Really good pizza. Sauce is a bit sweet/basil tasting. A bit pricey, but worth it once in a while.
Terri D.
Place rating: 4 Rocky River, OH
LOVE it. crust is perfect. the sauce is so yummy. kind of on the sweeter side, if you dig that. i think their cheesy breadsticks are fabulous. this is my go to for carry out pizza. quick, hot, delicious! check angelinas out! i think some of the best pizza around!
Leigha A.
Place rating: 1 Elyria, OH
Never will i order from this place again! Food was horrible! After waiting an hour for my food to be delivered. Not to mention I called to check on my order bc it was taking to long. my order was delivered the food was cold and tasteless ! I was completely unsatisfied so i decided to call and request to speak with a manager. Even worst !! The girl was rude.rude.rude! Didnt even apologize! Dont waste your money!
Christopher B.
Place rating: 4 Avon Lake, OH
Angelina’s Pizza is the best pizza I’ve found in NE Ohio. Their take ‘n bake pizza is my go-to since I can pick it up and then take it home and bake it off when convenience so it’s über hot and fresh. Online ordering is a breeze. My fav is the deluxe with extra sauce. Substitute the sausage for meatballs and you won’t be disappointed!
Rachel R.
Place rating: 1 Shavertown, PA
I ordered the Greek salad and added a chicken breast… possibly the grossest salad I have ever had… it came out cold, pre-packaged, chicken included. The chicken must have been a JTM because it wasn’t a «real» chicken breast(think McDonald’s processed chicken). My husband and kids had the pizza, which albeit greasy, was pretty good.
Jeremy S.
Place rating: 5 Elyria, OH
This place has amazing pizza, my parents used to drive to their other location when I was a kid to pick up dinner. The location wasn’t close to us but it was definitely our families favorite and then came an Elyria location too. Don’t always have to many deals but I’d say it’s the best in the area hands down!!! Probably been eating their pizza for 15 years or more between the two locations. A little pricier then other place but I’d say you get what you pay for. All I know about is their pizza, never tried anything else on their menu. Definitely worth giving it a try if you’ve never had it.
Dave M.
Place rating: 2 Elyria, OH
I was not impressed with there pizza. Did not like there sauce and the crust was not all that good. I would not order from there again.
Jennifer M.
Place rating: 5 Elyria, OH
We received a welcome package to the neighborhood in the mail. We figured we would give it a try. We ordered a large cheese and a large pepperoni and sausage. The sauce is fantastic, the crust is amazing and the toppings were perfect. We have been sticking to Marcos but I am glad to have found a local pizza that is FANTASTIC!!!
Matthew M.
Place rating: 4 Elyria, OH
Been here a few times and really enjoyed the pizza. Prices aren’t that bad compared to most pizza places(minus maybe the big chain ones). Only complaint is some of the pizzas are excessively greasy… only a complaint unless you’re looking for a lot of greasiness. I like it and whenever i’m out in that area Angelina’s is my choice of pizza provider.
Jamie J.
Place rating: 5 Cleveland, OH
Great pizza. Love the sauce!
Vinnie M.
Place rating: 1 Port Washington, WI
We stopped over in Elyria, Ohio on our way to Canada, and we were hoping to order something in since the kids were tired. This place advertised all of these awards that they received locally for their pizza. Our hopes were high as we were hoping for some decent pizza and pasta. When the food arrived I am sad to say… it tasted just as it looked, bad and probably not freshly made. The onion rings were identical to the frozen ones you get in the store, and the pizza was sadly awful. The pasta noodles were decent, but the Alfredo sauce that came with them was ridiculous. The sauce was a watery mess with zero taste. I cannot imagine it did not come from a can. So please do not waste your time on this establishment. For a small town like Elyria it may pass the test, but it fails when you look at actual taste.
Mike B.
Place rating: 4 Columbus, OH
Angelina’s is a good pie. We got a delivery to our hotel(Ramada Elyria) and it was right on time. Good crust and toppings. Sauce was a bit on the sweet side but I can manage that. Overall a good place to order in Elyria.