe aside, Simply Chic is very clean and offers an extensive selection of brand name clothing ranging from suits, winter boots and jewelry to perfumes and skirts. Expect to find brands like BCBG Maxima, Calvin Klein and the like. The store is very well organized with three dressing rooms on the back wall. I highly recommend this store if you’re willing to pay a little extra for brand name products.

I’m not one to give bad reviews, but the treatment I received from the manager was disappointing! I ran in to look for an outfit i saw the week before… couldn’t find it but found something else. As I was changing my 7 year old stated she needed to use the restroom. I told her to ask the sales staff. The answer was no… I was pretty hurt and disappointed! Usually a retail establishment would lead the child to the restroom then lead them back to the parent… I am disappointed… and saddened… I have a sneaking suspicion it was racially motivated.

Grabbing some sweet deals on some gently used threads for the momma to be Mrs F.
Mrs. F likes this place quite a lot we usually find one or two pieces that she loves. Prices are fair but Mrs. F says she can find better some times online for used Lulu’s. But we love coming to check out what the new inventory might look like from time to time. We will defintely be back over the course of her 9 months. Petite and short is hard to find… but sometimes you can find it in resale.

Staff is always soooo nice! Love it here but it’s like target, can’t get out of here w/​o spending (at least) 50 bucks!

This is a great spot to find fashionable resale clothing for reasonable prices. I cleaned up on my first visit with 2 coats, a sweater, jacket, jewelry and designer handbag. What fun! The staff is very friendly. I tried to sell some things there but decided to give them to charity because their offer to me was so low.

Located on 96^th Street, just off I 69 is a fabulous find for any fashion conscious woman. Simply Chic has been around for a few years now, but moved into a larger location just last year. They have a wide variety of better quality women’s clothing, shoes, bags and accessories at a very reasonable price.
Different from most consignment shops, they purchase your items outright instead of sharing a percentage of the sale.
They always have a nice selection in the current seasonal styles. Stop in for a great Spring outfit or make a little cash clearing space for new duds!