Bar-Fly Pub & Grub

The food is a pleasant surprise. The jalapeño poppers were absolutely delicious. They were freshly made by hand – I’ve never seen a fresh popper before, thus, this was the first time I’ve tried one. I doubt if I’ll ever try them anywhere else.
Full bar with a fantastic, huge array of craft beers on tap. Friendly, efficient service – what else could you want?

I really like this place. Whenever I am in Eureka, I make it a point to stop by. Their beer selection is off the charts! The food is very creative, and always very good. I highly encourage you to check this place out.

Atmosphere: B–
Drinks/​Bar: A+
Staff: A++!
Couldn’t ask for a better place to grab a bite to eat (the wings are awesome!) and a drink (or 15) with friends! Our bar tender was beautiful AND intelligent and made for a great evening. If your in town, go here or you’ll be missing out!

Love the atmosphere but the pitchers of beer we ordered tasted like they haven’t cleaned draft lines ew! Definitely need to make sure they keep up with that.

One of my favorite bars in town! Shelby, Brittany, and Shawna all know how to have a good time and make people feel welcome! Guess I go there a lot cause they all know exactly what I want to drink and it doesn’t take long to have a meal cooked and in front of you. Fast service, fun place to drink, and a great place to meet people!
Thanks for the hard work bartenders!

Awesome nice little local bar with +40 Beers on tap. Great food and most friendly bar tenders. Great atmosphere. Every night is … Special ;-)

Cute dive in a podunk hood. Bartender, Shelby, was a great entertainer as well as pouring a picture perfect duck fart.

We are out of towners looking to watch a Thursday Night NFL game. My wife was a little uncomfortable with the area where the Bar-​Fly is located but when we went in they made us feel right at home. Excellent beer selection, Bartenders were great and the food was good. Good TVs but the sound was a little hard to hear but they did turn off the music. Good friendly crowd. This a fun safe spot that I will go to again when I visit.

Best fish n chips
Awesome employees
Great atmosphere
Highly recommend.
Don’t forget to order the deep fried green beans

Great bartenders, great drinks, THIS IS THE PERFECT DIVE… the deep fried green beans are to die for. Me and my husband come here all the time. GOD BLESS THE BAR FLY!

Let’s start off with the food, it’s the tits. Ean is a grumpy old codger but makes good food so he’s alright but that black guy and the old bouncer are so chill they’re hot. And let’s not forget the beautiful Brittany and Kim that make your pink panty droppers and whatever other crazy thing you heard of to perfection. Karaōke on wed and Fridays, always a good time to watch wether your good or bad, I’m drunk so, job well done. Plus where else can you get burgers and rum at 1 am at the same place… Don’t worry I’ll wait. Plus they have more beer on tap then anywhere else I’ve ever seen. I feel relaxed and comfortable there like your drinking at your own house watching the game, and did I mention the food. A++
–Mike

Friendly local place with a great tap beer menu with a bar! Fish and chips where plenty for 2 to share, cole slaw was great, light no mayo base. We had an order of onion rings as well, plenty to share. Baseball on numerous tv’s waiting for karaōke to start FUN

Have to start out with the deep fried oreos which are ridiculous and crazy good. A fun, reasonably priced novelty. I bring them home to rave reviews. Otherwise. .it’s a nice, clean basic bar atmosphere. Pretty decent food overall. Fish and chips were unremarkable. Good grilled chicken. Good beer. Not the kind of place to order a fancy mojito. Come for the beer… stay for the oreos.

Charissa is the best bar tender in the land. I only come here for her! Her service is always impeccable. Drinks are always made to perfection. Also, amazing food!

Decent atmosphere, good drinks, most of the staff is friendly, the karaōke is always entertaining.

Had a wonderful time tonight! Great food! & shelby, oh shelby, shes the greatest bartender. Im a fan of brittany, but shelby is awesome too! I highly recommend the barfly, great bartenders, good drinks, chef is on point. Enjoy

The only problem I had was the bartender Shelby she is not a very happy person if she was at a bar in Orange County where I’m from California she would have been fired. She has a bad attitude never happy always complaining to customer she makes herself look ugly. I hear her talk about the bar not good I think she need to look for another job when she comes to work at the bar fly I cash out. Now Brittany she is fun happy she has her job down to a T she’s always happy and smiling I’m here for a week and I’m gone Jared cool cat very knowledgeable about sports what a bartenders should be always smiling great attitude makes the bar fun him and Brittany make this bar happen sorry about Shelby but I think she should of friends in Orange County that would fire her in 2 second sorry but she’s bad for your bar sorry

Lots of cider selections and the food is pretty good. Tried the fish and chips and the burger and deep fried oreos. The bartender, Briittany is a sweetie. Will definitely stop in again. Don’t forget the steak fries, I don’t like potatoes much and they’re great.

Went on a Friday night and they had karaōke night. It was actually fun, lots of participants singing off key and having a blast! None were boo-​ed off like in SoCal where one off note gets ya thrown off stage.
My daughter had a blast too… she liked the diverse age group and the fun people.
Lots of friendly faces, yummy fresh food and good drinks makes this place my choice of fun places to hang out!

Normally I have a good experience here. For that, a mediocre rating because my recent experience offsets the good.
The good: for being a bar, the food is decent and offers those rare things like frickles that are enjoyable once in a while. Great beer list, not what I would expect in a Eureka bar. So plus there.
The other night I was in there. The male bartender wouldn’t give me the time of day because I didn’t have boobs. I had pretty female customers actually direct his attention to me and he still ignored me. I actually had to, I kid you not, get a woman to order my drink and pay for it with my card. And when he did refer to me, it was through a woman! Never seen the guy in my life I can’t imagine he had a problem with me. WTF Barfly?