Sugardaddy’s Sumptuous Sweeties

Confirmed that this location is closed. And a note that shipping is a minimum of $ 10 no matter the size of your order, which was a deal breaker for me — it would have made 4 brownies $ 30. Insanity. You can choose to order online and pickup in Polaris, though, if that is somehow convenient for someone.

they actually get a solid 4/​5, in terms of taste. I’m a big fan, just a little concerned that their portions have gotten noticeably smaller. Hopefully I’m wrong and that was just am isolated incident; they usually have the best cookies/​blondies. That smaller size, however, caused it to dry out MUCH faster.

They have closed a couple of their locations but you can still order online and have them shipped!

Eh I found their brownies super lame. I was down the street craving dessert and was super excited when Unilocal told me I was in close proximity to a highly rated sweet shop. It was a disappointment.
Décor wise this is like the Apple store of bakeries. Lots of glass. Sparse design. Nowhere to sit. A case of brownies and blondies. Nothing else. It was like postmodern dessert world.
The brownie was OK. Mine had sprinkles. It was not worth $ 3.

Love these brownies… I had a brunette with pecans… eyes rolling back in your head good. If you like brownies, you really have to try these!

Boyfriend and his sweet tooth dragged me in here for a dessert first meal. The woman behind the counter was very very helpful and had a huge spiel about all the different brownies and the different ways they serve them up! They don’t throw anything away, but put scraps and leftovers into cheesecakes, truffles, biscotti… you name it and they brownie-​ify it! We settled on splitting a spicey brownie as sundae with vanilla ice cream and caramel sauce. Delish!

Much to my delight … Sugardaddy’s was right across the street from our hotel. The gal working there was super sweet. Answered all of our questions and made suggestions. Everything looked so amazing so it was hard to choose. We enjoyed our treats as a midnight snack and saved some for the next day. So delicious! This place could be dangerous — good thing I live in Detroit.

Sugardaddy’s is a gem. Mark & Tom, the owners, are so nice and welcoming. I visit the downtown and Polaris locations, and the employees are always very nice and helpful.
My hands down favorite is the Fiery Brunette, which is a dark chocolate brownie with chili spice. Yet a close second is the Celebration Blondie, which tastes like birthday cake.
While the individual brownies may be pricey, they are definitely worth it. The Pocket Change (brownie pieces) are an even better buy. If you’re looking to treat yourself, check out Sugardaddy’s.

Sweet tooth attack
since sugar daddy’s was on the way to my car I stopped in to see if I wanted anything. Decided on a cinnamon blondie and celebration blondie. The cinnamon blondie was the closest thing to my current apple pie addiction and it did not disappoint. It was crunchier than I would have liked, but hit all the right notes. The celebration blondie I expected to be like birthday cake. It was too doughy though and the frosting was just sugary not really a distinct flavor. Will definitely try again whenever my chocolate desire returns.

If there is one thing Columbus could use, is some sugar-​free good tasting desserts but I guess in this case it would defy the logic of ‘Sugardaddys’. After all it isn’t ‘Sugarfreedaddys’.
Nonetheless, I am sure there are one or two diabetics in Columbus that would appreciate the treat now and then. Wake up America — Diabetes is prolific!
However, since I am not diabetic, I opted to try the drunken something or other with nuts and chocolate chips. Anyone who can overeat this stuff is stronger than I am because sweet and rich doesn’t begin to explain it. A little piece goes a long way — you know, hips, rear etc.
But I like a good dessert now and then and these cookies are one of those things that should only be eaten as a real treat, or when someone is coming over for dinner and you do not want to make dessert, or when you are giving a gift to someone else. Keeping this stuff around the house can be detrimental to your health.
There has to be something about a food where the first ingredient is light brown sugar and not flour. Please — only indulge in small quantities.

We were downtown anyway so I decided to stop at this location of Sugardaddy’s. If you can go to another shop, I would highly recommend it because parking is a… well you know.
The place was empty and the fellow that worked there was clearly zonked, which is crazy because it was a Sunday and they open at noon on Sunday. strange.
He wasn’t all that excited about us being there but he’s was generally nice. It was my honey’s birthday so he hooked us up with a little birthday candle to go with our quarter-​order of cheesecake.
There’s a discount with the SBB card so be sure to bring it out.

