Sexy Pizza

If you are craving a greasy thin crust pizza with great flavor this is the joint to go!
Got delivery the other day. They came right on time and the pizza was delicious!
I took off one star cause the pizza could have been more on the crispier side but I guess u can’t expect that on delivery?
Four stars anyway. Maybe next time I’ll pick it up or eat at the restaurant.

My star rating is what I would call an «average» because we LOVE SP’s pie but we CANNOT stand the majority their staff. Let me elaborate…
The pizza is DELICIOUS! Perfect amount of sauce, perfect ratio of toppings, chewy crust with the occasional, ever-​so-​slightly charred, crispy edges… it’s like seriously really, good. I just can’t say enough good things about this pizza, seriously.
The staff is RUDE. They laugh and joke on the phone when they take our order every. single. time. We get hung up on regularly, I am not sure if this is an «phone issue», but this coupled with their non-​professional demeanor is a real bummer when placing orders for delivery or grabbing pizza at the shop. We have had to ask for a manager on more than one occasion in the past, and to their credit, they have always made things right.
At the end of the day, we LOVE the pizza, I can’t say that enough times. We love it SO much that we deal with a staff we cannot stand at least once a week to get this delicious, cheesy goodness. It’s worth it, people, I promise.

So I come in to this shop that has a slice with a banana peppers, tomatoes and spinach ready to go and everyone working makes me feel warm as the pizza is. Thanks guys. You do pizza right and better than most in town. Come to this location and the people are friendly and the sauce is saucy

Best NY style pizza in town! Love the sheihk pizza. Also, they have the best ranch — thin and cold! Great place to get pizza by the slice as well which obviously makes great drunk food.

This is my favorite New York style pizza place. The staff is great and the pizza is delicious. I recommend getting a Boylans root beer to wash down your slices of pepperoni pizza. Very reasonable prices and they deliver.

Sexy Pizza is basically your everyday cheap pizza place. It’s fine, but not something you go recommending to all of your friends.
Now that’s not to say it doesn’t have its strong points. I love that they use Boylan Soda for their fountain machine and that pizza slices are just $ 1 on Wednesdays. Granted you’re limited to cheese or pepperoni, but it’s still a good deal.
For me, it’s definitely not worth a special trip. But hey, they don’t really pretend to be something they aren’t.

Decent but they didn’t have very many options

Many choices for pizza, need more slice flavors. Good service. Free wifi. Quick service. Nice & hot!!! Excellent perk for writing a Unilocal review! !

I have been going to Sexy Pizza for years and it has always been consistently good. For both slices and full pies, I always go for the chicken basil jalapeño. Plus, it’s one of the few places that’s open in the cap hill area late nights, which is a complete win!

Great late night pizza! A friend lives near by and it’s dangerous after a night out of fun we order a pizza and I swear it hits the spot every time! Plus we do enjoy ordering and picking up for those cold nights for Netflix and pizza or a girls night/​date night! I’ve never bought them but they seem to always have a groupon too!

There is nothing sexy about this pizza. I mean they don’t even have sexy people working there. What a major disappointment. I live down the street, this was my 4^th and last time ordering from here. Change the name to «mediocre pizza »

Sexy pizza is always our go-​to pizza joint that’s close & consistent. They offer a wide variety of pizzas, sides & salads and are reasonably priced. Wait times are usually long, but worth it!

I read the reviews here after my experience, so I will cut some corners here with just a couple points:
1) Contrary to many reviews here, the pizza arrived well within the allotted time (ordered at 8:15ish, it took 37 mins when promised in an hour). Always like to see when businesses use the «under promise/​over deliver» maxim ESPECIALLY with pizza delivery.
2) The overall quality of the pie was definitely lacking. The crust was undercooked, the cheese overcooked and toppings were sparse. The sauce was not particularly flavorful or memorable. In the interest of full disclosure, we were 100% sober before eating this pizza (although we did require a few adult beverages afterward in order to «round out» a disappointing meal).
In summation I believe 3 stars to be charitable.

GREAT PIZZATHE BEST
I love this place, it is my go to for some sexy pizza. Definitely check it out if you’re in the area the breadsticks are the bomb-​diggity.

I am a Chicago comedian who came to Denver to perform on several Sexpot Comedy shows so of course I had to go check out Sexy Pizza too. Major props to Kayvan Khalatbari for creating a kickass pizza place and curating a great addition to the comedy scene in Denver.
This place makes a seriously good slice and has an awesome selection of sodas. The philanthropic nature of this place lets you feel good about eating a whole pizza by yourself and all in all it is just a solid place for some ‘za.

Best. Pizza. Ever.
Late night pizza craving? Close the bar down? If you’re in Cap Hill then Sexy Pizza is definitely the place to be!
At first glance, their individual slices are on the pricy side, but considering each one is the size of your face and with a ton of of unique and fresh toppings, it’s totally worth it!
You can also place an order for a large pizza if you’re not the type to mix and match — this will also save you a ton of money, and will actually be on the cheaper side as far as takeout pizza is concerned! I ordered the largest size once for three very hungry people to share, and we did not even come close to finishing it!

Always love my quick walk to Sexy Pizza for a few slices. Its super reasonable but delicious! Some words of wisdom: Stick to pizza. Tried the eggplant and it wasnt great. But… the pizza is fantastic!
Also love the Boylan’s sodas inside!

Despite being put on hold and then 5 minutes later… forgotten about… I hung up and called again… the gentlemen who answered and assisted was very friendly!
I have had multiple dishes from here and being just moved from NY… its not too bad… still not NY pizza for sure…
the Calzone was BOMB tho, really really suggest getting one of those before anything else!
cheers!

Sexy pizza is sexy. I had two delicious bites of the Fiancé’s meat lovers and am intrigued by the other offerings. I imagine it is just as good sober, but am not in the position to provide that sort of opinion.
Sexy imagery, sexy dining companions, sexy meat on sexy pizza. Sexy. Pizza. Sexy pizza.

MUST READ:
Ordered my pizza @1:30a, was told that delivery wait is about an hour… called around 2:55am to ask if my pizza was on its way… And the chick who answered said «it’s the next one out the door.» This place is dishonest and lies because when my pizza was finally delivered @3:20a (yes? Almost 2 hours later) the deliver guy apologized because our pizza got «mixed up» and they had to remake another one. When the guy delivered our pizza, he had to go back to the restaurant because he forgot our bottled waters. Come on now, Freal? Another lie, our pizza was cold like its been sitting forever.
Do not order from here after midnight-​service sucks.
Not a returning customer and will not recommend to friends…
**not one star, because the food is okay.