Edgartown Commons

Just checked in for 2 nights, in town for a wedding. The location for the money is fantastic! Everything is clean, the kitchen is upgraded, and the separate bedroom from the living area is perfect for traveling with kids. The bed is a little springy and the bedroom’s interior design is kind of stuck in the 80’s, style-​wise (why I gave it 4 stars…) but otherwise it’s perfect for us and I love that it feels like home away from home! FYI bring your own shampoo :)

If you stay here, what you’re renting is on par with a small apartment in a college dorm.
In our case, the flimsy bed was a torture chamber. The oven was so off calibration it burned a frozen pizza (to a crisp) in 4 minutes, set off the smoke alarm, and our room smelled like smoke the rest of the weekend. The TV remote only worked half the time. There was no air conditioning. WiFi was spotty at best.
Along with a number of other frustrations, staying here turned our vacation into slow-​motion train wreck.

Stayed here for three days with my two year old on a Mommy/​Daughter getaway. :) For the price, you can’t beat it. These are small, owner owned condos that are managed by a company. They’re spotless, well appointed and perfect if you’re looking for something affordable and close to everything.
We had a one bedroom apartment and since my daughter goes to bed early, it was so nice to be able to put her down in the bedroom and I could stay up and read or watch tv without having to worry about waking her.
This isn’t a traditional hotel, so no, there’s no turn down service or daily cleaning. But if you run out of anything, the office is fully stocked and you just ask.
Downtown Edgartown with it’s shops, dining and waterfront are just a block away. As a matter of fact, across the street from the commons is the town assigned parking for bikes and mopeds.
We loved it so much we ended up staying an extra night. This will be my go to on Martha’s Vineyard from now on!

Clean comfortable and affordable! I had a studio apt good for two
plenty of fluffy towels, stocked kitchen with dishes and cook ware
The pool looked inviting and it’s fall I thought it would be closed !
Walk to chappy ferry, shopping and historic churches, love it will be back

This place is really great for families and low key people who do not require a turn down service, luxury towels and five star dining facilities downstairs.
You will be staying in an apartment with a small kitchen, access to a pool, good parking on site and a laundry facility. Not to mention a shuffle board court.
Two blocks from Main Street in Edgartown, this location can not be beat. You can shop, eat, go to the beach, visit the light house, go to Chappy and then come «home» for a swim and a rest. You will have your own deck, a fully equipped kitchen, a large fan and that desirable parking… Not bad.
Sure, it’s quirky and you need to do some of your own laundry, make your own bed and wipe your own countertops. You can do that… right?
This is a super spot for the budget conscious and for families who enjoy casual spots where their kids can meet other kids. Do not come here if you are looking for lush surroundings. This is MV on a shoestring budget. And that is a rare commodity here. Closed in the off season, this place fills up quickly in the summer.
Good parking, a swimming pool, downtown Edgartown and affordable? I like it.

I’ve stayed here twice and I love it — will definitely be returning! True, they don’t provide daily maid service and you have to go to the front desk to get fresh towels, but this is not a «hotel,» it’s more of an apartment.
What they do provide is clean, comfortable, inexpensive, conveniently located lodging (right in the heart of «downtown» Edgartown), complete with a kitchenette, wi-​fi, cable, ample space and best of all, an outdoor pool.
As long as you know what to expect, I think you will love it too!

Spend a few bucks more and stay somewhere else! How about some place with air conditioning? and decent towels? and some sort of daily maid service? and toilet paper that you don’t have to fetch from the front desk? …If you require any of these things do not stay here! Oh, and to top it off… they are rude rude rude.