I’ve visited the Gay Street locations a couple times, was this place a bank or something? You enter a white stone lobby through double glass doors, Sugardaddy’s is through another glass door to the left. It feels a little weird for a bakery, I’m not sure what to do with myself when I’m in there. Very fancy. It’s hard to imagine brownies being produced there. It may just be a storefront with brownies brought in? That’s probably what’s going on.
The brownies are really delicious, and that’s what it’s all about. I like the one with mint and I like the spicy one. They sell bags of brownie chunks and that’s what I go for most of the time either as a gift or for myself. I like the bite sized pieces. I have had the brownie sundae one time and it was great, recommended if you visit.
Three stars, Sugardaddy’s is just too expensive for my blood but the place is beautiful, the brownie sundae is awesome, and I like the player piano.

I have to admit — I tried these about a year ago and was not impressed. Maybe it was the fact that I was hot and already in a bad mood or I was not paying attention to the food, but I thought for the longest time that I did not like this place.
I went to get brunch at a restaurant that was close and decided to stop by and try it out again. I am a huge believer in second chances, so I figured why not? Let me just say that I am SO glad I decided to try it again.
I got the blondie with cashews, pecans, almonds and sea salt for my boyfriend, and I got the brownie with walnuts. I got the vanilla icing to go on top. This brownie was SO fresh, moist and chocolate-​y. I seriously loved the saltiness from the walnut and sweetness from the brownie. It worked SO well together. The vanilla icing cut through the deep chocolate to give another layer of flavor. Yum! I did not try the blondie, but my boyfriend said it was amazing. Yum! I am so glad I gave Sugardaddy’s another shot! I love it!

Don’t go here! I had held off for awhile but I gave in and now I want to go back. I can’t go close to place again without thinking about those warm, gooey, and rich goodness. I tried two kinds of Brownies and then bought two other kinds of Brownies. I want to try their Ice Cream, Butter Cream shots, and other goodness that is amassed here.
I chose the Choc. Butter Cream Mint while my wife took the fiery Choc. Brownie. I usually don’t choose mint flavored items so this was out of my usual taste but I loved it. I thought it looked the most like a Whoopie Pie and I wanted to taste some Butter Cream so I gave it a shot. It was nice and fluffy with a superb taste of mint. The mint wasn’t strong and artificial like a Shamrock shake. It was perfect. My wife’s Fiery one was really good except that the Chili, one is suppose to taste in the brownie seemed to be a little weak. Maybe it was the spicy Cilantro sauce still saturating my palette that made it difficult to taste the spice, but I thought it lacked a little. My wife agreed. The Brownie itself was very rich and gooey, but not a buy again for either of us. I still give them 5 stars even if this wasn’t up to par. The Brownie was still great as a Brownie just not quite enough chili.
I also had a chance to taste the Drunken Chunky Blondie and I know I will go back and order this. I was going to order this but I knew I needed to expand my knowledge of this place and order something different. I love the slight taste of Bourbon in the Blondie along with the chunks of chocolate and nuts. I will return for a full taste of this. Pricing is also pretty good as it is $ 3 for Brownie and$.50 for Butter Cream shots. This place is valued well. I am really glad I ran 3 miles this morning or I would feel more guilty about this guilty pleasure.

I just ordered a Christmas gift for my friend’s family from Sugardaddy’s. A really nice presentation of 8 brownies that I think will make a great impression and taste delicious. I’ve stopped in here before for brownies for myself and they have such a great variety. The best part about this trip is that I stopped in right before closing and I was given free leftover brownies to take home!
The peanut butter strawberry blondie was really delicious and different. I could eat quite a few of those.

One of the great people working at the Ohio State University law fair alerted me to Sugardaddy’s. I had actually forgotten Sugardaddy’s was located in Columbus, so had it not been for the tip, I would not have ventured here at all.
Walking in, I was immediately greeted by two smiling employees. The abundance of pinkish hue initially threw me for a loop, but the brownies and blondies roused me from my hypnotic state — and into another. All the treats looked divine, and I didn’t know where to begin.
All blondies and brownies are $ 3.25. One of the employees allowed me to sample the «Tahiti Blonde,» the winning blondie from «Throwdown with Bobby Flay.» This one has toasted golden-​brown cashews, white and dark chocolate chunks, fresh sweetened coconut, and pineapple chunks. I now know why this blondie won the throwdown. Just spot-​on balanced flavors here. The cashews and coconut brought the texture contrasts I crave. Yet it’s the cashews that also keep the sweetness of the coconut and the pineapple in check. And hey, chocolate in a blondie? Yes, please!
But another treat also called my name: the Fiery Brunette. Loaded with chocolate, chipotle chile, and cinnamon, it’s yet another take on the Mexican Hot Chocolate treat — in brownie form. While I didn’t necessarily get a ton of spice from the chipotle, the airiness of this brownie (and even the Tahiti blondie) made every bite enjoyable.
These brownies and blondies may be shaped like hockey pucks, but (thankfully) possess such light, delicate, and smile-​inducing qualities! $ 3.25 may be a bit on the pricey side for me here, but at the very least, it’s worth it for the experience.

