Big Fat Gyro? Big fat zero… I ordered the Pizzaono’s Big Fat Gyro, which their menu describes as «Pita bread with extra gyro meat, topped with feta cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, banana peppers, black olives and our famous gyro sauce». There were plenty of toppings but hardly any gyro meat! Less meat than what should be on a mini gyro… It seems like they attempted to cover up the lack of meat with an abundance of feta cheese and black olives. Very disappointing. Based on my first(and most likely my last) experience with this establishment, I recommend going elsewhere. Shame on you, Pizzano’s!
Matthew H.
Place rating: 1 Columbus, OH
If you like cheese, then this is the place for you. Just had my first pie from this place and I had really high expectations. The pizza got to my place, I opened he box, and all I saw was cheese. All I tasted was cheese. I would have been better off to just run to Kroger and grab a huge block of Mozzarella. No sauce… hardly any toppings… just…cheese ass far as the eye could see. Cheese ooooozing over the sides. I feel so heavy inside and can’t wait until next January 1 so I can renew my resolution. This pizza alone crushed that dream of eating healthier for an entire year.
Daric K.
Place rating: 1 Columbus, OH
This pizza sucks. No real pork sausage or pep. Who said this was the best pizza a in town? you must be related to the owners because this pizza ain’t even real. get a frozen pizza from Kroger’s and save yourself a few bucks.
Hannah A.
Place rating: 5 East Brunswick, NJ
Best pizza in town! And if you’re in the area give it a try you won’t be disappointed! And the manager was very nice! Yum!
Brian D.
Place rating: 3 New Albany, OH
The pizza gods are a funny lot. Occasionally they just guide you to that pizza place you just haven’t gotten around to trying yet. Rain during rush hour and a standstill on 670 forced me to take the backroads home. Lo and behold, there at the corner of Cassady and Agler, I had a vision — a sign«New York Style Pizza». So, I bookmarked the place with one review(a one star, no less) and hit it up for Tuesday pizza night. I’m not sure what gas stations Craig has been eating at(sadly, this was his only review, so I’ll never know), but I’d like to try them. Pizzano’s tosses out a very respectable pizza. The dough is slightly thicker than most NY pies under the toppings, but has some good chewiness and flavor(no real crisp, or air pockets). The toppings were all quite good, with fresh shrooms, great peps and a sauce that hit some good sweet and tart notes, but finished with a spicy kick. Ratios were spot on. If you’re in a nearby hotel, you won’t be disappointed with this pizza. They are carry-out/delivery only. Oh, and the carry-out is a bit daunting as you have to ring a bell to get into the place(not real welcoming, but a sign of the location, I guess). Anyhow, Pizzano’s is A-OK, I’d definitely have it again. .. now to find those gas stations Craig was talking about.
Craig F.
Place rating: 1 Columbus, OH
Worst Pizza I have ever eaten. The customer service is as bad as the Pizza. I placed an order which was repeated back to me over the phone. I ordered 2 pizzas, one large cheese NY style and one specialty Pizza extra large thin crust. When I picked up the Pizzas, both were NY style. They argued they didn’t hear the thin crust over the phone. As I already stated they repeated my order back before I hung up. I verified with the people in the room my order. Just because a Pizza is cut into wedges doesn’t make it NY style. I’ve had better Pizza from a gas station!