Number One Gyro Shoppe

Columbus, United States

4.3

Closed now

20 reviews

Accepts Credit Cards

Contacts

QR code, vCard

Telephone:
+1 614-272-6244
Website:
www.greekexpressfamily.com
Address:
3591 W Broad St, Columbus, OH, 43228
Hilltop
Categories:
QR code
Download QR Image Download vCard

Map

Streetview

Activate map

Bussiness info

Takes Reservations
No
Delivery
No
Take-out
Yes
Accepts Credit Cards
Yes
Good For
Lunch
Parking
Private Lot
Bike Parking
Yes
Good for Kids
Yes
Good for Groups
No
Attire
Casual
Ambience
Casual
Noise Level
Average
Alcohol
No
Outdoor Seating
Yes
Wi-Fi
No
Has TV
Yes
Waiter Service
No
Caters
Yes

Today

Today 10:30 am – 9:30 pm
Closed now
Local time (Columbus) 01:13 Thursday, 29 May 2025

Business hours

Monday 10:30 am – 9:30 pm
Tuesday 10:30 am – 9:30 pm
Wednesday 10:30 am – 9:30 pm
Thursday 10:30 am – 9:30 pm
Friday 10:30 am – 9:30 pm
Saturday 10:30 am – 9:30 pm
Sunday 11:00 am – 8:00 pm

Related places

You might also like:
1
mi
Kabob Grill
3947 W Broad St (Hilltop)
1
mi
Greek Village Gyros & Donuts
3260 W Broad St (Hilltop)
1.5
mi
Kingro’s
2671 Sullivant Ave (Hilltop)
2.5
mi
Spiros
2958 McKinley Ave
3.3
mi
Jimmy V’s Grill & Pub
1788 W 5th Ave (Grandview Heights)
3.7
mi
Uncle Nick’s Greek Fried Chicken
1333 Northwest Blvd (Grandview Heights)

Nearby

Browse nearby places:
170
ft
Speedway
3605 W Broad St
210
ft
Clepper Abigail DVM
3588 W Broad St
270
ft
Healthy Pets Of Westgate
3588 W Broad St
270
ft
La Popular
3545 W Broad St
270
ft
Queler Andrew M DVM
3588 W Broad St
270
ft
Taylor Hal H Jr DVM
3588 W Broad St

