Attilio’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

This place should be ashamed to call itself a pizzeria. I ordered a large meat pizza over the weekend and it was terrible. All you can taste is the saltiness of the ingredients. I think they forgot to put tomato sauce or cheese. The crust was stale tasting and hard to describe how bad it was. I know it’s Edison pizza but I’ve had much better at other places such as Brooklyn Boys Pizza. People at this place are not nice and they nickel and dime you for the already overpriced poor food, including dinner entrees. The two owner brothers are arrogant and confrontational. I would not recommend!

— The grandma style pizza is excellent. The sandwiches are huge and very good. Staff is friendly. This place is a good bang for the buck, large portions at a fair price, without any compromise in quality.

Can’t say anything about the food. As soon as I plugged a cable in the electrical outlet, the waitress was told, to tell me,… $ 1 per minute for the electricity.
There was no smile or joke there.
I left, and so should you, if you would use their electricity while spending money on their menu items.

Been ordering here for 3 years and today is the final time. I have ordered the same few items. This time was the lunch special chicken parm. with penne with penne sauce on the pasta. Food delivered fast like always. Well my order wasnt correct. There was basic tomato sauce on my penne. Called to have this corrected waited twice as long then my original order. Asked when the driver left «he is leaving now» and the girl hung up. Called back the phone rang and rang till the a manager picked up. He expressed how if I dont like the business to go somewhere else. He doesn’t know what penne sauce is. He was upset and confused by the order also. (Im sorry but if you were upset and confused maybe you should have called the customer and asked) I let him know how I have worked in a pizza place as well as I am Italian as well. I dont care where you worked or what you are. If you dont like it take your business somewhere else he told me. He asked what are they suppose to do keep records of what everyone orders.(It is 2014 almost 2015 they have the technology to do so). To add to this actually was the owner not just the manager. Obliviously this place does not care bout their customers.

we just had an eggplant parm pizza delivered and it was fabulous! Thanks!!!

I just tried to order from them, and the customer service became horrible. I ordered a baked ziti, with chicken and meat sauce. When asked for soup or salad I said no. Put on hold, and was then told that total was $ 20.25 (excluding tip). I said ok. Then I thought. $ 20 for ziti. I could get a large pizza with toppings and still pay less. I call back, and ask. She puts on the manager. I think he said his name was Sal. I asked him, «Why is the price so high». His comment back. «If you don’t like it, go somewhere else». I said «I don’t want somewhere else, im just asking why it costs so much?». He said its because of the sauce and chicked. He than says «Well do you want it or not, we are very busy!!» I then said, ive been getting food from you for 10 years. If you are going to have an attitude, then forget it. He said fine, go somewhere else, and hung up.
So, I called back to find out this guys name, so I can tell the owner. The women answers, and I said, can I have that gentlemans name. She then hung up on me.
So, I call back, and I said, you don’t have to hang up, I just want to know his name and position. She said his name was Sal and he was the manager. So, then she puts him on the phone again. He says he is the manager and owner. Don’t know.
So, I searched for a new place. Pamatieris. Got the same food, PLUS a slice of pizza, for $ 5 less.
Customer services goes a long way.

Next time you’re in the area for a subway sandwich, go to this place instead and support a small business.
They’re always friendly in here and the Sicilian has the perfect ratio of cheesy goodness to crunchy crust.
If you’re opting for something healthier, their salads are good too.
The seats by the window are perfect for people watching (if you’re into that kind of stuff – then again, who isn’t?)

The Sicilian pies are the best! This is as good as it gets! Conveniently located in the Wick shopping plaza next to Pathmark my family and i have been going here for years. Friendly staff fresh food and great service are a winning combination.

Always a friendly face and greeting when entering Attilio’s.
Great thin crust Pizza