Pizza Club

Still waiting to join this club. Not sure how the membership works. Love the pizza and the soda selection. The staff is friendly.

Best Pie in town, Go for the Sicilian or the grandma. Do yourself a favor and pick up the pie yourself so you don’t whine like all the other people complaining about the cheese sliding off or the temp of the pie.
This place is busy as hell so cut them some slack! So glad I finally found THE best Pizza in edgewater, thanks guys!

Their pizzas are great — hands down no doubt, especially the regular cheese, pepperoni and Hawaiian! But delivery and customer service need a significant improvement. I’ve been using their online ordering for a while since it gives you 10% off your order. But the delivery time took forever for the past two times I ordered, making me wait for 1 hour and 10 min for my order to arrive. It would be great if the online system could update you on the progress of the pizza like how Dominos has. When I called to check in on the order, the lady over the phone didn’t sound very professional. Did not even say «thank you for ordering» or «sorry that the order is taking a while» etc.

This place is great! I’m very picky when it comes to pizza. I work in the same complex and go here every so often for lunch. From their plain pizza to their specialty pizza, everything is delicious. I highly recommend their wings as well. I’ve also had their pasta and sandwiches. I still have yet to be disappointed. The place is pretty big and has a nice view of NYC in the back. Prices are very reasonable and the staff is very nice!

This restaurant is wonderful. I have had bad experiences in other places, but except for 1 occasion, Pizza Club has delivered great food for great value on time for many years. They are kind and courteous and care about their customers. I am very happy to be their customer.

I think I’m going to order from here until I’m 90.
Billy hope you’re not going anywhere any time soon lol

Standard nyc/​jersey pizza, I got a slice of chicken, bacon, and ranch. It was really good, the prices are standard. I wish they had more pizza options, especially something so popular like pepperoni.

Pizza here is decent. Delivery is quick and accurate, but the delivery guys need to be taught how to hold the food properly. My pizza cheese slid all the way to the corner, dripping oil out the corner of the box and leaving part of the pizza topping-​free. My salad container was dented/​crushed. Not much of an issue, I used a fork to spread the toppings evenly, but an annoyance.
The chef/​antipasto salad is finely chopped — very good. Order dressing on side unless you eat the salad right away.
of their subs, I prefer the chicken cutlet.

I was really pleasantly surprised with Pizza club. We ordered a dozen hot wings, a regular cheese pizza and an order of garlic knots. Everything came super hot and the delivery guy was funny & friendly! We have no complaints about anything!

Not really the best pizza here in edgewater. They let their pizza sit for some time and just reheat it and send it out for delivery.
Sometimes we get ice cold pizza and we have to heat it up ourselves. So this is somewhat a mystery as they are only a 5 min drive to us. We even called about it and they denied that it came cold.
Idk but they seem like they could do better but they have a I don’t care attitude

I love it. Late night we ordered pizza, cheesesteak, salad and chicken wings. My favorite was meat pizza. It’s not like pizza, it likes a meat pie. Inside is ham, salami, meat balls, cheese etc. Very tasty. Delivery was very quick, just 20 – 30 min. Thank you. Recommend.

This should give you an idea of how good this place is: I used to eat here every day when I worked at Trader Joes which is in the same strip mall. I literally had all the food I wanted at my fingertips at a discounted price, yet I would always walk across the street and pay for some high-​quality pie. Honestly, its one of the only things I miss about working at TJs.
My GF loves the Red Mango here, so whenever we go toward the area, I make sure to grab at least 1 slice. Make sure to try pinwheels — they are awesome!

I just received our pizza and it is the worst I’ve ever eaten. There is barely any tomato sauce and the cheese and pie is overcooked. Never ordering from this place again. Basically inedible… gross

Had a great time here with about 11 of my friends on a Monday evening. They don’t take reservations but we were seated super promptly. We arrived around 8pm or so and took up a few tables on the deck. Wonderful view of the skyline. Our waitstaff was very friendly and even sat down with us to take our massive order. Very good pizza and pretty big selection!
The absolute BEST part of this establishment is their heart pizza. So cute. I love pizza and I absolutely adored it.

Delicious pizza! Delivery orders since our one time last bad incident have improved!
Grandma Margarita is amazing here. Hubby polishes off half off the pie by the time I’m done with my corner slice (so darn good!).
Yes it’s my cheat day. I run many, many miles on the treadmill and eat sashimi, plain greens, and grilled chicken/​veggie burgers all week along. Stop judging and go order a pizza lol!

Don’t let this place fool you. Not the biggest fan of the name or the décor, but the food is amazing!!! The grandmother slice was so delicious and fresh! We also ordered the chicken Marsala with penne. The pasta was perfectly cooked and the chicken has the perfect amount of coating. The sauce was also divine! Lastly, even the free bread was good!!! Don’t sit inside, go to the back and check out the view of the Manhattan skyline. It’s so picturesque! I can’t believe I would love this place so much!!! The service was awesome as well! I am definitely coming back or ordering take out.

The first time I praised Pizza Club was over 15 years ago. Back then I was eating pizza everywhere. But really I was subconsciously making comparisons from Bergen County to Brooklyn. Since then, I’ve become somewhat of a (flamboyant) food enthusiast. I started saying things like «I only savor empanadas when the recipe is Colombian». And I still believe a burger is only as good as the fries it comes with. That said, I value pizza based on its overall texture: thin but not too thin, cheesy but not too cheesy, the slightest crunch where it’s almost unnoticeable. But the key to Pizza Club’s technique is far from ordinary. They execute a flawless ratio of water to dough, which is why this joint is always on point.
Let’s just say I know what I want in my pizza and Pizza Club delivers (though I’ve never actually gotten delivery here). Each visit starts with two plain slices. Then it’s straight to the back to soak up the NYC view. A moment of bliss (and reminiscing) and I’m back at the counter ordering a honey mustard chicken slice or any one of their mouthwatering appetizers, sandwiches, or entrees. Even their dipping sauces validate why they stand out from all other restaurants.
Friends, believe me when I say… the best roasted duck in the world hangs at a hole-​in-​the-​wall in Bangkok; the best short rib gets devoured at an underground bistro in Barcelona; and the best pizza is here in Edgewater.

I ordered from here while at my friends’ apartment for delivery online.
The original time estimate was well over an hour wait for the pizza (ordered around 6:20, it said 7:55). What?! Thankfully, it arrived at 6:50! That’s more like it! Also the delivery guy had no problem with finding the apartment complex and the apartment (whew, we had some famished people there).
The pizzas were really great and fresh. However, it was on the oily side. But I just love a nice crunchy crust.
Also, ordered the mozzarella and tomato, which was pretty good. Only 4 pieces of each though.
The prices are reasonable and what you expect. So not bad and definitely worth ordering from if you live nearby.

Excellent chicken Casar salad. Chicken was cooked to order. The best part is outside dining over looking the Hudson. A hidden gem

We have ordered from here many many times. It’s the best NY style pizza in the neighborhood.
But, the last few times, we received pizza with the cheese and toppings slid off of the pizza dough and basically stuck to one side of the box. Obviously, the pizza didn’t come out of the oven this way, but it turned into a mess of a disaster during the delivery process. In short, it was truly disappointing and we vowed never to order from here again.
Fast forward 2 – 3 weeks. someone from Pizza Club reached out to me on Unilocal and asked me to call and ask for who I assumed was the owner or manager, which I did. He apologized and explained that he «wanted to make things right» by sending over another pizza on the house. About 23 mins later, it arrived piping hot and looking and tasting delicious.
Great customer service, that’s how you run a business the right way.