Buffy’s Cupcakes

Is this store still open for business? I heard rumors it’s closed, going out of business.
Glad to hear you guys are still open, cause you can’t always believe rumors so I asked.

I was less than impressed by the cupcakes. The red velvet cake by itself was moist, but unfortunately the icing was a bit hard. The buttercream icing has too much sugar and the cream cheese tends to smell like it’s gone bad. I feel that i could have made these exact cupcakes at home. Overall, the only thing worth getting there are the drinks.

Love cupcakes & Buffy’s makes great cupcakes.
First — they are known for their Dr. Pepper cupcake & it’s worth knowing. I’m not a Dr. Pepper drinker myself, but I will agree that this is a great cupcake. I don’t think it tastes exactly like its namesake, but it is a moist and airy cupcake with a yummy frosting, topped by a gum ball & a straw like a drink. Cute & tasty!
The red velvet is my 16 year old cousin’s favorite & for her recent b-​day party, there was a mix up at the bakery where her cake was ordered. Her mom had me go by Buffy’s at the last minute to try to get some red velvet cupcakes. They were sold out of the cupcakes, but had red velvet whoopie cakes — which are essentially two cupcake tops with icing sandwiched between them. Buffy’s makes the best cream cheese icing I’ve ever had. It has a lighter texture than most of the others. So these whoopie pies were a huge hit with my cousin. (The pumpkin cupcake also has that yummy cream cheese frosting.)
The customer service at Buffy’s has always been great. I’ve ordered here multiple times for parties and large events. They will create cupcakes in custom colors to coordinate with your theme. They even offer mini cupcakes which is nice because you can order several flavors for your event & people can try more than one of Buffy’s delicious cupcakes.
I have gone in around noon on Saturday and almost all of the cupcakes will be gone. There is usually a lot of people in the back baking & frosting more cupcakes, but if you don’t place an order in advance on the weekend, you better go early if you want to make sure you get a cupcake!

For about the past year I’ve been going to different cupcake shops in different cities. Was excited to try Buffy’s when I read they were on cupcake wars. It’s a cute little shop on Main St. I had the strawberry cupcake and I was surprised that it wasn’t better than I expected. The cake itself was very moist but did lack flavor. The icing tasted more of a whip cream and buttercream mixture which made it to dense for me. Overall, its a decent cupcake but I’ve had way better.

My newest addiction!
I was so excited to be there on opening day for Buffy’s and couldn’t help but buy one of each flavor they had available at the time. I have since been back buying more. They are a cute shop that any little girl will love. They offer cupcakes, cookies, and lemonade. The only down side I think are I can only get there late in the day most days so my selection is smaller. I am willing to deal with that for fresh cupcakes.
Dr Pepper is the BEST! I don’t even like Dr. Pepper but the cupcakes are amazing.
My hubbys favorite were butter pecan and pumpkin but he is getting excited to try egg nog.
My girls love them all especially Oreo.
Do not pass by without getting a treat,
Now I just need a birthday so we can do a party there. They opened a month too late for my 5 yr old cupcake themed party,

I have had cupcakes from Tulsa to Tokyo and these are among the best. I realize that cupcakes have become trendy but the trend shows no signs of slowing. Buffy’s does everything right to continue this trend making it a mainstay on main street. I suggest the Dr. Pepper, the double chocolate. Really, anything shaped like a cup cake will knock your socks off. Oh, and the frosted cookies are awesome too. If you’re ever in Denison make sure you stop in.

I love love love Buffy’s Cupcakes. The shop is so cute and fun. It’s about time we have something so fun loving and fabulous in this area! The cupcakes are wonderful. It’s awesome that they have seasonal favorites and interesting flavors you could never dream up. (The Dr. Pepper cupcakes have quickly become a local favorite!) Thanks for bringing something great to the area and I wish nothing but success!

I tried pumpkin and red velvet. The red velvet tasted like any other red velvet cupcake from a grocery store. The pumpkin smelled good, but lacked flavor. I was excited to get a specialty shop, sadly I could have made them that good myself. Disappointing!