20 reviews of Number One Gyro Shoppe

No registration required
Place rating: 3
Garner, NC
I was not impressed by the gyro’s here. That being said I’ve had gyros all around Europe so I might be more critical of them than the average customer but even for stateside gyro’s that I’ve had this was sub-​par at best. I got the large gyro meal that includes a 9 oz gyro and was a little upset at the fact that they use the same size pita for both the regular and large sizes which makes the gyro essentially a pile of meat and veggies that is too difficult to try to eat traditionally. No bathrooms inside, very small place, but not bad in a pinch I suppose since they have a drive through which I liked.
Place rating: 5
West Jefferson, OH
This is my favorite gyro place. The staff is always friendly, the food is amazing and absolutely great to go in and have a quick meal.
Place rating: 5
Lockbourne, OH
Very reasonably priced, fresh and fast. I usually order the falafel and greek salad with gyro meat! I simply love this place
Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH
Lots of desserts here, none of which I’ve tried. They look good. One day I’ll have some of the baklava. The gyros and fries are consistently good, generous portions, and warm, as in, give it a minute to cool. I don’t like soft drinks, and they substitute a bottle of water for the drink, which I appreciate. Not every place will do that.
Place rating: 4
Galloway, OH
I love the food there, I go like once a week, prices are fair. They recently remodeled the dining room and despite the look of the outside of the building it’s clean and neat on the inside. As a small business owner myself I alway try to patronize family owned establishments. The reason for 4 out of 5 stars is they need to clean the restrooms up.
I’m in the Construction biz I like to wash up before I eat it looks like they don’t clean in there very often.
Place rating: 2
Columbus, OH
Food gets 5⁄5. Customer service seems to be getting worse. Besides the owner and his wife, all the associates here are rude. They hardly greet you and they act like we are bothering them when we come in. Some of the associates, when slow, they stare at you like they want you to leave. If it continues, you’ve lost me as a customer.
Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH
I love Greek food, and this place was on point. Definitely will come back here when I’m back on this side of town.
Place rating: 5
Cable, OH
Absolutely phenomenal food, great service, been going to this place on the reg for prally 15 yrs. Family owned and the same Greek dude has been making the food for as long as I can remember and the food quality represents this.
Place rating: 4
Columbus, OH
I’m not sure why, but this is about the only place I ever get gyros. Makes no since, since I love them here! That being said, I don’t have a lot to compare them to, but I think their gyros are fantastic! Their gyro’s are always packed with meat, lettuce, tomato, onion and their wonderful sauce. Definitely grab an extra napkin! The meat is always tender and delicious. Their fries are seasoned and really good as well. Stop in, you won’t be disappointed!
Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH
This restaurant that has a fast food design decently deserves from my family! We went in after a lunch rush to be greeted with a very kind man (owner). Placed order, received a generous portioned gyro salad and mini gyro, oh and baklava!!! He came out, sat down with a customer and had a friendly talk about hunting. Such wonderful people here and great food!
Place rating: 5
Columbus, OH
Hits the spot every time! The gyro meat is always delicious and tender… never over done. When you open the tin foil the topping are so plentiful they spill out… so do not forget a napkin!
Place rating: 5
Myrtle Beach, SC
This is my favorite restaurant. Their fries are always hot & delicious.#9 is the jumbo gyro w/​fries & drink for 7.59 is the best value & filling
Place rating: 5
Galloway, OH
The #7 (regular size gyro, drink and fries) hits the spot every time, the manager is very friendly, and the prices are worth it. This place is definitely worth checking out if you have a hankering for a gyro.
Place rating: 4
Columbus, OH
This place is great! It’s located in an old Taco Bell. Good gyros, and even better French fries. Cheap eats too
Place rating: 1
Columbus, OH
The few times my boyfriend & I ate her it was very good. We won’t be going there again anytime soon.
Place rating: 4
Columbus, OH
Me: «Hello?»
Voice on the phone: «Hey Mike. It’s me. It’s been a while.»
Me: «Yeah? Is this who I think it is?»
Voice on the phone: «You bet buddy. It’s your Sweet Tooth calling.»
Me: «Crap. What do you want this time?»
Sweet Tooth: «Baklava. Go and get me a piece of that Pecan Baklava I like. You know, the one with the cherry on top. Actually, make that two, you’ve got an Entertainment Book coupon in your car glove box. They’re about a five minute drive from where you are now.»
Me: «Alright, I’m on my way.»
So off I go to get a couple pieces of Baklava. If you haven’t had it before, you are missing out. Crispy filo pastry, leaden with sweet honey and some of those sweet/​crunch/​chewy pecans all rolled together with a Maraschino cherry on top.
Theirs is not homemade but it still really good. They were $ 1.89 each but I got two for that price. They tasted great with coffee by the way.
So if your Sweet Tooth calls you, I’d recommend you check this place out.
Place rating: 5
Hilliard, OH
We absolutely love this place! The food is amazing, the staff is very nice and the prices are good. What more can you ask for?
Place rating: 5
Galloway, OH
Gyros here are consistently very good. I usually come here every couple of weeks to curb my gyro cravings. I have been to several gyro places around town and this restaurant is the best.
The jumbo gyro is massive and a meal unto itself. The mini gyro is a good size for a small lunch. The pita is always soft (not stale), lamb meat is well seasoned (not too much), and they seem to always have the right amount of tzatziki sauce (just to the point that it begins to drip out).
The fries are surprising good, though sometimes not seasoned quite enough.
And I also recommend the pecan baklava!
Place rating: 3
Columbus, OH
I’ll keep this short and sweet — great portions and delicious food! Yes, as stated by all the other Unilocalers, this is an old Taco Bell. Don’t let the outer appearance of the restaurant stop you from enjoying reasonably priced and great tasting food.
I’m not familiar with restaurants on this side of Columbus, so I did a Unilocal search, saw a familiar and reliable Unilocaler’s review and decided to check this place out.
Glad I stopped in and didn’t let the location keep me from missing out on a delicious gyro and great Greek salad. I got the mini combo which was more than enough food for me, which says a lot — I am a big eater.
Good food, great portions, friendly staff, and reasonable prices — my type of place.
Place rating: 5
Hilliard, OH
I haven’t reviewed this place? really? I love this place as I was reminder why I come back here every few months after I have been going on first dates with other gyros.
Why do I love this place? It looks like it shouldn’t be good but it is. The prices are hard to beat. And it reminds me of living in Russia and stopping on the Shawarma stands that sold gyros that would have juice and sauce running down your hands while you walked down the street. The owner is almost always there as well as other family members. The price.
I love the jumbo gyro as it is worth the $ 5 and the fries are spiced just perfect. Don’t judge it for being an old Taco Bell or for not being cute. It is reliable, tasty, and a gem all in one. I will keep dating other gyros but I will come back here more often than not. One Negative– I don’t think they have a customer friendly restroom.