Myrtlewood Liquors & John’s Fine Cigars

I love this place. Great selections on wine, beer, and spirits. The employees are fabulous. Great customer service! I feel safe every time I come to this liquor store. Feels like home. Thanks John, and to all employees day&knight.

This place is excellent.
It looks a bit sketchy from the outside, but don’t let that deter you. The selection is extensive, the staff is knowledgeable, friendly and always willing to help you kind what you’re looking for.

Surprising variety of everything liquor or tobacco related. Very nice humidor generously stocked with top end, mid range and value cigars. Prices are comparable to other places I’ve shopped. Staff are friendly, knowledgeable and helpful.

Local, friendly, great selection.

I always stop by here when on that side of town. If nothing else, they have the best prices on cigarette papers and loose tobacco I’ve found anywhere in town.

Johns is right down the street from my business so I am a little bias. However holy smokes its so awesome. The shop is family owned. They must treat their staff well because the same people are always there so I feel like I am hanging out with friends when i stop in because I am not meeting new employees every time.
You can tell John loves what he does. He upgrades his shop all the time with things like a tasting area and a great humidor and always getting in a great selection of spirits that his staff will help you select.
I love Johns Cigars Myrtlewood Liqueurs. Its a great local spot you should all check out.

This is the place to go for electronic cigarettes and e-​juice! Not only is there a large selection at a fantastic price but the staff was well informed and friendly. The specific employee who helped me went above and beyond by pointing out places in the area I might also like to visit. I’m so pleased with my experience and the products I received I’ll be sure to return many, many times throughout the duration of my stay in Eureka.

Not just the best place in Humboldt County to buy cigars, it’s really in a league of its own for the area. A beautiful walk-​in humidor with a wide variety of brands and prices. Not cheap, but good cigars aren’t cheap to begin with.
If you are looking for inexpensive, flavored cigars, they have them. If you are looking for a legal Cohiba, Avo, Fuente or Motecristo, they have them. If you are looking for a less mainstream brand like Acid, Perdomo or Gurkha, they have them. Everything is fresh, in good condition and can be bought per-​cigar or by the box.
The store’s liquor selection is also the best in the area. They have a huge variety of single malt Scotch, small batch Bourbons, fine ports and every other liquor you can imagine. John, the owner, can pretty much answer any question you have on the subject of cigars, Scotch, Bourbon and Ports. The only downside is that there is only one of him and he isn’t there 24×7.
The beer and wine selection isn’t THE best in Humboldt County, but they have a lot more variety than most places in the area and their prices are certainly reasonable. Besides cigars & liquors, they also stock some grocery items and smoking supplies as well. I’ve been shopping there since the place first opened. I’ve never had a bad experience and when I have the money, it’s my favorite place in town to shop.

You would drive right by this place. From the outside it looks a bit trashy and, unfortunately, it’s next door to an even trashier-​looking comics store. When I moved over to this side of Eureka, I stopped in one day and whoa, SURPRISE! Inside, it feels like a high-​end spirit shop. The people are mostly knowledgeable and friendly. I think they’d do well to de-​junk the outside appearance.
ps, The food truck in the parking lot serves delicious, fresh Mexican food!

Great staff. The guys working the register are always nice & informative. Dog friendly — always welcomes my pup in & even gives her treats! I love this place. They carry lots of liquor selections, even odd or rare items. I love the novelty things they have at the register, too. They carry Zubrowka, a great bison grass infused Polish vodka, that is sometimes difficult to find. BevMo just came to town & I’ve already made a trip there, but don’t waste your time. SHOP LOCAL — John’s prices are very comparable to other places!

I honestly don’t have a bad thing to say about this place. I’ve been able to find liquors here that I can’t find any place else in Humboldt. They also have a huge selection for everything you could need for smoking, lots of cool trinkets and lighters.
I’ve also found special limited time liquors that again, you can’t find any place else in Humboldt. This is by far the best liquor store/​smoking shop around.

If there is ANY type of alcohol you ever need you can find it at John’s. They have a massive selection of every spirit and can order in pretty much anything. Their prices are pretty good and the wine selection is quite good too. They even have a wine tasting room in the back, and the staff is incredibly helpful and knowledgeable about their wines/​spirits.

Up visiting and found a nice bottle of wine, someone even poured us a few ports. I would have had a cigar if not with the family. We bought the chocolates and they were good. This was a great little find if you want some quality wine, beer, and cigars.

Friendly people work here. I haven’t seen any loitering outside which is nice for a liquor store. The prices are average but that’s okay because at least they are close by. It would be nice if they had local Humboldt milk and at a better price then other places– I like when our stores support local businesses and farmers. The chocolates here are amazing, I have to wonder where they are from (have to ask next time I’m there)… but they are GOOD!

Most amazing liquor store ever. They have EVERYTHING, and I do mean that. Extremely helpful staff who are very knowledgable. I am sad to have moved away from this place!

Where else can you get a bottle of Fernet-​Branca. Great liquor selection, and lots of cigars.

Outstanding selection of the sins worthy of taxation. Cigars, whisky, whiskey, beer wine and spirits. The staff is extremely helpful and they have made excellent recommendations for me over the years.

I have been buying cigars from John since he had to take a break from dog grooming in order to open up the humidor.
Now, years after he bought Libbys liquor store, he has really brought his A-​game to myrtletown. He has not only the best cigar selection in the greater area but he has an awesome selection of spirits and wine.
Good job!

This place would rate as very good in any region — in Humboldt county it’s fall-​off-​your-​chair awesome.
On liquor and wine — good selection and fair prices. Only place in Humboldt I can say that about.

If you were passing by the Myrtletown Shopping Center you might not guess that the modest storefront of Myrtlewood Liquor & John’s Fine cigars housed a truly excellent liquor and cigar and tobacco store.
Coming through the door, you are immediately surrounded by the welcoming smell of fine tobaccos that occasionally escapes from the door to the humidor on the left. Along the right wall, floor to ceiling bottles, bottles, bottles, staples and stalwarts mixed with gems and jewels, stretch most of the length of the store.
There’s a little tap room in the back! It wasn’t open when I was there, but I liked the looks of it.
A very cursory examination of the store inventory seemed to support my initial impression that they pretty much had it all. If you were throwing a party and needed to pick up some things to make a cocktail, this store will have you covered.
At the counter, there was a basket of lemons and limes. A nice touch that I always appreciate.
When I’m visiting a liquor store for the first time, I like to sort of randomly think of one cocktail and see if I can make it with what is found in the store. For my walk through this store, the cocktail I had in mind was a Singapore Sling. Everything was there, but I wasn’t finding pineapple juice. The counterman asked me if I needed any help and I asked if he had pineapple juice.
«Right over there» he said, pointing at a nearby cooler.
My Sling was complete!