Absolute proof that Unilocal Elite Events work wonders. Since Unilocal’s Sweet Serenade I have been utterly addicted to Sugardaddy’s — making a visit at least once a month if not more.
Mark and Tom of Sugardaddy’s are an absolute Dream Team, providing not only exceptional customer service (I’m pretty sure Mark remembers me from the Unilocal Elite Event every time I visit), but the most amazing brownie I have ever tasted. I love to bake, but I won’t touch baking brownies these days. Not when I can just go to Sugardaddy’s instead!
What I love about Sugardaddy’s (besides the customer service, amazing product, beautiful interior) is that they use every part of the brownie! Nothing gets wasted. Crumbs turn into crusts for cheesecakes, edges get turned into pocket change — have you tasted the truffles yet?
My all time favorite is the Dark Berry brownie followed by the Drunken Chunky (blondie). Seriously, TREAT YO SELF and grab some Sugardaddy’s the next time you are downtown (or at Polaris or Easton).

Curiosity brought me out the first time, and I had previously ended that curiosity with a bit of disappointment. I’ll admit that still, the whole blondie craze is lost on me, the saltiness and butteriness is just too much for my taste buds to handle.
Thanks to the Unilocal glam jam, I finally did sample a brownie though and found what I had been missing. YES, brownies! I had some sort of brownie and mint cream sandwich, and the minty sugary sweetness of the cream balanced the salty richness of the brownie, and made a harmonious connection.
It’s still too rich though, I would like to see a smaller size for sale (petit!), I literally cut mine into quarters and one at a time is enough for a sugar rush.
The owner contacted me after the last review, and I give him credit where it’s due, he is willing to stand behind a product that many people crave and love, and I am willing to stand behind him too (or at least his brownies).

*mouth stuffed with brownies* ooh mah gawd dees aw soooooo goooood…
In town visiting my sister and she said she had to take me here. I’m not much of a sweets person (though I do love my cupcakes), but had to check it out if Ellen and Bobby Flay love em!!!
–Yummy brownies and blondies the size of hockey pucks for 3 bucks.
–Cutesy décor. There’s also a little seating area by a piano if you wanted to sit and enjoy your goodies.
–Friendly staff. I loved how as we walked to the counter, the gentleman right away welcomed us as he lifted the lid from the sample tray for us to help ourselves. Now that’s customer service!
–Ordered the caramel, chocolate peanut butter, raspberry chocolate brownies and the chai spiced and cherry almond (seasonal?) blondies. All were good, depending on what flavors you like. Brownies were moist and flavors blended well. My faves would have to be the caramel and cherry almond.
Dear Sugardaddy’s, wouldn’t you like to open up another location in sunny San Diego? *wink wink* :-) Actually, on second thought, you better now because then I’d gain like 100 pounds haha

Dear goodness these brownies are fantastic. Fortunately I was given the opportunity to try a wide variety of Sugardaddy’s specialties and I demand you all go try them for yourself. From the brownie cheesecake to the icing shots, everything I tasted was delish. My personal favorite has to be the brownie biscotti, I would happily eat those daily with or without a cup of coffee. Of course their signature brownies are amazing, every one I sampled (which may be more than a few…) was moist and filled with flavor. There are so many options to choose from, from the raspberry to the brownies doused in liquor, you just can’t go wrong.
The owners, Mark and Tom, are a lively bunch. I’m sure the questions I asked of them were a touch obnoxious, but they were more than happy to spend the time telling me all about their business. My suggestion — if you like the brownie edges, try and enjoy the fantastic biscotti. For a slightly less expensive treat, grab a bag of the edges that they call «loose change». Yes, the brownies may be a touch more expensive, but you won’t be getting this quality out of a box of Betty Crocker. So go ahead, treat yourself, you deserve it!